Software
Houzz Logo Print
prayerrock_gw

Are these real Jades?

16 years ago

I found some "jades" called 'blue waves', 'coral' and 'campfire'..also crassula clavata, 'morgans beauty', 'red devil'.

I am just wondering if these are really jades or another crassula?

Thanks for any help.

Mary

Comments (6)

  • 16 years ago

    The use of the word "Jade" or any other common name is subject to the eye of the beholder, and varies in relative circumstances. Do you know how many different plants claim the name "Hen & Chicks"? Too many to count! Call them "Homer" if you want to, it really has no meaning. That's why we try and use the botanical names if we know them.

  • 16 years ago

    LOL..yes I am aware of this..that is why I am asking about these specific names I have found..there are some great Jade experts here that I think may be able to help me with correct IDs on this and to know if they are really Jades or not.

    Mary

  • 16 years ago

    Campfire may be used as a cultivar name for a number of different plants, but the one I think it's most well-known for is Crassula erosula. Annie's Annuals sells it, and shows how pretty it can be: http://www.anniesannuals.com/plants/plant_display.asp?prodid=2928 Personally, I wouldn't consider it to have the characteristics a "jade plant," but it's still freakin' gorgeous.

    Blue Waves is a Crassula arborescens cultivar, a species normally considered a jade.

    Coral is a known Crassula argentea cultivar, another species normally considered a jade plant, but in a slightly different leaf form.

    The Succulent Garden has each of the latter plants with good pictures: http://www.thesucculentgarden.com.au/crass.html

    ps. Death to common names!

  • 16 years ago

    Whoops, missed the last two.

    Morgan's beauty - probably wouldn't be called a jade.
    Red devil - same

    Every one you mentioned is an awesome plant though, and I wouldn't let that dissuade you from getting any of them. Crassula's such a neat genus.

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Mary!

    The Crassula called "jade" are either Crassula ovata or Crassula arborescens. (As you know, and Dav4vid & unprofessional have commented on already.) Portulacaria afra is sometimes called Baby Jade. Crassula argentea, C. portulacea and C. obliqua (seen at many sites, like the Australian site listed) are old names, synonyms for Crassula ovata (the "Jade Plant").

    Of the ones you listed, the only ones that would be considered "jades" are the 1st 2, 'Blue Wave(s)' & 'Coral'-although Coral is really 'Gollum'-so a misnaming of it. C. 'Blue Waves' seem to be a name used in Australia. It may be the same as one here in the U.S. called 'Blue Bird' which is a cultivar of C. arborescens ssp. undulatifolia.

    The others you named are cultivars of, or different Crassula species than ones considered "jades".

    I hope this has been of some help. :)

  • 16 years ago

    That helps a lot Ro thanks girl:) I had thought about the same but it gets confusing some times with all the names used. I didnt know 'coral' and 'gollum' were the same one either so thanks on that too.

    I am trying to bring more to my jade collection, types I dont have, but i dont want to duplicate one I have by getting the same thing just called a differant name also.

    I would love to get 'blue waves' that looks like an interesting one. I also want to get the 'skinny fingers'. I am trying to find out what is out there..I am really interested in the differant varieties.

    Thanks everyone.
    Mary