Software
Houzz Logo Print
coffeebreak

Leaking issue - Newbie Question

18 years ago

I am new to canning. My only experience is from making a few batches of jam. This is my first time trying to put up fresh Santa Rosa plums. I thought I followed the directions for cold packing them, but I definitely did something wrong. The directions I read said to leave 1/2 inch head room. When I pulled them out of the hot water bath, there was red liquid boiling out of the top of the jars. I must have needed more head room right?

Here are the questions:

- How much room do you need to leave at the top?

- I have heard the ping sound of the seal. If they are sealed, are they safe to store at room temperature?

(They are only plums with a 6 part water, 2 part sugar syrup with them.)

I searched and found a thread last year about a pie filling leaking. Unfortunately, I do not know enough about the ingredients to understand if the advice would be the same.

Thank you for any guidance you can provide!

Comments (32)

  • 18 years ago

    You may have lifted them too soon if they were boiling out of their jars. All boiling should have stopped before lifting them.

  • 18 years ago

    Siphoning can be caused by several things - jars packed too full, not enough head space (as you mention - 1" is better for the larger whole fruits but best to follow the recipe, lids not adjusted properly, removing the jars before the pressure equalizes and the jars seal.

    In a BWB, the usual recommendation I think is after processing time is complete remove the canner lid and let the jars sit in the water 5 minutes before removing them. Siphoning is also much more common with cold pack processing - hot pack is better for several reason. ;)

    Siphoning does not mean that the food is not safe to eat but the food above the liquid may discolor during storage so we use those jars first.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    You need to leave the proper headspace when you can. Never change the headspace called for.
    Leaking is due to siphoning, probably because you didn't let them sit for 5 min. in the canner after processing before removing them.
    Also, be sure to remove as many air bubbles as possible, as that helps, too.
    Raw pack fruit will float more, but I prefer the flavor and texture to a hot pack fruit.
    There are raw pack and hot pack foods. Did you also prick the plums first ? That helps, too, with plums.

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you all! This explains quite a bit. I never saw any mention about letting them sit for 5 min before removing them in the directions. Maybe it is just something everyone knows (except me!) :) Also, I may have packed them too full since I sliced the plums into two large pieces to remove the pits. These are not free stone plums so I figured I better remove the pits. Maybe I shouldn't have?

    I read a bit about both hot and cold pack processing and honestly, I chose cold pack since it sounded a bit easier and it was my first try.

    So... if I can actually accomplish this canning process... anyone have any ideas as to what to do with the canned sliced plums? :)

    I also have a bunch of peaches that I would like to try to can. They made some lovely jam, but I have quite a few more to use. I was planning on removing the skins and pits then slicing them up. Does that sound right or should I leave them in just two pieces? I read that slicing them can affect the texture a bit... but I don't know how much or if it is a bad thing.

    Thanks again for all your help!

  • 18 years ago

    I like sliced peaches to put in my yogurt or smoothies. Unless you plan to serve them as dessert or something, sliced is probably easier. When I make them, they do get a little cooked flavor.

    I think the 5 minute waiting time before removing is new, if I remember what Linda Lou said on another thread. Or maybe it's a new 10 minute waiting time for after pressure canners come back to atmospheric pressure.

    Be sure each jar of plums is sealed before you eat it. Jars with syrup stuck under the lid can come unsealed over time. You want a nice concave lid and a clear tone when struck with a spoon.

    Melissa

  • 18 years ago

    Plum recipes... yum! I use them for cobblers, crumbles, pies and almond upside down cake. Because canned seem to be a bit juicier than fresh the upside down cake sometimes turns out to be an upside down landslide cake, so if you make one make sure you turn it over on a big plate. Messy but oh so good. =)

  • 18 years ago

    Headspace. Cold pack can give that problem too once the jars heat up in the canner and do expand their contents. IT may be better to fill the jars with to hot fruits and a boiling syrup, then cap and process. The 1 inch headspace would be important too. One final note, plums, like amny of the others in the same family tend to oxidize once they are canned. Its a browning of the contents that oxidize and starts on the surface in a few days to few weeks, and can discolor the hwol jar in a few months. Syrup can also contain some loose fruit fibers, and as mentioned can make a seal leak. This happened to me with a single quart jar of peaches that had fermented inside and allowed gasses to escape and enter. By the time it was noticed it was about 8 months later. All the liquid had left and the peaches collapsed and discolored so it was thrown out. I made a batch of Pluot jam and canned peaches and pluots. These ultra sweet fruits have a very short season, so they need to be watched for in stores.

