Software
Houzz Logo Print
wakieone

Dawgone it! Researching again!?

19 years ago

Greetings, floor folks!

I have a combination question/rant for your appraisal and comments.

Two years ago, we had a glue down installation of Mirage engineered flooring over our concrete subfoor dining/living room.

It was a brain strain to research for a variety of reasons- not least of which were:

1. Will there be moisture issues?

2. Will they be cold?

3. Will they hold up to high traffic and dog nails?

4. Will there be serious differences in maintenance, vs. carpeting?

5. Can we afford it, and is there a good return during resale?

6. Is there really a difference in quality relative to price of products?

Turns out, the floors are fab...and for those of you with pets who transition from carpet to solid surface floors, wait 'til you see the giant tumbleweeds of hair and dust that used to cling to your carpet. Yikes! I do find myself cleaning the hardwood floors more often, because I can see the dirt...but I *think* that's a good thing.

It's time to do the bedroom now, and here is where the rant comes in-

The Mirage gurus have decided the consumer is better served by distributors it controls, along with price and availablity information. No way now to compare Mirage product and price with whatever else is available, unless you chit chat with their selected distributors. I don't mind talking to guys, but I'd like to at least try to know what I'm talking about (and what they are talking about/trying to sell) before I go there. Now I can't do that.

I'm worried enough about putting a hard surface flooring in our bedroom, which is unfortunately over our garage (is cold and hard a good choice for the loveshack?...hmm), but I thought I could hedge my bet using a product from a manufacturer I'd had a good experience with-and reassure myself that installing a realtively expensive hardwood product with our beer budget, and then covering them up with area rugs is a totally reasonable and rational choice to make.

So my comments are two-fold:

Mirage is so concerned about holding itself out as an upscale product, that it may have just taken itself out of the running!

AND

Am I really going to have to start from square one now, and rethink hardwood vs. laminate (I'm told it has better insulation properties than straight-up hardwood) vs. (yawn) carpeting again?

I think I need a nap. :)

Comments (3)

  • 19 years ago

    Laminate and hardwood flooring are not insulating products, however certain underlayments for floating floor systems do contain insulating properties.

    If coldness from your garage is a consideration, insulate between the joists under your bedroom between your garage and you bedroom, weatherproof your bedroom and garage from drafts, and use an underlayment with insulating properties (such as Floor Muffler which adds R-value to aid in insulation) in combination with use of a floating hardwood or laminate flooring system.

    Another option or addition would be to use insulating floor panels.

    It is true carpet will feel warmer than hardwood or laminate flooring, and it also has insulating properties.

    You also have the option of Radiant In Floor Heating for the coldness concerns.

  • 19 years ago

    Sorry about the lag time thanking you for your response, floor guy. DH has just the kind of weather the doctor ordered to impress upon me how *very* cold our floors can be :"
    I haven't given up on laminate yet-but just to cover my bases, if I do eventually cave and give in to carpet, I wonder if you have any opinion on Smartstrand products for durability/stain resistance vs. Stainmaster.
    This installation is in our upstairs bedroom over our garage, as earlier mentioned, and I'll have to run whatever we choose into the master B/R closet, hall closet, and in front of our double sinks (thus the additional interest in stain management.)
    I suggested a compromise laminate/carpet install, but the prevailing opinion is this "chops up" the room from an esthetic point of view.
    Now I remember why I keep putting off doing something about this!

  • 19 years ago

    Well I don't give opinion on aesthetics, decoration, or looks, because my opinion might not be the same as yours or anyone elses, so I limit my repsonses to the purely technical.

    As to the durability factors of carpets, this goes to fiber type, construction, and density primarily. Nylon being at the tops in terms of durability. Twist and density denote durability factors there.

    All carpets come in varying grades. The higher the grade the higher the durability and longevity. A higher grade of your carpet selection will have a tighter twist and more density in fibers per square inch.

    In terms of overall durability and stain resistance combination, nylon is king of the road.

    Frieze carpet has the highest twist level at about 7-9 twists per inch which makes them higher in terms of durability and maintaining their look over time, as opposed to a similar grade of cut pile carpet that has fewer twists.

    So, in summary, both brands you mentioned have low to high grade products, so any comparison unless you are comparing specific selections would be compaing apples to oranges.

    here is some more information on Comparing Carpet

    Here is a link that might be useful: Comparing Carpet