Software
Houzz Logo Print
pennyhal

Need Plant ID Help Please

15 years ago

Today a local nursery that has quite a few succulents had a presentation from a fellow who makes frames for growing succulents. His knowledge of how to grow succulents was appalling. He said that you could put all kinds of plants, flowers, herbs, succulents, together and water them all the same. Anyhow, the nursery gave out a 50% off coupon for succulents if you bought them today. Who could resist that?

Now I promised myself that from now on I would only buy plants with name tags. Not that they are always correctly tagged, but one supplier that they get their plants from does a pretty good job of it. I also decided that I just wanted to grow Crassulas. But I did buy one plant without a tag. I was looking for a plant that was something something "ghost" (forgot to write down the name) and they said that this was it.

{{gwi:677492}}

{{gwi:677494}}

Comments (18)

  • 15 years ago

    looks like a Graptopetalum, probably paraguayense

  • 15 years ago

    Penny, Nice plant! It would be best to wait for flowers to get a positive ID on this (white or yellow-spots or not). It's definitely a Grapto-something. Could be Graptopetalum paraguayense (Ghost Plant), but it looks too thick to me for it to be that. Might be an xGraptosedum.

  • 15 years ago

    Aha! Now I understand my confusion. I looked at my list of plants that I wanted and I was looking for Graptopetalum paraguayense (Ghost Plant) and remembered the "paraguayense" and "ghost" parts of the name, and forgot the "Graptopetalum" part. So I bought this:
    {{gwi:677496}}

    But it wasn't a Graptopetalum. It was labeled a Sedum. I thought it sort of looked like one, but so often when I buy a plant, as it grows it changes it's look quite a lot. So I figured I still would find and buy the Graptopetalum I really wanted. The clerk picked the plant in the first post out for me as the Graptopetalum. It looked different to my untrained eye...paler, color green/whiter, growth seemed different, but no label. Who was I to question the expert?

    So I'll let them grow and see what happens. Lovely colors. Soft gentle growth. Amazing texture. No spikes! No fangs!

  • 15 years ago

    Oh my gosh! So sorry to take up your time. I did a little more computer research and found out on Dave's Garden that the synonym for Graptospealum paraguayense is Sedum weinbergii. Now how crazy is that for a newbie? I think I'll go eat some chocolate.

  • 15 years ago

    Regardless of your confusion (which is no big deal), I always love seeing your plants, Penny. They're beautiful and very nice finds. (I'm always up for more Graptopetalum superbum shots! ;) )

  • 15 years ago

    Penny,

    That's a gross case of mislabeling, but at least they spelled it correctly. As others have noted, it likely has some Graptopetalum in it, and the other half it of might be a Sedum, but then it would probably be a Graptosedum (or a Sedeveria, or something else). It's not a Sedum - I think it's a intergeneric hybrid. There is, I think, no such thing as a Sedum paraguayense, only a Graptopetalum paraguayense (which isn't from Paraguay, but from Mexico).

    One for Colleen, since she asks so nicely, never demanding S'bum shots. And look - I even repotted it for her, too.

    {{gwi:677498}}

    {{gwi:677500}}

  • 15 years ago

    That was great of you to post some super bum photos! They are in such an interesting arrangement with contrast of light to dark colors and leaf shape! I like that fat little guy at about five o'clock. I almost bought another super bum today too as I love everything about that plant...color, shape, growth habit!

    Yes, "Sedum paraguayense" gave me some concern as it sure doesn't show up anywhere in the search engines or nurseries that I've been checking. Glad to know that I'm not totally off base here. But Sedum weinbergii/Graptopetalum paraguayense commonly shows up as synonyms for the same plant. Why that is so, befuddles me.

    The only reason I care about the "name" is so that I know what the growth habit is before I buy the plant! It would be nice to have plants that belong in the Northern Hemisphere so that summer is summer for both me and the plants. It seems my Kiwis are starting a growth spurt. Being from Africa, I guess that's to be expected...but for "Aeonium 'Kiwi'"to also be known "percarneum 'Kiwi',A.haworthii 'Tricolor]" sent my little brain in a tizzy for a minute or two as well.

