Software
Houzz Logo Print
broconne_gw

New Construction - HVAC Dilemma

17 years ago

Hoping to go under contract next week on new construction. However, I am faced with an HVAC dilemma that I am having trouble solving on my own. The builder seems not inclined to let me talk directly to the HVAC sub (protecting his people from annoying customers - I imagine is his stance). However, if I pushed, I am sure I could have a conversation with the HVAC sub - however, I would like to do a little research on my own so that I can hold an intelligent conversation - and I don't want the building process to start off contentious.

House:

New Construction

2 Zones

3900 square feet

39 Windows

R13 and R19 insulation on walls.

R30 in second floor ceiling.

R19 in garage ceiling

Location: Cary, NC (Near Raleigh)

Included Equipment: (Cheapest Carrier they could find)

A/C Unit Carrier 24/ABB (One for each floor)

Furnace (Basement): Carrier 90% 58MCB

Furnace (Attic): Carrier 80% 58STA

I inquired about replacing the A/C units with a heat pump - apparently I am the only person who has asked to do that in this development. The price to do so is $1050.

The heat pump he would install is a Carrier 25HBS3 which is a 13 SEER HP.

I am trying to calculate my ROI on using a heat pump and can't seem to find a simple method to determine my payback period. If it is 5 years, then it is a slam dunk. If it is 10 years.. I am not so sure I would spent the extra money. Does anyone know what the payback period is for such a system?

Winter electric rates are: 9.634 cents per kWh

Gas costs are: 1.177 per therm.

I have tons of other questions as well:

Would a multi-stage furnace be better than a heat pump?

Should I do a heat pump only upstairs and remove the 80% furnace? In that scenario does the heat pump with electric strip backup perform better - specially since the downstairs would be fired by gas if emergency heat was needed?

I swear, HVAC is very confusing the more I look into it, the more questions I end up with!

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I would find out who the subcontractor is, go to their office and talk with the owner/sales staff about options. If you are building a house that size and installing a builder grade system, I think you will be unhappy.

    When you build a large home that probably have nice finishing touches in it, people geherally forget the most important item-- the heating/cooling system. They tend to spend the least amount of thought on it and it is the one thing they utilize every day.

    The contractor will also give you options and pricing. Your electricity/gas prices look ideal for a dual fuel heat pump. I don't know if your quoted electricity/gas rates include taxes, delivery charges, etc. However, it still looks pretty good.

    I would suggest a couple of things for your building envelope. Make sure you windows are at least lowE2, preferably with argon gas. You have a lot of them and heat loss/heat gain is a major consideration. Not all windows are created equal.

    Secondly, I would go no less than R-38 in the top floor ceiling and preferably to R-50. Your upstairs will normally get 4-5 degrees warmer than downstairs. You might also look into radiant barrier for the upstairs on the deck sheeting during the install. That will cut down your heat gain in the summer and make a noticeable difference in your home's comfort.

    AT least R-19 in all exterior walls and R-30 under the main floor crawl space. You los a lot of heat through the floor during the heating season-- more than folk realize.

    YOu'll need to have these final numbers -- whatever they are-- for the HVAC person to do a proper load calc so he can size the heating and duct system properly.

    Don't let the contractor snow you. You have rights as you are the homeowner. I am assuming this is a custom home and not a tract plan. If you are pying the bill, you have rights. If it is a custom and there has been an allowance set for the heating system, you will likely need to pay additional money to get a better than builder grade system.

    My builder was supposed to install energy star rated heating equipment in mine and somehow it got changed. it was inadvertent but I got it changed back. Cost me a little to upgrade my HP to what I wanted but it has paid off, I just wish I had known a little more about heating systems and options before we went into the process. I've since upgraded my insulation to R-57 in the attic and installed radiant barrier.

    This spring/summer I will upgrade the crawl space insulation to R-43 by adding styrene rigid board to seal my R-30 insulation. I will have a nice tight envelope.
    You are in the best position to get what you want.

    It's always easier to do it right the first time than to go back and fix something. And... not all HVAC contractors are equal. Check on the HVAC company reputation with the better business bureau, etc. Remember, cheapest may be better for the contractor, but may not be better for you. Then again, you may find someone with better pricing who will also do it the right way.