  • 18 years ago

    I find that syphoning happens more often with products that are processed using a syrup solution. I am extra cautious when canning elderberries or grape juice. Sugar syrup gets way above 212 degrees when making candy, so why wouldn't the syrup in the jars get much hotter than boiling water. I wait at least five minutes before I remove the canner lid. I don't have a syphoning problem when canning items like salsa or even meat.

  • 18 years ago

    Melva - thanks for the tips! I will watch those lids closely.

    Whynot - I have heard of an earthquake cake, but an upsidedown landslide cake sounds much better!

    Ksrogers - I appreciate the browning tip. Good to know. yummm pluots! I tried them for the first time a few years ago at a farmers market. They had so many varieties, and all of them tasted very different.

    Shirley - Canned salsa! That is something I have to try someday.

    Thanks for all the information and guidance. It sure is appreciated! Now... I'm off to find more jars!

  • 18 years ago

    When making candy I'm betting the heat source is hotter than 212 degrees. Since water evaporates when it gets hotter than 212 I don't think it can transfer much more than 212 to the syrup in the jars. Then again, I'm no physics major. :)

  • 18 years ago

    Annie's Salsa is one of the most favored recipes here.

    Pluots I see, are yellow, red, and green, or mottled in some form. Some are orange flesh, some red, and some yellow. The other favorite plum is those big black ones that when you pick them up they are almost like water balloons. Bite into one and your going to get a lot of dribbling! Tiny stone inside too.

  • 18 years ago

    How much leakage is too much leakage? I put up cherries last night. I knew I had siphoning because the canning water was colored from the fruit so I waited for the pings. After I heard all 7 I went to bed. This morning I see just how much liquid I lost. Some lost enough that the liquid is lower than the "shoulder" of the jar. Will these be ok or should I reprocess them? My concern is safety not discoloration.

    Also, will the sound of the tapped lid be different because of the lower content level of the jar or is it likely to be because of an improper seal?

    Thanks in advance. Now, back to our regularly scheduled cherry pitting. lol

  • 18 years ago

    If the lids are all concave, they are sealed. The volume of contents inside the jars will affect the sound when you tap the lid with your fingernail.

  • 18 years ago

    Todays 'dimpled center' lids are the perfect way to know the jar is under vacuum. If its not, the dimple is a amall round bump, if its a vacuum inside there is a slightly sunken in round hole.

  • 18 years ago

    If your jar is sealed and doesn't unseal during the period it's sitting on the counter, you don't need to worry about safety. The fruit is fine regardless of how much syrup has siphoned from the jar.

    I do put those jars at the front on the shelf so that I can check the seals periodically and make sure they're consumed first. However, it's not for safety. It's because exposed fruit is likely to oxidize over time, which is unappealing. (And because canned fruit like that bugs me, LOL.)

    All BWB products should be left in the canner after processing (with the lid off) for 5 minutes. There are many home canners who don't have regular contact with Extension services and aren't aware of this regulation.

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Even if canned under commercial conditions oxidation can occur even with no air inside. The oxidizing is from the contents. Ascorbic is a form of vitamin C. Some fruits hold a lot, some dont, some lose it all quickly when dried or handled. Its not a very sour acid on its own, so usually will not affect taste, just color retention longivity when stored, or frozen.

  • 18 years ago

    OK, I'm not exactly a newbie but I have always experienced siphoning. I just pressure canned 7 quarts of tomatoes today and even though I watched the pressure VERY carefully and adjusted my flame whenever I saw the needle trying to go below or above the 10 pound mark, and then I waited actually more than 5 minutes after the pressure said "0" to remove the weight. When I did, there was a little hiss of steam. So I waited 5 mins more, then turned the lid and left it sitting on top so that some steam could escape. Then I lifted my jars out.

