Software
Houzz Logo Print
jenniesue_gw

ketchup--is it worth it

19 years ago

Who's made ketchup? It kind of struck me as not worth the effort, but I was looking at june Taylors website and she's selling it for $14 a bottle. So I should hope that means its a whole lot better than heinz.

So then, do you all think its worth the effort and the 25 pounds of tomatoes? Do you know if it keeps well past 1 year?

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago

    At one time I made several batches of ketchup. I still prefer Heinz. To each his own. I can make a nice batch of salsa with 25 lbs. of tomatoes.

  • 19 years ago

    I did a few batches and have never been able to quite get that flavor of Heinz. Instead, I mix it with chopped peppers and onions and call it a 'chunky' ketchup. Really good on a burger!

  • 19 years ago

    Ken, I do the same... chunky everything ... add a few cayenne peppers and call it Chili Sauce. Oh I do use a lot of sugar and spices, being from the South you know.

    And I DO NOT DILUTE THE VINEGAR!!!!!

  • 19 years ago

    The only ketchup I have made is a chipotle ketchup posted by bitterword (linked below). It is awesome. I am NOT a big ketchup fan, but I can eat this straight. However, it probably wouldn't be a big hit with kids.

    Also, I am not an expert in safety issues, so if someone else comments on that - I'll listen!

    Ann

    Here is a link that might be useful: chipotle ketchup

  • 19 years ago

    Yup, some of us like vinegar. Thats one of the main ingredients in make Japanese shushi and California rolls. They adde rise wine vinegar to the cooked rice and also to many of the items that are rolled in it. I have found powdered vinegar too, but its only the flavor and none of the acidity. I still have some 20% vinegar too and use this only if I want a lot of acid with little added water. Ketchup is a good candidate for that. I have found that even though many recipes for sweet pickles call for several pounds of sugar, that if you use Splenda, you can get nearly the same 'taming down' that sugar would do. A 5 pound bag of sugar in a sweet pickle recipe equates to only about a cup of Splenda.. Even the maker never knew this, but because I must avoid most sugar now, Splend has been a godsend and works great in every sweet pickle I make. There are a some mixes made by Ball and Mrs. Wages that also add a small amount of modified food starch (Clear Jel) which helps to control the watery liquid seperation. Its a small enough amount that it doesn't affect the consistancy or safety. Some might think that the Clear Jel would be used to thicken a watery ketchup, but thats not what its for. For ketcup, I remove the seeds and watery centers of meaty plum tomatoes. Then they get run through a Villaware food strainer and you already have the consistancy of a tomato sauce. Cooking it down some will thicken as well adding dried tomato powder, tomato paste, along with other dried items like ground dried onion, garlic, peppers, and of course dried spices.

  • 19 years ago

    I always make catsup, although it sure doesn't taste like Heinz. My 18 year old daughter LOVES the homemade stuff, my future SIL likes Heinz. To each their own. Anyway, I make several batches every year.

    My recipe is at home, I'll post it later if anyone is interested.

    Annie

  • 19 years ago

    ooh, yeah, Annie let's see that recipe

  • 19 years ago

    I made ketchup this year and actually liked it a lot. Everyone in the family ate it without question. Okay, so I served it in Heinz bottles.LOL Mind over matter until ya get used to somesthing new.
    Now that we know we like it, a ketchup pump that fastens on a canning jar would be nice!
    But you asked if it's worth it..hum. For me, As a grower of lots of heirloom tomatoes, yes. I usually have more that I need and this is a good way to use them up...in addition to canning salsa, stewed, plain, juice, tomato/spaghetti sauce, and with zuchinni. But....If you have to buy tomatoes, it would probably depend depend on if you get a good enough price to "experiment"
    I tried several recipes and the least favorite one got mixed with Heinz- which made it acceptable. It could have been used in chili, goolash, meatloaf, soups etc. to keep from wasting it.
    As far as keeping past a year; I don't know why it wouldn't. I have chili sauce and spaghetti sauce that is several years old and they are still as tasty as the day they were canned.
    SOS

  • 19 years ago

    Thats the nice thing about home canning. Many items we make at home laste far longer on the shelf than a store bought product. I do know that I have never refrigerated store bought ketchup, and have never had a problem with it spoiling after opening. If its my recipe, I would definately refrigerate it.

  • 19 years ago

    alighty. I will see how my tomato situation works out. If I have the excess tomoatoes I'll give ketchup, but if push comes to shove I'd rather have sauce.

  • 19 years ago

    I've done home made catsup before using the Joy of Pickling recipe, and its good, but It sure doesn't taste much like Heinz. At this point, with a daughter who considers catsup an entire, essential food group, we buy the #10 cans and rebottle it. That can costs the same as a large bottle but with 4 X the amount.

    I was thinking it might be a whole easier to pop $10 and flavor up 3 x #10 cans with various spices, particularly chipolte, and then re-can it, then try to cook down 100 lbs of tomatoes.