Software
Houzz Logo Print
udarrell_2007

Quick Check for Sizing Units to enough Airflow

17 years ago

Quick Check for Sizing Units to enough Airflow

Actually, even on service calls where there are cooling problems the ductwork should have a quick Manual D performed.

Then take the ESP static pressure & compare to blower graph or chart, also take the FPM duct velocity.

Then do a quick estimate of airflow per equipment tonnage.

To find area of a round duct; Duct diam is 7"; 7"X7"= 49-sq.ins., X's .7854 = 38.04845-sq.ins divided/ by 144= 0.2672541-sq.ft. area X's FPM Velocity 550-FPM = 160.35246-CFM X30 = 4,810.5738 each 7" run X's 6 branch runs = 28,863-BTUH, or airflow for 2.4-ton.

That would also be good for 2-ton; at 550-FPM velocity X's 0.2672541= 147-CFM X 30 = 4,410-BTUH each run X 6-runs = airflow for 26,460-BTUH.

Never sell units requiring more airflow than the duct system & Blower will support! - udarrell

Here is a link that might be useful: Equipment Sizing to Ductwork Sizing for Adequate Airflow

Comments (15)

  • 17 years ago

    I read over alot of your material.
    A subject that is never discussed which intrigues me is....
    THE OPTIMAL COOLING RUNTIME

    I saw mentioned in one of your articles a 5 min on, 30 min off, that to me would be extremely too short.

    I'm sure there are alot of variables, most important might be HEAT LOAD, I should think an experienced A/C person ought to have a gut feel for what is optimal, let's assume a mid 90s outdoor temp.

    My current home runs about 15 minutes ON, 15 minutes OFF at mid 90s, humid climate.

  • 17 years ago

    It doesn't take an experienced HVAC person. A basic understanding of the process tells you that the system should run continuously if it is operating at its design conditions. Example: A system sized to cool a residence to 75F when it is 95F outside should run essentially all the time once the outside temperature hits 95F.

    If yours cycles on and off with a 50% duty cycle under those conditions, it is grossly over-sized. An over-sized system will likely have poor humidity control, be inefficient, and shorter lived than it should be.

    Plus needless expense was incurred when the system was purchased and installed.

  • 17 years ago

    How about a reference for what your saying?
    In over 35 years of reading I have never heard such a thing.

    So if I have a 2.5 ton unit (30000 btu) thats a eer of 12 - drawing 2500 watts when it runs.
    Youre proposing having perhaps an 18000 btu drawing 1500 watts constantly. And in two years it will be worn out and need replacing with another. So why would the manual J call for a 2.5 ton, not a 1.5 ton?
    I don't want to argue, I just want a reputable reference that backs up your concept.

  • 17 years ago

    I am doing a correction on my initial post.
    I had re-figures it at 600-FPM but left 550-FPM in the equation.
    0.2672541-sq.ft. area X's FPM Velocity (not 550-FPM) 600-FPM = 160.35246-CFM X30 = 4,810.5738 each 7" run X's 6 branch runs = 28,863-BTUH, or airflow for 2.4-ton.

    Creek_side, is essentially correct; except the figure is contingent on "the outdoor summer design wet bulb & dry bulb of that particular climate area."

    Motors & the relay components wear out faster depending on the frequency of the starts. Therefore, a more constant running unit will normally last much longer with fewer failures than the short cycling unit.

    This is a reason for reducing air infiltration, window improvements& more & better insulation, because when the unit cycles off, the off-time will be greatly increased, reducing both the size the the units & the number of cycles per day of cooling. - udarrell

    Here is a link that might be useful: Correct Sizing of Residential Air Conditioning Systems & Ductwork Systems

  • 17 years ago

    I don't want to argue, I just want a reputable reference that backs up your concept.

    Will udarrel do? :-)

  • 17 years ago

    Udarrel....given his statement of "A system sized to cool a residence to 75F when it is 95F outside should run essentially all the time once the outside temperature hits 95F.", isn't it true the system would fall behind when outside is over 95?

  • 17 years ago

    this is what all those charts want you to do , is to buy a furnace and air con. that won't heat your house if it gets too cold, and won't cool your home if it gets too hot. This way you have a efficient system. Its all good for you. later paulbm

  • 17 years ago

    I'm not gonna pass judgement on the concept, I just want it explained further. 99% of houses have their systems designed around a TYPICAL outside temp, but have the capacity to handle higher temps by way of longer runtimes. Longer runtimes aren't a possibility in this option.

