Software
Houzz Logo Print
mccall_gw

Solid Cherry table or not?

18 years ago

I can get a hardwood Cherry finish table for about $400 Or I can get a similiar solid cherry table for about $1200. the question is is it worth the difference?

I would not want vaneered in either case.

What is the real advantage of solid cherry? any thoughts

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    Depends on the Finisher! And the type of finish.

    There are pigmented finishes (think paint) and aniline dyed finishes. Cherry is beautiful when done with aniline dyes, and shellac midcoats. Its one of the best and prettiest woods in my opinion when done right by a master finisher. Deep, rich hues with dark grain lines, and if you happen to get some flame cherry (also known as mottled or curly) then you have a spectacular piece.

    However, if the finish is done in a pigmented stain, then it really doesn't matter much. That is a covering stain (used by the vast majority of production furniture makers) that is fast, easy, covers flaws and pretty much chokes off the beauty of the wood.

    I have at my store right now a hand-scraped, double pedestal solid cherry table that we made for a customer in 1995 in aniline-dyed, shellac-coated cherry. It was gorgeous. My customer , who is 200 miles away, ironed a table cloth directly on the table top this past Thanksgiving and it destroyed the topcoat (intense heat and steam are bad combinations for finishes). She was very upset and contacted a local antique store in Penn. for a good refinish person. Took it to him, paid $600, and the clueless refinisher took a belt sander to the top, then put on a pigmented finish similar to most production finishes. She was ill when she got the table back as the difference between the original finish on the base and the new top was black and white. Finally, she called me and though the cabinentmaker who made her table has passed away, I have a master finisher in Ohio who will re-scrape the top, and restore that original aniline-dye/shellac finish...though its going to cost her another $ 1,000.

    Clear cherry is another way to go. It can be one of the most handsome finishes if left in a near natural state and allowed to be in direct sunlight. Cherry will 'ruby-up' (that is, turn red) and darken when bathed in sunlight, and that makes for a gorgeous finish in about five years time.
    For that same reason however, it can make a poor flooring choice as areas covered by rugs, furniture and the like will be noticeably lighter when the obstruction is moved at a later time.

    Cherry is a hardwood, but a 'softer' hardwood. Done right - its tremendous. Done so-so, its just another wood.

    Duane Collie

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with this.
    Cherry is a hardwood, but a 'softer' hardwood. Done right - its tremendous. Done so-so, its just another wood.

    Cherry is one of my favorite woods to work. But the price has escalated in the past 20 years to make it one of the most costly of domestic production woods.

    In addition, to develop the patina, the oatmeal colored sapwood must be removed or hidden, further contributing to the waste / cost factor.

    Be aware that some manufacturers bleach the color out of cherry, then start over with a coloring process they can control. If this is the case, I'd pass.

  • 18 years ago

    hardwood Cherry finish: = a cheaper wood stained to resemble cherry. There's no telling what the wood is, and if you dent or scratch it you will see the color of the wood, which is unlikely to be the same as real cherry.

    Solid Cherry = solid cherry. Duane and bob have pointed out the difference between a good finish and bad finish, but it seems to me that the choice is more fundamental than that.

    In theory, the less expensive table could have identical construction and finish to the solid cherry table, and be cheaper only because of the material price difference, but in practice you tend to get better construction when you pay more for furniture.

    Good luck,

    Paul Downs

  • 18 years ago

    The advantages of real cherry IMO are strictly aesthetic. Cherry is not as hard as maple or oak, and cherry has more dramatic color shifts when exposed to sunlight.

    If your table has a leaf, if the leaf is stored it will not change color as quickly as the rest of the table. If you keep a vase or centerpiece on the table you'll get a "tan line" in the covered space.

    All this said, many people find cherry more attractive than other woods that are colored to look like cherry. I have cherry bookcases, dark cherry kitchen cabinets, and Brazilian cherry floors (but a maple dining table.)