Software
Houzz Logo Print
lafdr

How is the concrete/ elevation measured?

19 years ago

We built a garage and 2 bedroom addition attached to our existing home. The 3 contractors we had give bids all said that it was tight,but there was room to build the garage with a 9 foot instead of 8 foot ceiling, and the existing canales would drain onto the new garage roof. When the concrete was poured, I was surprised by how tall the floor and ??stem walls looked, and was reassured by the GC that they do seem to stick up like that it is normal. I said as long as the canales are fine. (Our 2 main project limitations were the height of the existing canales, and a 10 foot side yard setback we planned to build right up to, and these were pointed out to all contractors who bid)

Then after the framing is done the GC says there is a little problem he needs to figure out, the roof of the addition is above the canales, which are now in the space between the roof and ceiling. After researching and checking code, he said it was no problem to put roof drains in through the garage between ceiling and roof, exiting on the side of the garage. He never mentioned an extra charge, or how this mistake was made. And I was too busy reading about roof drains, and concerned about if they would leak to ask why this happened.

The plans specify depth of concrete and footers, but the original ground was not level and dirt was moved and compacted. The plans say 9 foot ceiling, then I was told it would be 2 more feet for roof etc. The ceiling height is correct, and I am assuming the roof the expected distance above too. But it seems to me that the dirt was built up more than I expected so the total height is much more than expected above grade.

The plans show the existing home and addition to be at the same height at the top of the parapet wall. They are built with the addition over a foot taller on the outside.

The GC is now saying that it will cost us 1100$ more for the roof drains because the plans were poorly done and did not take the canales into account. He says they (the concrete guys) set the elevation of the concrete so the floor between the addition and existing home would be the same, which it is for the bedrooms.

The garage however where there is the roof drain problem is built attached to the existing house with a shared wall, but you must walk out the front door and down a step to get to it. Since there is no connection between the garage and bedrooms, or garage and house the floor did not need to match.

I think what happened is that they adjusted the concrete height for the bedrooms, and did the same elevation for the garage, forgetting that they needed to be sure to plan the distance to the canales for the garage. (Or the concrete guys were probably never told to be sure to set the height to the canales)

Our written plans do not specifically mention the issue with the canales, but this was specifically mentioned to the GC the first time we met, and in subsequent conversations. In fact he and the other contractors we had spoken with all said we had room to fit a 9 foot ceiling instead of just 8 under the canale limitation. By the time it was discovered the entire garage walls and trusses had been installed and could not be lowered to the 8 foot ceiling height without a huge redo.

I realize now, and would do it so much more informed if I ever do this again.....that some of these problems/miscommunications are because some details on the plans were vague or left out, and we had a verbal agreement with the GC as well as in writing with him that the addition would match the style of the existing and we thought that was enough. But his framers went off the plans that had not been changed, and said there boss never told them of the details (also wood beams and tongue and groove that had to be added after the fact, exposed wood over and around the windows etc)

If we specifically discussed the canale height as an issue before the job, and several times after, who is responsible for the added cost of roof drains? We clearly mentioned it multiple times since those were the 2 issues we knew could not be changed. (We had even tried to get a setback variance and were denied.) If the GC had been more closely supervising the concrete and measured the distance to the canale before the concrete was poured, or the framers to stop the roof being built over the canales, he would have caught the errors before they reached a point of no return, and the retrofititng and roof drains could have been avoided. Admittedly the extra height of the addition is more visually interesting, but not sure I would have chosen to pay 1100 extra.

I know errors and changes from the original plans happen. It just seems to me that this was a preventable error, and it was not the homeowners responsibility to catch it.

So who should pay for it? I have asked him to show us on the plans where the information is or is not that made this happen, since he is blaming it on the bad plans we provided. It seems to me that since we paid a licensed design company for the plans that were reviewed by their architect (not involved in the building process, since it was supposed to be relatively straightforward)and supposed to be up to code/buildable we believed they were adequate. The contractor knew the canale was the main issue on the south side of the addition. Shouldn't he have caught the mistake on the plans, or at least as it was being built?