    I still did have a little siphoning, it must've happened before I opened the canner as I didn't see anything boiling out of any of the jars. The water in the canner was tinged ever so lightly with the tomato juice. It doesn't appear that it's as bad as I have experienced before. I can't tell yet if any of them look like they've lost liquid, will have to wait till they cool.

    But this question occurred to me about the 1" headspace. Am I making my mistake in this area? The neck of the jar is about 1" tall. So I've been filling my jar just about up to where the "shoulders" of the jar taper into the neck. Is this correct, or does the 1" head space not include the neck of the jar?

  • 18 years ago

    The one inch head-space is from the absolute top of the jar where the lid sets. Can you see the latch on your canner? On my Mirro, I can see where it unlocks, then I know all the pressure is out and I take the weight off. I then turn the cover and wait 5 minutes before removing the jars. All else sounds like you processed everything correctly.

  • 18 years ago

    Syphoning in a pressure canner?? Odd, the water level outside the jars is quite low, and is not close to the mouth of the jars or their lids.

  • 18 years ago

    I just checked my jars and it looks like I've lost about an inch of additional liquid from each jar. The tomato solids rose to the top with liquid in the bottom part of the jar. When I gently shook the jars to try to get the solids to combine with the liquids, I noticed there were two jars where it looked like some of the solids had actually lodged in the top of the jar, like maybe some of it had siphoned out, too.

    My pressure canner is a new Mirro. It closes by lining up the arrows and then twisting the lid down half a turn so that the two handles on the lid are on top of the two handles on the canner. You are supposed to know the pressure is down by the needle of the gauge being on "0".

    The thing that concerns me is that there was still enough pressure to hiss when I started to remove the weight, and it had been ten minutes since the gauge had first shown "0". It wasn't much of a hiss, but I wonder if that was enough to allow the liquid to boil out of the jars??

    Maybe next time I will try leaving a little more than an inch of headspace and waiting longer before I try to remove the weight. I thought maybe I was misunderstanding and that the neck of the jar, where the threads are for the lid, was not to be included in the inch headspace allowance.

  • 18 years ago

    It's only my opinion as a past Mirro owner and now the owner of a Presto, which is very similar... that you're gauge may be off or you didn't give it enough time to cool. When the time is up on my canner load I shut the burner off and remove the canner to a cool burner. I leave it alone until about 5 minutes after the "lock" thing drops. That can be about 15 minutes, sometimes more. The gauge will read zero. Then I remove the weight. I open the canner but leave the jars if I see they're still bubbling inside. If they're not bubbling I lift them out and set them on a towel on the counter. No matter how I've done it I sometimes get a jar that leaked out and is a bit low.

  • 18 years ago

    I had siphoning from jars processed in my pressure canner. I'm new to PCing so I figured it was me goofing up. I did let the canner cool and then flipped the lid and let the jars cool in the canner for another 5 minutes. But the leakage occurred some time before I had opened the canner since I noticed the colored water when I flipped the lid. It was cold packed fruit with a med-syrup. I read in another thread that cold pack in syrup can have some siphoning issues so I didn't really think much about it.

  • 18 years ago

    Doesn't flipping the lid expose the pressure gauge to hot steamy air? That may not be good for it.

    Not tightening the bands snug enough may allow syphoning also - or so I read somewhere.

  • 18 years ago

    I'll be trying again in another few days. I thought I had the jar lids on tight, but maybe I didn't, I'll watch that more carefully next time, and wait longer after cooling down.

    I have wondered, myself, if my gauge was not working right, as it has always seemed to have pressure on it when the gauge reads zero. I'll see if I can find out where to take it to have it tested. I just assumed, with a brand-new canner, everything would be working right.

    My canner doesn't have a lock thing. I wish I had bought one that did.

  • 18 years ago

    Firm but tightness, not wrenching tight for rings. My dad would crank down so hard that you were unable to get the rings to unscrew once cooled. The rubber seal in the lids was almpst down to bare metal. The need is to snug, not really to point where it hurts your hands after screwing a few lids on. Heat also loosens the ring a little, so the cooling should be followed. Finally, if the jars are filled to the required levels, you use a damp cloth or sterile sponge to wipe the sealing rim of the glass. The lids would be sitting in lightly simmering water, and you gently place a lid on and carefully screw on a ring. Because of their design, rings can be accidentially bent into an elipse/oval, which makes for a difficult attacment. View the open part of the ring for roundness. If its oval, gently squeeze the narrow sides together to get it back to a round again.

