Software
Houzz Logo Print
jra2127

Rotting away

14 years ago

I have never posted. I always find the answers I need by searching, but this time I can't quite find the same situation. I have read about crown rot and southern blight but I am not a seasoned enough gardener to diagnosis the problem.

I have many different beds, but only one with a problem. Just this week I noticed that my 2 eyed orange marmalade's leaves were turning sickly yellow. When I inspected it, all the leaves of 1 eye were rotted off and the second eye beginning to do the same. near it is a Great expectation that is in better shape but it is doing the same. This morning I dug them up. Orange marmalade has no eyes left, just a crown. Great expectations still has both eyes but the petioles are rotting. The roots seem okay on both only the petioles has rot but I don't notice a foul smell. Also, I do not notice any fungal strands on the rot nor do I notice mustard seed sizes scolerotias.

Both hostas were planted in 2010 but neither have been fantastic growers, in fact, my husband thinks I should have renamed great expectations to no expectations. Last year I lost a 4 year old strip tease and dream queen that was relocated in that bed. Looking back I have lost a lot of different plants that I have tryed to grow there. This bed is under a cedar tree. The previous owner loved river rock landscaping and I did not remove all of the river rock, so it is a rocky soil. I have a matching cedar tree rocky bed about 15 ft away that does fantastic.

So what to I do now? Can I save my Great Expecations? How about the orange marmalade crown? I have a new strip tease and stiletto that I just planted about 2 weeks ago, what should I do with them? And finally what do I do about the bed? Any advise would be appreciated!

I am trying to post pictures

Comments (8)

  • 14 years ago

    It's possible that you could save the Orange Marmalade and GE, but it's not easy and takes time. You might be better off tossing them and buying new ones.

    If you want to try to save them take them off all of the soft rotted parts and give the crown a bath in a 10% bleach solution. Then pot them up in a soiless sterile potting mix, keep them in containers in full shade until the fall and then replant them then.

    As for the entire bed. I don't know how much root competition you are dealing with, but the real issue is how well does the soil in that bed drain. To test drainage, dig a hole about 1 foot deep. Fill with water and allow it to drain completely. Immediately refill the pit and measure the depth of the water with a ruler. 15 minutes later, measure the drop in water in inches, and multiply by 4 to calculate how much water drains in an hour.

    Less than 1 inch per hour is poor drainage, indicating the site may stay wet for periods during the year. Plants that don't tolerate poor drainage will suffer. 1 to 6 inches of drainage per hour is desirable. Soils that drain faster than 6 inches per hour have excessive drainage.

    If it's not a drainage problem, then you are probable dealing with root competition from the cedars.

    Steve

    Here is a link that might be useful: Checking your soil's drainage

  • 14 years ago

    I think I have figured out the pictures

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pictures

  • 14 years ago

    I will try the drainage. I would be suprised if that is it just because this is an old rock landscaped bed with lots of rock still in it. I thought that the rock would help drainage, but what to I know. I also have thought about the root competition, but do you think I would have a problem with one cedar tree and not another? The garden around the other cedar does very well. But then I have been watering these guys more because I was concerned that there was a problem with the cedar roots.

  • 14 years ago

    Just copy the HTML code into the message box to post the pictures here.

    I can see it's a drainage and a soil compaction problem from this picture. If you are going to plant in this area you must have soil that the Hosta roots can grown in. What might be better is to plant your Hosta in either pots or root control bags called spin out bags. You aren't going to grow very successfully without better soil.

    Steve

    Here is a link that might be useful: Spin out bags

  • 14 years ago

    I had the problem a couple of years ago on a potted u. albomarginata. I just washed all the soil and rot off, tossed the soil and repotted it. I'm in the city, so I have lots of chlorine in my city water. If you don't have the chlorine, use the bleach solution Steve suggests.

    My u.albomarginata has grown very well since then. I put it in two pots and both are full this year.

    I'm not sure, but the pathogen may survive in your soil. I would pot the hosta until they recover. That will give you time to figure out of the rot problem is attacking other hosta in that bed before you plant them back there. Make sure you use a light potting soil that drains well. Put the pot on pot feet or something that will make sure it drains fully. (I make my own potting soil, but I think Steve says he uses Miracle Grow, note - not MG moisture control potting soil.)

    Good luck.

    bkay

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks Steve. I would rather it be a compaction problem then something above my head. At least this way I have some direction for solving the problem.

  • 14 years ago

    You might want to read this thread in the Hosta Seed Growers Forum about blight or crown rot. One fix is to douse the site with a fungicide.
    Bernd

    Here is a link that might be useful: how to fight blight

  • 14 years ago

    what is that tree??

    the soil is dead dry.. key word DEAD ... and i suspect the tree as a part of the problem ...

    mulberry????

    increase water significantly ...

    i have had 9 GE.. and they all died.. welcome to the club.. just throw it away.. and quit fixating on it ... there are only 4 peeps in the continental US [make that north america] that can grow it well.. and 3 of them are here .. its CARP ...

    ken