Software
Houzz Logo Print
dgkritch

Helpful Info for new Posters...

18 years ago

In an attempt to help anyone new to GardenWeb I would offer a few suggestions.

1. If no one posts to this thread, it will stay on top!

2. The search engine leaves much to be desired. BUT, there are some ways to use it more effectively.

....a. Use ONE or TWO words to search. You'll have more to read through, but more likely to find what you're looking for.

....b. Try it several different ways. Ex: If you're looking for a Dill Pickle recipe, try "Dill Pickle" first. Then try just "Dill", then maybe try "Dill Recipe", or "Cuke". Even if you end up with more than you need, there's often additional information in the threads.

3. Most everyone here trys to "Keep it Friendly". Sometimes we all have bad days. Be nice, the next might be yours!! LOL

4. There's going to be disagreements. Fact of life. It doesn't mean it's personal, it doesn't mean there's not something to learn from it (maybe unrelated to canning...grin).

5. Don't give up. The purpose of this forum is to share, support, teach and celebrate success solve the dilemas.

Hopefully, this can help everyone be an active part of a wonderful group!!

Deanna

Comments (26)

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks. Lets just hope that people know how to read and be a bit logical in their attempts at finding the right into. Logic isn't just for Vulcans! Friednly is up to a point, and can really low when a lot is repeated, searched (even a TINY amount) and eventually retyped again.

  • 18 years ago

    Yeah, but now it won't stay on the top of the list.....

    :+(

    Oh well.

  • 18 years ago

    I try my best to use the search function when I need something and nobody has ever really scolded me but...sometimes I do a search and receive 500 hits and after reading 100 of them still don't have my answer. And, I have read some nasty responses to other people (will probably get one here) but it would seem to me that it is as easy to write a nice answer as a nasty reprimand. Besides, you don't have to reply if you don't want to. I have read some really, really good info from nice people like Dave, Ken, Carolyn and Trudi. You have helped me more than I can say.
    My thanks go to you.

  • 18 years ago

    apparently no one read number 1

  • 18 years ago

    I sure wish we had a FAQ on this site. I don't know how one goes about getting one added on here.

    Lynn :)

  • 18 years ago

    Please do a search of a 'FAQ', it was just disussed in detail a few weeks ago.. Hardly an easy task, and nearly impossible with many many hours and months to compile.

  • 18 years ago

    Since someone already posted and blew the 'keep it as the first post' idea...

    Thing is, I DID search. I searched on the term 'pressure canners' and came up with over 400 threads -- some with over 100 posts -- that's TENS OF THOUSANDS of posts to wade through. No one expects anyone to read that many posts before asking a question. So I narrowed my search to 'best pressure canner' and came up with 177 threads. On the first page, two looked promising ('which pressure canner should I buy' and 'which pressure canner') and I read both of those threads the whole way through. I was left with a couple of specific questions, so I posted to ask them.

    In the very first response, I got scolded for not searching. I explained that I had searched. I then got scolded for not searching logically. I explained my logic. That led to a generalized rant about illogical, irrational newbies unwilling to make even a tiny effort, on and on.

    I'm thinking you're giving posting advice to the wrong folks!

    (And just FTR, I'm not new to GardenWeb -- July 22 I'll have been on here for 7 years. Just discovered this particular forum.)

  • 18 years ago

    Don't let it bother you one iota. When I tried to explain myself it led to an irrational rant accusing me of complaining. I've used the search feature and ran into the same problems you did. Hundreds of posts on certain subjects and question may never be answered. Just ask your questions and ignore you-know-who. :)

  • 18 years ago

    Okay, I did a search of FAQ. It returned 23 threads, only one of which appears to be about FAQs. The last post is dated 2007. I would like to read the thread. Can someone please give me a little more info about what the thread might have been named?

  • 18 years ago

    I've been visiting this forum for almost 2 years, and the Cooking forum for much longer. I read much more than I post, so while my username doesn't show up very much, I'm certainly not a newbie.

    Since the Search tool is not perfect, perhaps directing the OP to a previous discussion thread would be more helpful than a condescending reply. Veterans at the Cooking forum do this quite frequently... without the scolding.

  • 18 years ago

    Greenhouser, I'm not bothered. I just want to get it straight -- I did search before I asked. And not that it's important to whether or not I searched, but I'm not remotely a newbie to GardenWeb. I daresay I've probably been here longer than anyone on this thread. I've posted a lot, I've searched a lot, and I've helped my share of newbies in various forums.

  • 18 years ago

    valaree I hope you don't mind if I use you as an example to show some tricks with the SE here? I don't mean to single you out, just that yours is the most recent question I dealt with so I can recall its details. Ok?

    First keep in mind there are 2 different search engines here - one for all of GW at the top of the page and one just for this forum at the bottom of the page. BIG difference.

    Second, keep in mind that results are returned based on relevancy so the most relevant posts will always be the first 5-10. If you browse them and find nothing to help, pitch the rest and refine the search terms.

    Third, your primary question was "I want to buy a pressure canner" so a search using the forum specific SE using "buy canner" gets me 296 matches with the first 6 being relevant. Using "buy pressure canner" cuts the total to 198 (dumps all the ones about BWB canners) and now the top 3 are the most relevant and all you have to do is quickly scan them.

    But you are quite right, they still wouldn't have answered your questions about which was the heaviest or the largest but it would have told you that Mirro is the only one without a gauge. ;)

    One other tip- if you Google and add Gardenweb to your search term...."buy pressure canner Gardenweb", look what you get for results. ;)

    Hope this helps some.

    Dave

    suzytwo - excellent suggestion!

    As to the FAQ question - yes it was recently discussed - well 6 months or so back - and there are multiple problems with doing one that all boil down to Administration policies that we have no control over. Trust me - even on the forums that have extensive FAQs sections they don't get used and folks often get offended if you even refer them to the FAQ. The idea sounds good in theory but they don't work in practice unfortunately.

