Software
Houzz Logo Print
momtothree_gw

How many revisions is normal after first initial plan?

18 years ago

We got our first floor plan from the architect in the middle of June. We made some revisions after seeing it. It took them a month to get the revisions completed. Several changes were moving doors, reworking bathroom layouts and adding a bar in the gameroom. The bigger revisions were shrinking the hallways from 60" to 52" and making the utility room a separate room all by itself, rather than having to pass through it when coming in from the garage. We are using a firm that has several architects. We were shown a copy of our e-mails that we sent to the lady and she responded in red as she made the changes. Well, at the top of the e-mail to the owner of the firm, she said any further changes would have to be ok'd with her. That our changes were very time consuming. She's getting paid to do this. We are very disappointed and let down by her. One of the areas we asked to be reworked was the master bedroom/bath area. Her solution was adding a separate toilet, therefore adding to the square footage. Then she placed a half-wall and desk as soon as you come into the master. We think she threw this together and did not spend much time on it at all. How many revisions are usually made or allowed before you get the perfect plan? What is normal? I e-mailed the owner last night stating our disappointment with the architect. We love the lay-out, just not how some areas are laid out. We're almost at the point of firing them. Please help!! We're using a firm out of Sugarland. I may need some suggestions of other people to use.

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    Momtothree: We have gone through 4 revisions, so far, and will be getting our working drawings very soon - the ones that supposedly will be used to apply for a building permit. Not sure if this is "normal" but my DH and I spend hours and hours going over the plans, make lists of what needs to be changed and then have at least a 2-hour conference call going over all the stuff. We are doing this long distance. Since we haven't seen the last set of revisions yet it's hard to know if this will be the last round. That being said, I have to say that our designer has been very good (and patient)about dealing with our changes and additions - we also had a major revision in the master bedroom/bath area and he worked with us until we got it perfect, and he has said to us more than once that, "it's your house, I want you to love it" - so with that insight is it possible to work with another architect in the firm who will work with you to make it the way you want it? Are you way into the project and money invested that it would be impossible to get another architect? We really like our guy and couldn't possibly think of working with someone who was difficult. I would recommend him to you but he lives in Hawaii! Good luck and I hope you can find someone else in the firm that will be more accommodating.

  • 18 years ago

    I solved this problem by refusing to do any more designing by email. (Yes, I predate email by quite a few years). Like in the old days, if people want me to design their home they have to sit down in front of the drawings with me so we can work it out together.

  • 18 years ago

    This is really not as bad as it sounds but we are our 3rd designer. Not design, not revision, designer. The first didn't work out due to some personality conflicts.

    Our second was a very nice helpful person, who was patient and easy to work with. We almost got what we wanted(and many of you helped with our floor plan), but then it all fell apart on the elevation. What we wanted was just really beyond the scope of what she knew how to do. It was really turning into a waste of time and effort for both of us.

    This third designer has been awesome. He's extremely talented, very patient and has been a real pleasure to work with. He managed to nail the elevation with a pen and some trace paper in 10 minutes sitting in front of us. I spent months with the other designer and still never got there.

    We are so happy with the new design and elevation. I never felt that way about the other designs. It makes the nearly a year of frustration(and money) dealing with the other designers all worth it.

    My opinion, keep after it until you get a product you love. If you can't get the love from this one, move on. It's worth it.

  • 18 years ago

    I am amazed that here, most of the times, the clients like our designs and we hardly have to change anything (that happend mostly in commercial design). My boss also have some clients that can not make up their mind and we change everything until they are satisfied.
    Sometimes they call me directly and I change whatever they need, and email the changes to them with copy to my boss. That is what we do here.
    We were helping a lady that wanted an addition and we had like six meetings (just for a porch but it was hard because she wanted a traditional stone porch in a contemporary house so we had to be careful) and we worked with her as may times as she wanted until the design was good. She is happy now.

  • 18 years ago

    marthaelena- You don't happen to be located in Houston are you? I've looked at several plans you critiqued and always thought your opinions on floor plans were right on. I hope we can find someone that will help us. We have two areas on our plan that need major help. One being the layout of the master bedroom/bath and the other is the foyer that we think is too big.

  • 18 years ago

    Sorry Momtothree,
    Capital of Illinois here (central illinois)

    I hope you find a good Architect.
    Good luck!!!

  • 18 years ago

    Momtothree,

    We have had the same problems with our architect. We have paid for revisions 3 times, yet it still isn't what I have asked for. It is getting very pricey asking for changes, but then not getting what I want. Our architect charges by the hour. Our first meeting was in person, but since then it has been over the phone or through e-mail.

    I've had such good suggestions from this group! You might try posting your floor plan and asking suggestions. They thought of things I never would have thought of until it was too late.

    I'm still in the revision stage for small things. We broke ground today! Yippeee!!! It is raining now...Bummer...Hopefully it won't rain too much.

    Good luck and don't give up until you have what you want!

    Michelle

  • 18 years ago

    Oh my goodness. We went back and forth with our architect, numerous, numerous times making so many revisions. It was about a 4 month process to get the set of construction drawings and probably 30 different revisions sets. It was never a problem with my architect and he was always very responsive and timely with the revisions. I usually only had to wait a couple of days for new revisions. BTW, I worked remotely with him in Minneapolis, so much of it was done by email and only 4-5 face to face meetings.

  • 18 years ago

    The face to face meetings are where the architect gets to know what you like and adjusts his thinking to accommodate it. It also allows the owners to be tactfully shown why some of their ideas are not as good as they might have initially seemed without taking the time to actually revise the drawing and send it by email.

    Good design is always a collaborative process. Putting obstacles to clear communication between the parties involved should be avoided whenever possible.

  • 18 years ago

    marthaelena,
    So you are in Springpatch? I did my residency there. We are going to build outside of STL in Edwardsville. Do you know any good architects in this area? I interviewed 4 and decided on one but haven't signed anything yet, so if there's a hidden gem down here please let me know.

  • 18 years ago

    mimi,
    Yes I am!
    I know someone but I want to ask my coworkers, and get back at you. You are just about 1 hour and 20 minutes from here!
    Good luck on your selection

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!