Software
Houzz Logo Print
sluice

grafting, early observations, question

17 years ago

First practice experiment, grafted about March 20.

Performed with hunting knife, rubber bands, 2 gallon Pinus strobus understock from local big box, and roadside scions.

Pinus flexilis #1

It looks like much of the scion is toast, but some is still green.

The browning was not gradual, it seemed like all of it showed up within just a few days after grafting. Color has been holding steady since then.

Will the entire thing eventually turn brown, or is it possible for only part of a graft to survive? Thanks.

{{gwi:696881}}

Pinus flexilis #2

similar story

{{gwi:696884}}

Pinus aristata

Looks slightly better than flexilis

{{gwi:696887}}

Comments (14)

  • 17 years ago

    first two got cooked with heat or roots dried out completely or combinations of both.
    aristata looks real good yet. when the buds push, you'll know.

    Dax

  • 17 years ago

    see how the needles are leaning down? you must attempt to re-hydrate - water the hell out of them. if buds are ok after and plants are re-hydrated, they will be ok.

    Dax

  • 17 years ago

    dax knows what he is talking about...

    but i will add some observation ...

    first .... i heard of grafting knives .. and i heard of razor blades .... i never heard of hunting knives ...

    was it sharp enough ...??

    was it sterilized????

    i like the simplicity of buying a box of 100 razor blades in the paint section of the hardware store.. and throwing them out every 5th cut or so.. when they are no longer sharp enough ...

    next.. i didnt see any buds in the pix... its all about whether the bud survives ....

    it isnt good if all the needles fall off.. but it makes a big difference whether the bud remains viable ...

    most grafting is done in early january ... i know you did it when the opportunity arose... my point is that the scion may have been in better shape earlier in the winter ... in other words.. the scion may have been dessicated or burnt.. before you ever cut it off momma ... it might be interesting.. if you drive back by momma.. to see if she has any similar damage ...

    keep on grafting.. you will get it all down.. sooner or later ...

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    From what I can see it looks like your scion might be a bit too big. It's best to graft 1-2 year wood and getting a good matching cut is essential. I don't think you can do that with a hunting knife. Personally I use a grafting knife but I know others that use razor blades. It all depends on what works for you.

    What are you doing for post care? In all actuality more grafts are lost during post care than are ever lost due to grafting technique. The grafts need to "sweat", basically meaning that they need to be in a warm humid environment. You need to avoid temps over 90 F as this will cook the scions, especially spruce.

    I think you have a good start though.

    Bill

  • 17 years ago

    Ok, I'll make sure to keep well hydrated. The knife was sterilized. It seemed sharp enough at the time! My index finger is still recovering... I will try to use something different next time.
    For post care, the grafts are kept covered in clear plastic, either under bags or in totes. It seems to be humid enough, there is almost always condensation showing on the inside of the plastic.
    {{gwi:629087}}

  • 17 years ago

    If you use a good grafting knife or blades I think you will find it safer for you. I am sorry to hear that you were cut. Wrong tool for the job. I included a link below to AM Leonard. They have some inexpensive grafting knives, just don't forget the hard stone. I don't like razor blade but alot of people use them.

    If you get the grafting knife please note that is has one flat side and one beveled side. When you sharpen it never put a bevel on the flat side and only put a long bevel on the other side.

    Post care is a balancing act between humidity and heat. If the humidity gets too high you can get fungus if the heat is too high things will burn up. It just takes a bit of time to figure out what works right for you.

    Good luck,
    Bill

    Here is a link that might be useful: AM Leonard Grafting knife

  • 17 years ago

    Bill...will you please give examples of how and when to harden off these grafts?

    Thanks!
    Barbara

  • 17 years ago

    Barbara,

    Let me see if I can help you. First wait for the buds to break this will be a good indication that the grafts took. After this happens I cut about half of the understock off. You can also start to ween them out of the tents at this point, do this over a few weeks. After you are sure the frosts are over you can put them outside. If you have any extra branches you can cut them off now but leave the half the understock. As a rule the smaller the scion the longer I leave the stick. If it a larger plant and it's growing good go ahead and cut it off just above the union. If you decide to up pot them do it now and add some HollyTone or some Osmocote.

    It is probably a good idea to keep them out of all day sun if you can. The east side of your house should be about perfect.

    That should do it,
    Bill

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks Bill! I'm having trouble keeping my Picea pungens rootstock alive. Assume it is a fungus; soft new growth collapses and eventually the main rootstock stem starts dying too. Funny thing is that the best growing scions have the most diseased rootstock...just my luck. Advice?

    Thanks for your warning about dogs and organic fertilizer. I once fertilized some perennials with organic fert as they were planted in the ground. The dogs were so entranced by that fertilizer smell I don't think a single plant survived. Live and learn!

    Barbara

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Sluice,

    It is hard to make comments when not a part of the actual situation. However, I believe you took the scion wood too close to the end of the grafting season. The parent trees were already waking up.