  • 18 years ago

    Deanna - we can always just keep "bumping" it back to the top. ;)

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Dave, please. Teach your grandmother to suck eggs. :)

    Yes, I know how to search a forum vs. the entire GardenWeb. As I've said, I've been using GardenWeb for 7 years now. Click on 'My Page.' You'll see -- 7 years, come next Tuesday. Yes, in my original post I talked about preferring gaugeless, and I noted that made Mirro the only choice in that aspect. I SEARCHED THE FORUM.

    You know, I wasn't bothered by this when it started. Truly, when Ken answered my post with a scold, I figured, "Oh, well! Every forum needs one!" and that Ken was possibly the resident crank. I tried to answer him politely, and when that didn't work I shrugged and talked to someone else. No biggie. Seriously.

    But now I am starting to feel that you are trying to make this somehow my fault. I have said several times now that I searched the forum, which I do know how to do. I used 'best pressure canner' instead of 'buy pressure canner' and if you really want to quibble with that, then there's no reason for us to discuss this any more -- that's the point I went and talked to someone else in my original post, as it became obvious that no amount of explanation on my part was going to make Ken feel I hadn't done something wrong. I searched. I read the posts that came up as most relevant. I had further questions.

    I understand that apparently you all have been having a time here with newbies. Not surprising, since home food preservation seems to be becoming all the rage. I understand that can be frustrating because most people do show up here spouting questions and without bothering to search or do their own research first.

    But even if I had been that person, it wouldn't have been my fault if I were the 1000th such newbie to come in here and start asking questions without realizing there was a search function or knowing how to use it. Yes, people are dumb. But each person is not the cumulative dumbness of all the dummies who came before her. What I mean is, you can only blame a person for their own dumbness. You can't treat the 1000th dummy as if they've done this to you 1000 times. They haven't. They've only done it once. You all, on the other hand, have =experienced= it 1000 times, and here's this one more person and if you have to answer that question ONE MORE TIME you're going to LOSE IT...and that's the point at which you should stop answering newbie questions. Let the almost-newbies answer those questions. Don't even click on the ones with subject lines that make your blood pressure rise. Life's too short.

  • 18 years ago

    If you dont want to help out the new folks please dont read them a new one. Lurked here off and on for years and did not like the answer some new folks got. Give them the link to the ? or dont post. Keep the caps down please. We are here to share, to much info now to wade thur.

    ML

  • 18 years ago

    Mlcon very well put! As a new comer I've only wanted to share to and pick up helpful advice. Not fun being yelled at in caps over and over for no good reason. Thanks for posting!

  • 18 years ago

    But now I am starting to feel that you are trying to make this somehow my fault. I have said several times now that I searched the forum, which I do know how to do. I used 'best pressure canner' instead of 'buy pressure canner' and if you really want to quibble with that, then there's no reason for us to discuss this any more --

    No, no, no. Not my intent at all, honest. Sincere, humble apologies, valereee. Picture me down on my old arthritic knees.

    I know you and that you know how to use the SE here. I just used your post as an example to try to offer some helpful hints to others on how the SE works. Bad idea! Not my first and likely not my last one unfortunately.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Whaaaaaaaa Hooooooooo...this is more fun than eatin melons in the field!!!! Valereeee, Dave was not being mean in any way. He really does try to help and not chastise anyone...newbie or oldee. He was referring to Deannna's first post when she was trying to keep it a one post advise. And that got shot down so fast the ink was still wet. Oh well mixed in with all the shotin I am finding some good advise and really enjoying the hopalaaa. Let'er rip........DT

  • 18 years ago

    And then there is me, who has got beaten down so many times, I figured it was not worth my efforts anymore. It only takes a single rotten apple to spoil the whole bunch.

  • 18 years ago

    Dave, no apology necessary. I should have phrased that paragraph a lot better. I didn't intend to make you feel -you'd- done anything wrong. I know you were just trying to smoothe over the waters. I'm usually not hypersensitive at all. I just felt as if no one was hearing me say, "But I did search! And I know how!"

    Very funny, popcornhill. May you live in interesting times, too. :D

    Ken, I hate the idea anyone would get beaten down by too many newbies. It does tend to happen, and the problem in this particular forum is likely to get a lot worse before it gets better, IMO. Canning is likely to gain popularity for at least several years, and unfortunately few people have in-person resources for mentoring. So they come online and do a google search and up pops Harvest.

  • 18 years ago

    Search?? Did I hear SEARCH?? Hope it will help some here too.

  • 18 years ago

    Another tip (and another bump of the thread ;) is to use the Clippings option and save any really good important info posts. I have so many clippings saved on my page I keep expecting to get a note from admin telling me I have to clean house. But it sure makes it easy to go back and just C&P previous answers to the same question. ;)

    Dave

    PS: I managed to pressure can 1/2 a bushel of green beans and 2 batches of Roasted Tomato & Garlic Soup today without blowing up the house. Kitchen floor is a mess but the house is still standing. ;)

  • 18 years ago

    OK, I'm an "old timer" who never seems to mind answering the same question another time. I find the search feature here to be cumbersome and nearly useless.

    Any newbie wants to ask me for a repost, go ahead, I'm happy to do it.

    I get more tired of the lectures and then I go away for a couple of months until I can become unannoyed, so maybe you shouldn't ask me after all. LOL

    Annie

  • 18 years ago

    hi annie ... haven't seen your words of wisdom around this forum ... figured you had better things to do!!!! ;-)
    Glad you're unannoyed ...
    Kay

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with everything Annie just said!

  • 18 years ago

    Annie is married now, she has much more to do.. right Annie?