    The bottom line is that it really doesn't matter which plant I buy. Whatever comes home with me, I keep and nuture.

  • 15 years ago

    Haha, Jeff! Thank you; your superior efforts are not overlooked. Love and envy that plant, I tell ya. And Penny, you lucky duck that you can find it locally, not once but twice! (I probably would have gotten a second one.) I keep looking. Maybe it'll be some freaky find in the dead of winter this year, as I came upon some great things last February when I didn't see them coming.

  • 15 years ago

    You buy enough succulent plants, you learn to expect mislabeling. No--you learn to assume they are mislabeled.

    Nice plants!

  • 15 years ago

    The plot thickens. Today my book, Crassulaceae,
    by Eggli(Ed.) arrived. Now why I need this book, I have no clue. But when I'm done with it, I can donate it to a library I guess.

    It does reference Sedum paraguayense as being the same as Sedum weinbergii/Graptopetalum paraguayense...a rose is a rose is a rose I guess.

    Not only that, I was sitting looking at these plants and figured that I've bought three of the same plant: named, not named, misnamed maybe. So I give up for now. I love the Graptopetalums. I think I'll plant all three (I have some that I haven't photoed) in the same pot and see what happens!

  • 15 years ago

    After you get them all planted, we'd love to see photos. ;)

  • 15 years ago

    The same plant can look radically different depending on growing conditions.

  • 15 years ago

    Penny,

    You went for that big dog of a book? Good on you - I'm sending all of my queries to you. How to differentiate among all of the Kalanchoe fedtschenkoi varieties is at the top of the list.

    Yes, in the nomenclatural history of a plant, you'll often see a genus change names several times. Once upon a time all cactus were 'Cactus engelmannii' for what we now call Opuntia engelmannii (using an example which may not be true, but I think you get my point).

  • 15 years ago

    I'll leave that book to you in my will! I don't have much tolerance for "name confusion." Just a thing that bothers me for some unknown reason. So, hopefully, I'll be able to check names that come from the nursery and know a little bit about the plants I buy without being too much of a pest on this Board...of course that assumes that the nursery puts a name on them to begin with!

    On the other hand...it was a great mystery to watch these unknown characters grow up and totally surprise me as to what they really looked like past the baby stage.

  • 15 years ago

    Ok. Jeff. I took the bait, but the book was no help...which I suspect you already knew. Any description that says "very variable" automatically means "could look like anything."

    But once having my curiosity sparked, I did find what, by my lowly standards, gives the best description of all, a photo. These photos in this link are wonderful for identifing plants. I never knew that there was such a thing as a "field number query" or someone special called a "field collector." Gosh, is anyone on this Forum a field collector?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Kalanchoe fedtschenkoi variegata

  • 15 years ago

    You can also check photos for ID at Desert-tropicals.com, they used to do a reasonable job. It's a good source to start at too, one can search BOTH by botanical name or common name (not so frequent to have both) & it has a section specifically for succulents too.

  • 15 years ago

    Penny,

    I remember the descriptions form Hermann Jacobsen's Handbook of Succulent Plants as being very detailed on five or six varieties / forms.

    I've collected in the field (in fact, just about 800' feet from here) but I suspect you're asking if anyone 'published' has done so. The answer is yes, and he (Cactus Jordi) even has a form of American Southwest Cacti named for him.

  • 15 years ago

    Well, Jeff, I feel very honored that you are willing to share your expertise with us on this forum. Especially with those of us who are so new at this and are poking our way around these plants trying to find what is best...quite often after we've already done things in not such a good way!

    I can just see these field collectors out there in the sun with their hats on, notepads and cameras in hand, on the lookout for cacti and succulents not yet catalogued! With the thousands of plants already documented, it is an amazing and daunting task to have been taken on. Gee, and all I have to do is pick up a book or go on the internet in my nice air-conditioned home to reap the benefits of their efforts. The world is a lot smaller place than I think at times.