Software
Houzz Logo Print
fishpants_gw

We're confused- HRV or good filter system? Help!

19 years ago

We are going to have a 'tight' house with Corbond insulation. Our understanding has been that we should probably have some clean air circulation as a result. We have thought that an HRV system would be the way to go, but now we are aware of filters such as the LifeBreath system. We're not sure which type of system we should do.

A little background: 6000sf conditioned living space, 3 story (full in ground basement). We have been sized for (Trane) 3 LP forced air heating and 2 ac units. We will have a 1200cfm hood in our kitchen, as well as the usual suspect bath fans, etc. in the house.

So what do we choose? A circulator, which we understand itself would need some kind of a filter for the outside air coming in, or the LifeBreath system? Will the LifeBreath system still give us 'fresh air'? And will one system work for the whole house?

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago

    The best filters in the world will do you no good in a tight house. All they will do is filter the same stale air over and over and over. You need an HRV to introduce a certain amount of fresh air into the house while expelling the stale air. An HRV will extract a considerable amount of the heat in that stale air and transfer it to the cooler fresh air without the two masses of air actually coming in contact with each other. These units come as stand alone of they can be incorporated into your regular HVAC system ducted in before the filter.

  • 19 years ago

    .

    HRV's and air filters are separate; different things with different reasons behind them.

    I'll ditto that in a tight house you NEED and HRV for reasons of your own health. They deal with getting fresh oxygen in, and removing the CO2 and humidity from the place. Every one I've seen has a filter on it; though they are fairly Mickey Mouse in terms of what they remove . . mostly intended for removing crap coming in from outside like bugs and big hunks of whatever. If you or yours are particularly sensitive to pollen, dust etc; then a separate filtering system may be needed. It is NOT however; a replacement for bringing in fresh air.

    The best filter in the world does NOT create fresh air from lousy . . . . just takes out the particulate matter.

    You NEED an HRV; you may or may not need any further air filtration . . . .

    Bob

  • 19 years ago

    This may be a very uneducated question to ask, but would the filter be an okay consideration without the HRV when you consider:

    -The range hood will be sucking the life out of the house. We already know this.
    -We live in an extremely UN-humid climate
    -There is always, at minimum, a moderate breeze where we live

    Why not just prop open a window now and then and let the filter clean up the air that blows in? Yes, I have considered winter/summer temps. We cool down at night in the summer, and well, cracking a window in the winter isn't anything we haven't done in the past anyways.

    I am listening. And I haven't made a decision either way. Just another thought I had...

  • 19 years ago

    Fishpants:

    You have had one tech and one individual tell you to go with the HRV.

    I am another tech who is telling you to go with HRV.

    Now quit trying to SELL US on what you THINK you want (Your reasoning is flawed.), and buy what the house and its occupants NEED AND SHOULD HAVE.

    Get it done now!

    Fairy Princess

  • 19 years ago

    .

    Opening your windows . . range hood . . . they'll all bring in SOME fresh air. What they WON'T do is do so at any predictable / constant rate; or distribute it equally throughout the place. THAT is what's important in a tight house. One complete air exchange every 3 ~ 4 hours. A given volume of fresh air is condtioned and brought in; and an EQUAL amount of stale air is exhausted. Using a range hood or opening a window exhausts air => but at what rate ? . . that's determined by how much air can come in from ? wherever ? . . and in a tight house there will be few places.

    Range hood and open windows waste ANY heat ( or cooling; and dehumidification in the case of an ERV ) that you've invested . . . HRV's / ERV's recover a very healthy percentage of it before exhausting it to condition the incoming stream.

    No air filters can change CO2 into oxygen . . .

    Your nickle, your family, your choice . . .

    Bob

  • 19 years ago

    hrv yes why not use heat pumps instead of outdoor straight a.c.

  • 19 years ago

    That kills me ! Why build such a tight house and then say you will open up a window now and then to make up for the air exchange? What a waste!

  • 19 years ago

    Like I said, it was an uneducated question. Now I'm educated, albeit eaten alive! We'll be going to visit with the hvac guy today re putting in an HRV.

  • 19 years ago

    The question still remains, You are going to such great lengths to build a well insulated and tight house. Even with the HRV, why are you installing propane as a primary heat source given todays fuel costs? If natural gas is not available (why else would propane be used) then electric driven Heat Pumps would not add much to the cost of your AC units and deliver most of your heating needs. You may elect to keep the propane as the secondary source for those nights that fall below what the HP can handle.

  • 19 years ago

    Yes, we ARE installing propane as a primary heat source. NG is NOT available, and never will be where the house is located; we know this for sure. Heat pumps in our area are prohibitively expensive due to climate. And electrical is frequently knocked out. Subzero nights (and many days) are the norm in winter.

    Of note to those who seem very concerned about resources: We DO have lots of wind, and are planning on installing a wind generator to help with/possibly cover electrical needs. And later on, tying in solar.

  • 19 years ago

    all things considered,you really should consider using heat pumps in conjuction with your propane furnace.initial investment would be minimal.you would most likely be imppressed with clean heat pump heat but could always use propane exclusivly if you choose to.