I admit I am being way more nitpicky about this 1100$ than I should be. I am worn down by being months over schedule, and the other issues I have posted. I just can't help thinking about how many hours I have to work to make that 1100$, and maybe it should come out of his profit instead of being added to my expense. He did not put in the hours at the crucial times to review the plans from a professional/experienced perspective to catch these omissions, and was not having the attention to details that would have caught these problems as they were happening either. Shouldn't the GC have known to put the details on the working copy of the plans so there would not be these kinds of confusions? We know now, shouldn't he have known from his past experience? I know he has built at least a few houses completely as well as major remodels, and has been doing this for years. Did he not know all details should be on the working plans? Or was he just too busy or non detail oriented to think about it.

I knew it was not enough to have just a verbal agreement, and we do have details in writing from the GC, I did not know that all details should be on the plans so no one can say they were never told something about the build. (And then I have no way of knowing if the GC did tell them or their boss and they forgot, or if the GC never told them and later blamed them for the omission. (Since I don't see the details of what they are paid I don't know what work required change orders between them)

I am usually a very nice and understanding person, really. So it is a weird position to feel distrusting and taken advantage of which makes me doubt my judgement as to what is the right thing.

What do you think? Thanks for any replies.

Thanks for your thoughts.

Comments (4)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I didn't read your entire post because it is so long.

    However, in my area a surveyor comes to measure the exact elevation after the compacting is done and after the hole for the footers has been dug. They put string in that measures the entire elevation on all 4 corners, etc. This way everyone knows what the starting point(elevation) is in relation to the land and other structures.

    Then the builder knows what the expected height of the new structure is, and where it falls in with other structures, other things on the property (canals, etc) - all which should have had their elevations measured prior so that drainage is appropriate, height limits are followed, etc.

    Sounds like your builder made a mistake.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Elevations concerning grades generally aren't on the plans and are an individual element onsite.The responsibilty is typically done by surveyors teamed with the excavating and foundation contractors.Often times elevations are changed to make things such as the septic work,run-offs from the house, or setback changes.

    The bottom line is that the builder/g.c.is responsible for all subs and actions on a build.Communication is a huge factor and many mistakes are made from a lack of, misunderstandings,or even ego's from trades people who "have always done it this way".

    Your builder has been willing to address this problem you have and has come up with a solution.Even though it is his ordeal in the long run, maybe you can work it out by splittng the $1100.00.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Re: "After researching and checking code, he said it was no problem to put roof drains in through the garage between ceiling and roof, exiting on the side of the garage. "

    I would want to understand this in more detail. What type drain is it, what type filtering is in place to prevent clogging from leaves, etc, what is the result when the screen filter clogs up, etc?

    If you communicated to your GC in the same way you wrote this letter I too would have been glassy-eyed & most likely thinking about 20 other things by the time you finished. Don't take this the wrong way but there are a lot of people that use so many words to describe a situation that the real message gets lost.

    Since you like the looks better & if the drain solution is an appropriate one I'd suggest you pay the $1,100 or do as sierra said & offer to pay 1/2.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you all for your honest feedback.

    Sorry it was SO long,I was upset when I wrote it. I hoped people not interested in detail could skim/skip. I will take the time to edit future posts for everyone else's sanity :)

    The roof drains attach into "canale" openings. Copper/ squared "scuppers" (?) enter the parapet wall, then becoming round and connect to fat PVC. They were installed by a plumber, who pressure tested after he installed. Yes a grill fits over the roof opening and needs to be kept clear. They are less ideal than an open canale due to increased clog risk in the 20+ feet of pvc in the roof. I believe we get a roof top swimming pool, and/ or leaks if they clog :) (We hope to check/clear regularly.)

    They are installed correctly, they just were not expected. Somewhere something was missed or changed so they were needed.