  • 17 years ago

    srercrcr, i agree with you they should be sized to have a little backup to do the job. Later paulbm

  • 17 years ago

    I was happy to see this thread started by udarrel 2007. Please help me with my difficult situation. When I did my numbers by udarrel's formula, they did not work at all. I have an early 1976 doublewide, not my primary residence. 2 x 4 exterior walls, 1440 square feet. Originally with electric furnace only, previous owner had heat pump installed. 3 ton unit, not Listed for mobile homes, but it lasted 20 years. Now to be replaced. The chart at the link shows 2 1/2 tons for cooling for my location. 1441 square foot (just one more than mine) mobile home would be 3 tons on the chart. My ductwork is in the floor, from the factory- changes are not at all possible. The existing air handler is downflow, into a plenum which goes to the duct in each side of the DW. Each duct has 5 floor registers, total of 10. The ducts are smooth aluminum interior. One duct measures 13 11/16 x 3 3/4 (51 in2), the other 13 11/16 x 3 (41 in2), for combined duct area of 92 in2. Not very much. But my only choices are to get the new heat pump air handler installed on the existing plenum (what size?) or demolish the place. Demolition is not my preference. And the existing 3 ton unit did work for 20 years. Your suggestions?
    As an aside, my permanent home has 11 x 15 galvanized duct with interior insulation for a 2-ton unit. The air handler was tested and adjusted for 400 CFM. Quite different from the mobile home.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Manufactured homes

  • 17 years ago

    "99% of houses have their systems designed around a TYPICAL outside temp, but have the capacity to handle higher temps by way of longer runtimes. Longer runtimes aren't a possibility in this option.

    Only if the designer was incompetent.

    The design should have been done to the 97% limit.

    That means in a 6 month cooling season the unit will run 100% (and not meet demand) for around 131 hours over the 6 months (about 1 hour a day).

    99% design values are also available.

    Add in the typical 'rounding up' in unit sizing and it is even fewer hours.

    Part of the problem is determining an exact demand.
    Manual J calculations are only as good as the input data.

    A small error in the R value of exterior walls and ceilings can result in major errors since the square foot area is large.

    Infiltration is another major cause of errors.
    Absent a blower door test to actually measure the air exchange rate all you can do is estimate.

    New construction can be easier since R values are better known, but it still requires attention to detail to achieve the design R value, and also to limit infiltration.

  • 17 years ago

    Re: my earlier post of July 14, today I dismantled enough to find the label on the indoor coil. Goodman UDC36. Website shows it to be 8.5 SEER with total BTU 33,400, a 3 ton unit. Also shows "sensible" BTU of 25,000. That is new term to me. And I still do not know if the new unit should be 2 1/2 ton or 3 ton. Suggestions welcome.
    Also, if the new unit is 13 SEER, does that mean that it will consume just 65% of the electricity of the old one?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Goodman

  • 17 years ago

    I have the same size DW MH on my ranch in hot south texas...it runs a 2.5 ton quite adequately. I don't think the ceilings are a full 8 ft. My main house first floor has a 2.5 ton cooling 1320 sf with 9 ft ceilings, but all other factors are ideal...shade, porches, orientation, glass, insulation, ventilation, second story serves as the attic for the first floor....you name it.

    By the way, as to run times, a caller called into a radio show...he has a 1940 house probably no insulation at least in the walls, and the retofit central air runs 10 min ON and 10 OFF...my opinion is it's 10 off because of the high heat gain he's getting, I guess the 10 ON means he's oversized.

    Two units, both the same cooling capacity, a SEER 16 would use half the electricity of a SEER 8.

  • 17 years ago

    "I saw mentioned in one of your articles a 5 min on, 30 min off, that to me would be extremely too short." (srcrcrcr)Mon July 6,09 6:31
    Sorry, I have not been visiting this forum for a long time.

    That had to be an example of being a bad situation; or I need to find the statement & correct it.

    The best combination is sizing & weatherization so there is a long runtime & then a long off time near average summer runtime conditions.

    At summer design conditions (indoors design @75-F) the unit will be running most of the time. In extreme temp conditions, if indoor temps climb to 80-F, humidity should be low, use a floor fan or two & for that short time - U'll be in the Human Comfort Zone.

    As for a reputable reference, they refer to my work as it corresponds to the reputable authors work.

    Everyone is welcome to disagree with any of my work, but try to reference the work you disagree with. It could have been an error in the content that I need to correct.

    Excessive air infiltration & inadequate ductwork systems are the gigantic factors that destroy lower cooling cost efforts.

    Reduce the heat-gain all U can first, then get the duct system optimized for the A/C size it calls for.

    Forget the SEER savings charts, in real life situations those claims usually become insignificant. - udarrell

    Here is a link that might be useful: Proper Sequence Toward Reducing Utility Bills

  • 17 years ago

    Could you please tell me your thoughts about why Manual J calculations are designed around somewhat equal ON/OFF run cycles, rather than around your long (95/5?) runtime model?