  • 18 years ago

    My pressure canner is the weighted jiggler kind. I remove the weight before I open the lid so it's safely tucked in the cupboard at that point. :)

  • 18 years ago

    There are so many causes for siphoning of liquid from jars you have to be a canning detective to identify why it's happening. Circumstances differ.

    If you're having problems with liquid loss, you might take a look at the list I linked to below to see which cause (or causes) apply.

    Also, although it's been mentioned previously in discussions of pressure canners, remember the wait time after processing, which can help reduce liquid loss.

    Once you are sure the canner has returned to zero, remove the weight and let the closed canner rest for 10 minutes before opening. If liquid is still bubbling in the jars, wait a few additional minutes before moving them.

    When I remove the weight, I don't lift it directly off. I first shift it gently to be sure there's no pressure remaining. Once I'm sure it's truly at zero I remove the weight and start timing the 10-minute rest.

    I'm not sure I understand the remark about the Mirro not having a lock. All pressure canners lock in one manner or another.

    Carol

    Here is a link that might be useful: Reasons for Liquid Loss from Jars

  • 18 years ago

    OK, let's see if I can clarify what I said about the lack of a lock. My Mirro has a twist-on lid. You line up an arrow on the lid with an arrow on the canner, then twist about half a turn. This lines up the handles on the lid so that they are directly on top of the handles on the canner, and the lid locks down. Greenhouser mentioned that she listened for the lock to drop. I don't have anything like that.

    My weight sits atop a post on the lid. When the needle on the pressure gauge pointed to zero, I waited actually more than 10 minutes before I attempted to remove the weight. This is where the steam began to hiss. If it had been a "robust" hiss, I would've left it on, but since it was rather weak I went ahead and removed the weight. Once the weight was removed and no steam emitting from the post that it sat on, I waited 5 minutes. Then I twisted the lid to unlock, lifted it slightly and left it a little askew so that steam could escape. I waited 5 minutes more and then started removing my jars. At this point, there was some bubbling going on in one or two of the jars, but they didn't emit any further liquid. The water that was in the canner had taken on a slight red color from the tomato juice.

    I did, and always do, wipe off the rim of the jar before placing the flat on, and I always keep boiling water in a bowl in which to soak my flats. I always remove air pockets from the jars before putting on the flat.

    I'm thinking I just didn't wait long enough but I'm still going to try to get my pressure gauge tested.

  • 18 years ago

    Presto has a small aluminium pin that raises slightly to prevent the lid from ACCIDENTIALL being twisted and unlocked. This is a safety device and helps to keep an accidential opening of the cover of the canner from occurring. I do not know any other brands that have this lock pin, but my new Presto 23 quart clearly states what that lttle aluminium pin/plug does. Always have the jars inside raised above the metal bottom. A half inch or more of rack space is very necessary.

  • 18 years ago

    I understand. My old Presto latched the same way.

    Regardless, it sounds like getting the gauge tested is a good idea. It's unfortunate that it's more and more difficult to find places that provide this critical service.

    Do remember once the weight is removed, regardless of how long it's taken to get down to zero, wait an additional 10 minutes before opening the lid. The current processing times are predicated on that assumption.

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Regarding the lock on the Mirro canner, To check the locking latch, I must be at eye level to see between the top and bottom of the handles. There is about a 3/4 inch gap between the top and bottom handles. When it locks, a lever will come down from the top and lock into the bottom handle. The lock releases when the steam is out of the canner. As carol said, gently and very lightly tilt the weight before removing. If there is any hiss at all, leave the weight on. Before you set up your canner, turn the lid upside down. You will see the mechanism that controls the latch. I would ignore the pressure gauge.

  • 18 years ago

    OK, thanks, all of you, for all those tips. I'll look for that latch! I've called the extension agency about checking my gauge, had to leave a voicemail and they have not returned my call. --Ilene