    Second, you need more light than you get from a house window. Add some shoplights.

    Third, unless the room maintained a temperature below 50 degrees fahrenheit, it was too warm. Maybe try spring grafting outside.

    Fourth, just bag the seedling and graft you don't have to bag the container also.

    I never had much success until I built a grafting structure. However, Pinus strobus is about the easiest conifer to gaft. I would play with that species until I gained some experience.

    For just messing around, an Exacto knife needs no sharpening since blades are cheap and it is easier to control the cuts than using a razor blade. Just a suggestion.

    Bob

  • 17 years ago

    The longer you can leave the grafts in the tenting structure the better. When it gets to a point where the temps are not controllable, that's when it's best to move them out of the tenting chamber. It's just a fact.

    Everybody does it all differently. Thank you for your thoughts Bill.

    Some conifers will simply die if the understocks are removed. I have no examples in mind. It can just happen to any graft really. I got three of the same plants from Bob and one had all the growth on the understock removed, the others had varying amounts of plant material still in-tact. It made sense to me. A shade structure or east location or dappled light from a tree are all sufficient and your grafts should go under one of these for at least one-year which actually turns out to being 1.5 years total (time it takes to gain at least a one-gallon root system) and that's just how I roll. A large graft you made for yourself, etc- though may have no probelm right from the greenhouse to, right into the ground in its' permanent location -- Essentially you already had the gallon amount of roots when you made your graft.

    Spruces need the most light. That's always a tip to convey. Some will tell you these are the most difficult. Personally, FINALLY I'm getting better than 9.5 out of a possible 10 on all grafts and cuttings this year.

    It'll take a few years, and you'll get there. I would definitely recommend a structure such as a greenhouse. As Bob says, it truly changes everything. Sluice my friend, it appears you're a college student grafting in a dorm room. You got it bad man, don't you? Keep up the good work!

    Dax

  • 17 years ago

    You're right that everyone has different methods but Bob is fortunate that he lives in Washington state. If you are a hobby grafter in 5b the option to build a grafting house may not be doable. I have a friend locally that grafts conifers in his basement under grow lights. His doesn't get great take but he is always happy with the results. In the conditions you have you are not going to get the take Bob, or Dax, or I get. It's a fact. You just need to decide what level of success you are willing to accept.

    Like Bob stated, White pines are the easiest and spruce are the hardest. Light has alot to do with it as well and you can provide artificial light the help. You also what to take your scion when they are dormant. Once the buds start to push the scion will be to vigorous to heal the union.

    The one thing I would suggest though is that you take notes and use these as a guide to direct your efforts. I was over the top with notes for years and taught myself how to get the best take based on my conditions. I I started grafting about 12 years ago and currently graft over 1000 plants a year in all type of plants and add about 200-300 new cultivars to my collection each year. On average I get about 80-90%+, higher on white pines and lower on spruce and I am happy with those results. When I started I got considerably less. I just kept at it until I got where I am today.

    Lastly, I don't think I want a plant that I need to keep the understock on. I never leave the undestock on more than a year. You need to decide if this is what you want. There are very few selections that are going to require you maintain the understock.

    The best advice I can offer is that you don't lose all of this great information. Plan your next season now and be ready when it's time to graft. I think you will be happy with the results from this extra effort.

    Bill

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks to all for this excellent advice. It looks like there are many areas where I can improve, and your helpful suggestions have given me plenty to consider!
    I'll post another update after a few weeks.

  • 17 years ago

    I'll add:
    Spruces need the understock kept on for one year while the others: Fir, Pines, dawn redwood, larix, etc- the understock can be completely removed at the time of potting up.(no more chances of imclement weather). The two things that I remember are "june-budding" as that's the time apples are grafted, and generally overall, that's just a great time for conifers and other woody plants to be potted up. Again this is just one of those things. About mid-june the roots have slowed down considerably, the plants are taking a break in all stages of growth and the new growth has had it's chance to flush out completely versus doing so during the later moments of spring.

    Just remember that spruce need the understock kept on from (June to June) and you'll be good to go.

    If you can learn to graft the second through the fourth week of Feb. the light will begin becoming brighter as the conifers callous therefore eliminating factors such as grafting too early which causes extra expense or "TIME" if you view it that way, and it just helps you overall having the sunlight now on your side! So it's a timing issue. Abies and Picea's will appreciate this the most. Overall if you're a skilled grafter, work all winter it really won't matter what time you begin grafting all species. There's just too much to say about perfect conditions. Once you got em, you always get the percentages. A pen and paper is a great investment!

    Like Bill said and it's so very true, those guys in Washingtonstate and Oregon can stick scion after scion on understocks, then simply throw them on the floor under benches and on above benches.. cover them up, walk away and return a month later and everything has taken! It's mind-boggling and it isn't.

    Dax

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting