Software
Houzz Logo Print
valereee_gw

Putting It Up With Honey

17 years ago

Does anyone have this book? It's from 1979, so I don't know how reliable any of the low-acid recipes are, but I was wondering about the jam recipes.

Is there any reason -not- to substitute honey for some of the sugar in canning recipes, other than the change in flavor?

Val

Here is a link that might be useful: Putting It Up With Honey

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago

    I don't have this book, but the jams and jellies should be fine safety-wise. Look to see what the author says about setting. With normal sweet preserves (that is using no commercial pectin or commercial pectin but not Pomona) if you use too much honey the jam won't set. There are ratios of honey to sugar depending upon whether the preserve uses commercial pectin or not.

    You might try a search of honey to see what's still here on the forum. There has been some previous discussion of canning with honey. If you don't find what you need and the book doesn't address it, I or others can re-post.

    Carol

  • 17 years ago

    NCHFP says "Light corn syrup or light, mild honey can be used to replace part, but not all, of the sugar. For best results, use tested recipes that specify honey or syrup."

    Dave

    Here is a link that might be useful: Previous discussion on using honey in jam

  • 17 years ago

    Carol, yeah, I searched on honey, and there were a lot of entries, just nothing on this particular book. I was guessing that the recipes themselves in this book could probably be canned safely as long as they didn't include anything like fresh garlic or other low-acid foods. I haven't bought the book (all the copies are used and priced at $70 or more!) but I did find a copy at the library.

    Dave, I saw that discussion -- that was one of the ones that came up when I searched -- but I didn't find any discussions that seemed to actually mention this book. Searching on Putting It Up With Honey brought up 115 entries, but searching on "Putting It Up With Honey" brought up zero.

    Thanks! I'll bring some of the recipes here when the book comes in at the library!

    Val

  • 17 years ago

    Sorry I focused on your question not the book. I thought it would be of help to your question:

    Is there any reason -not- to substitute honey for some of the sugar in canning recipes, other than the change in flavor?

    as some very relevant points are addressed there that would apply regardless of the source of the recipe.

    A book that old likely wouldn't get much discussion here because it is way too outdated and there have been a number of safety guideline revisions since 1979.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    I also thought you were more interested in the preserving issues than the book itself.

    If you decide it meets your particular needs, despite its age, half.com has a copy for $4.00 and one for $8.99.

    Carol

  • 17 years ago

    With low acid, and honey, your looking at a posibilty for a food poinoning if there is enough honey in teh low acid product. Very young kids should never be given honey as its unhealthy due to possible traces of possible bad bacteria. In any case, low acid would require pressure canning to be safe to can, whereas most jellies and jams are not usually low acid to begin with, but if they are, added acid is usually required

  • 17 years ago

    Carol, I was interested in both the book and the question of honey itself. I just didn't want people to think I hadn't done the due diligence of searching on it first. :) Thanks for the pointer to half.com -- I'd looked at Amazon (expensive) and abe.books (no copies listed) but I hadn't tried half.com. I went ahead and ordered the $4.00 copy -- I figure if it doesn't turn out to be a good resource, I'll just resell it.

    Dave, yeah, I'm a little leery of any book that old. With jam and jelly recipes, is it as important that the book be updated? I was figuring most jam and jelly recipes, assuming all the ingredients are low-acid, the changes would be just in the processing? For instance, there could be recipes in that book that call for open-kettle or inversion or whatever. I did a canning demo yesterday and one woman told me she'd never canned, but then said she'd put up apple butter and jelly. I said, "Oh, well then, you've canned." And she said, "No, because with apple butter and jelly you don't need to process it." Eeek. I'm thinking she's using grandma's recipe.

    Ken, that's what I'm wondering about -- whether the honey itself is a problem, and whether that's why we aren't seeing modern recipes using only honey. OTOH, honey is so expensive that possibly the dearth of recipes calling for 100% honey could be attributed to lack of demand for such recipes, just like the dearth of recipes for tomatoes processed in a pressure canner without added acid -- the USDA doesn't think people want to process tomatoes for lengthy periods when instead they can just add acid.

    This question came up because I got a question from someone who tries to avoid refined sugar (she's on a "specific carbohydrate diet" that allows honey and maple syrup but not sugar, I guess) and I couldn't find any modern recipes that called for all honey. Personally I think the flavor of honey would not be what I'd want in my strawberry jam, but maybe it would be okay in, say, a pickled pepper.

    Val

  • 17 years ago

    I was figuring most jam and jelly recipes, assuming all the ingredients are low-acid, the changes would be just in the processing?

    Just a clarification - Jams and jellies (other than fig and a few with added unusual ingredients that require added acid) aren't low-acid. They are considered HIGH acid recipes because the natural pH of the fruits used is quite acidic.

    Ken, that's what I'm wondering about -- whether the honey itself is a problem, and whether that's why we aren't seeing modern recipes using only honey.

    That is the important issue and yes, as discussed in the linked posts and as Ken said, honey is considered a source of potential bacterial and yeast contamination and can even ferment because of the yeast content in it. That is why NCHFP suggests using only the honey tested recipes.

    If you search 'honey' at NCHFP you'll find a great deal of info on its use and associated problems.
    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    arg, yes, just a mistype. Thanks for the pointer to NCHFP!

  • 17 years ago

    Ever price honey at BJ's? Its a 3 pound jar for under $10. Best deal ever! I only use a little in anything I need to make a little sweeter and want the 'sticky' of a sugar compared to a jello texture when using no sugar, and instead artifical sweeteners.