    My three cents worth (inflation).

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Tiger thanks for the comments. I have a few questions based on your statements.

    "I would consider a high eff HP like Carrier's Performance 15 "H" model version with matching var speed air handler for upstairs. For downstairs, I would look at an 80% Infinity furnace paired with a matching Infinity 16 HP or again the Performance 15 HP. you do want the tin plated evap coil for the furnace application and in the air handler."

    What is the advantage of the tin plated evap coil?

    I would consider extra insulation if you have a room above a garage. these rooms are notorious for being difficult to heat and cool. they are usually cold in the winter and hot in the summer. add extra insulation for the attic.

    This may be naive - but isn't the insulation R value mostly dictated by the space that can be filled with insulation? I have looked into doing spray insulation but it is out of my price point.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    What is the advantage of the tin plated evap coil?

    Carrier's premium coil...better reliabilty/leak issues..

    insulation is relatively cheap. however, there is the law of diminishing returns. I would put R36 in attic and ask GC about recommendations for superior insulation for room over garage if you have one. you won't regret the upgrade. there's nothing worse than a room with good living space that's only comfortable six mths out of year.

    IMO

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the info on the coil...

    Ok - I am really still a bit confused on insulation. Isn't insulation a function of the depth of the wall? That is what I can tell from the owens corning site. If the exterior wall is 2x4 the insulation you can fit in is R13. If it is a 2x6 wall, then you can fit in R19?

    I can ask if the joists are big enough between the garage and bonus room to support R30.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the feedback speedmonk.

    Here is a response to your useful comments.

    "I would find out who the subcontractor is, go to their office and talk with the owner/sales staff about options. If you are building a house that size and installing a builder grade system, I think you will be unhappy.
    When you build a large home that probably have nice finishing touches in it, people geherally forget the most important item-- the heating/cooling system. They tend to spend the least amount of thought on it and it is the one thing they utilize every day. The contractor will also give you options and pricing. Your electricity/gas prices look ideal for a dual fuel heat pump. I don't know if your quoted electricity/gas rates include taxes, delivery charges, etc. However, it still looks pretty good."

    I have the number of the sub. The GC has made it pretty clear he wants to be the interface between myself and the subs. In order to keep the process running smoothly, I am going to respect that. If it becomes a problem - well then I will have to work past that with him.

    "I would suggest a couple of things for your building envelope. Make sure you windows are at least lowE2, preferably with argon gas. You have a lot of them and heat loss/heat gain is a major consideration. Not all windows are created equal."
    Windows are low E but not argon. The window manufacturer they use does offer argon as an option. How helpful is the argon? Wonder if I should have them price that out.

    "Secondly, I would go no less than R-38 in the top floor ceiling and preferably to R-50. Your upstairs will normally get 4-5 degrees warmer than downstairs. You might also look into radiant barrier for the upstairs on the deck sheeting during the install. That will cut down your heat gain in the summer and make a noticeable difference in your home's comfort."
    I am just not sure how they could fit R50 in the space between the ceiling and the attic floor.

    "AT least R-19 in all exterior walls and R-30 under the main floor crawl space. You los a lot of heat through the floor during the heating season-- more than folk realize."
    It is R30 from the basement to the first floor.
    " YOu'll need to have these final numbers -- whatever they are-- for the HVAC person to do a proper load calc so he can size the heating and duct system properly.

    Don't let the contractor snow you. You have rights as you are the homeowner. I am assuming this is a custom home and not a tract plan. If you are pying the bill, you have rights. If it is a custom and there has been an allowance set for the heating system, you will likely need to pay additional money to get a better than builder grade system."
    This type of housing is called semi-custom. Small neighborhood, regional builder. I would compare them in process to Toll brothers, but better quality and NSO/options only marked up 100% not 500%.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The argon is another barrier that improves the overall glass. I'm no engineer only that the glass numbers are better. Makes it a better window.

    On your attic floor, I'm assuming then you have flooring on your rafters. You could get the R-50 with spray insulation, but you already mentioned that was beyond your budget. If there isn't flooring over the attic floor, then R-38 or R-50 is no problem with either bats or blown-in.

    I would still talk to the sub with the contractor's permission to get the type of system you want. That's critical.