Software
Houzz Logo Print
gomanson

Need tips for protecting against animals...

17 years ago

I live in south central Minnesota in a partially wooded area. We have whitetail deer, racoons, rabbits, and (especially numerous in my neighborhood) grey squirrels. Last spring I found the leader on a 12" picea glauca had been nipped off. I also had some spruce seedlings in pots which were nipped off. Last week I brough all my potted trees up near the house and buried them in the garden to protect them from our super cold winters. Later that same day all my oaks were chewed down to nothing :( They had been dormant for weeks back by the woods and nothing touched them, so it's strange they would be eaten when I move them right by the house.

My questions are: Who is the likely culprit for the damage? I know there are deer around, but I've never seen tracks around where my trees are. I've put up chicken wire cages around some of the spruce, fir, and red cedar babies; but there are a lot, and some are in big groups. At what size can I stop protecting them? Do they need to be caged in the summer too? Any tips on cheap/easy/decent-looking cages or cage material?

Comments (9)

  • 17 years ago

    I'd bet a weeks pay it is the deer.Best cure is get a dog and he will keep them away from the area.
    Peter

  • 17 years ago

    Gamekeeper, my Siberian husky's kennel is 4' from where the oaks were nipped! And it's on the "neighborhood" side of my property; where the oaks previously sat (untouched) was right along the woods. So I'm leaning towards rabbits. Furthermore, I have some spruce and red cedar in the woods where the deer have been spotted, and they haven't been bothered, but maybe I've just lucked out there.

  • 17 years ago

    I use tomato cages and for larger beds I use rabbit caging and bamboo stakes. Don't know or can say what or how well the rabbit cage will work, regardless it's cheap. What you really need to do is have cage and b)go to the Dollar Store and buy Irish Spring soap and shave it with a knife all around the perimeter of your plants. That's about the best method available to deter deer. You can even hang the boxes. For larger trees I've seen electrical conduit poles at about chest high pounded in the ground on the East-West or North-South sides of trees. The poles will drive the deer nuts when they bump up against them. They'll even try to eat the poles and are capable to bite chunks out of anything metal. A plant tag about 4mm thick I saw the corner eaten off of once!

    Dax

  • 17 years ago

    When I think of Minnesota I think of Snowshoe Hare but perhaps you have Cottontail Rabbits as well?They might do it.

  • 17 years ago

    i installed a ring of hardware cloth around my smaller conifers/trees over the weekend. needs to be taller than expected snow cover but we usually don't get much. i've seen some people who put tops on them too.

    not really sure if rabbits/voles have a taste for these (pine, sciadopitys, spruce) but i had the hardware cloth anyhow and is an easy preventative. no deer here in suburbia.

    usually remove in spring when the bulbs are coming up, they prefer those i'm sure.

    once they get to a certain caliper probably not an issue, maybe 1"+?

  • 17 years ago

    My guess is squirrels unless you have snow cover now. Although rabbits will eat the things mentioned, they usually hold off on woody plants until after the clovers and grasses are covered (around here, at least). I saw a squirrel nibbling on a pine branch here last week and tips of (mature) spruce branches are laying around. Is your husky outside 24x7?

    tj

  • 17 years ago

    TJ, yes, the dog is 100% outside. He's on a long cable run during the day. The squirrels know his range and they really give him hell, so I assume the bunnies do too. I've also seen some spruce tips lying around. Anyone have a good squirrel recipe?

  • 16 years ago

    on the fruit forum they talk about using "bon bons" for squirrels. it's a 50/50 mixture of peanut butter and plaster of paris. there isn't enough water in the peanut butter to make the PoP set but when the squirrels eat it, it sets in their stomachs, they can't pass it and die. doesn't sound the nicest but is said to have good results. search the fruit forum for bon bon and read all the posts.

    i guess i never took squirrels serious as a conifer threat, thought they only had a sweet tooth for my apples and peaches. we'll see if they climb over the rabbit fencing for a snack.

  • 16 years ago

    My stuff's getting massacred here already. Rabbits are stripping the bark off understocks and seedlings and they are eating my soft pine foliage grafts/seedlings mainly.

    Then there's deer who are eating (anything) really except for spruce. A few of my fir seedlings they've eaten the leader but left the rest... but no spruces are they venturing to eat.

    It's gonna be difficult I see. My plants are large enough I think where now the deer have something to invest in themselves!!

    Dirty bast...

    Dax