Software
Houzz Logo Print
alaxsxaq

HVAC Quotes - Heat Pump

15 years ago

We want to replace our existing heat pump and oil furnace and have received quotes from 4 reputable local dealers. I'm looking for some help with sorting these out.

Location: SE Pennsylvania

House: 3000 sq feet built in the mid-70's. Situated on the north-east side of a hill along a stream, so it tends to be colder in the winter months and cooler in summer.

The heat pumps are all 4 ton except one as noted.

Dealer #1:

Carrier 25HPA648 w/10kw heat strip - $9,175

Carrier 58MVC120-20 (5 ton) w/Carrier 25HBC360 gas furnace - 9,125

Climate Master TTV064 Tranquility 27 Geothermal HP w/10kw heat strip - 23,295

Dealer #2:

Bryant 286BNA048000 w/Bryant 355CAV060120 gas furnace - 11,000

Dealer #3:

Lennox XP21-048 w/15kw heat strip - 9150

Lennox XP21-048 w/Lennox G61-MPC-06C-091 gas furnace - 10,580

Dealer #4:

Trane XR15 w/Trane 90,000 BTU gas furnace - 9,867

Trane XL16i w/Trane gas furnace - 11,018

Trane XL15i w/Trane gas furnace - 10.503

For the gas furnace, we would use propane, so there will be additional costs for the tank installation. Propane also has the negative price fluctuations that we've experienced with oil and we get tied to a supplier unless we purchase the tank which is likely how we'd go so we could bury the tank since it becomes hard to hide it otherwise. Electricity is about .085/kWh.

We're waiting for another quote on geothermal. Both dealers are talking about drilling a well for the coil. Our soil is clay/shale, so maybe trenching is out?

Even with the full 30% tax credit for geothermal, it still ends up being about double the cost of the other quotes.

Thoughts on these quotes?

Thanks!

--Glenn

Comments (6)

  • 15 years ago

    How close to Philly are you? 120,000 BTU furnace (even a 3 stage) seems excessive for a 3000 SF home. Was an accurate heat calc done?

    I'm across the Delaware in Camden Cnty w/2500 SF home that needs 60,000 BTUs.

    Since you are cooler in summer, you might do with less than 4 tons. Humidty a problem?

    V

  • 15 years ago

    glenn

    I think you have two basic questions you have to ask yourself as far as importance to your decision.

    1.your budget
    2.operating cost specifically for heating.

    using $0.09/kwh and COP of 2.75 for electric and $2.50/gal at 95% eff for propane, you will find that electric even with strip heat is cheaper than propane. see link below for fuel comparison calculator. plug the numbers in. if you believe that nation's economy will eventually recover, then you can count on propane increasing as it will track fuel oil prices.

    you do not list furnace mdls for the Trane quote. I would want a load calc performed before I decided on a 120 KBTU furnace,whether Carrier,Trane, or Bryant. You don't want to be oversized.

    I am not a Lennox fan and would put them 4th in that list of conventional HVAC options.

    you must qualify dealer's experience and reputation whether conventional or geothermal HVAC. get references. if you have any hot/cold spots in your home, now is the time to address.

    IMO

    Here is a link that might be useful: Fuel Comparison Calculator

  • 15 years ago

    how much do you pay for electricity? Figure this out by taking the total dollar amount of your last bill and divide by number of KW's used.

    I don't think you want propane. That geo-thermal quote is interesting. If your planning on being there along time that might be the way to go.

    How well is is your house insulated? How are windows and attic insulation?

    Air source Heatpumps do well in alot of climates for most weather. Ofcourse when it gets extra cold you might be running your auxiliary additionally but thats not the majority of the time.

  • 15 years ago

    If you can get geo for $16k after tax credits, that would seem to be the way to go. Geo is a reasonable payoff in lots of situations and not in others. Local/utility incentives? I put in Solar hotwater and got a surprise $1000 from local utility company after the fact!

    Not having NG and needing both heating and cooling really helps geo pay for itself.

    A look at last year's energy costs is helpful for deciding if geo is worth it. Perhaps an independent energy auditor can give you cost estimates for a geo system.

    In NC with NG and HP, Geo saved just $200 a year. So payback didn't cover the interest on the extra cost which was more than yours.

    Your extra cost looks like just $7k ($23-7=16). 5% is pretty common now but availability of credit is an issue. That is just $350 a year. I would think you would save closer to $1000 a year based on propane and your climate (wild guess of course).

    People often talk about how long you plan on staying in a house for these kinds of things and that is a reasonable question. But I think geo would be a pretty good asset at resale. Imagine 10 years from now and guess oil costs - might be $80, might be $200. If it is $200, then geo is going to be a huge selling point. And, last but not least, you would be doing your part to reduce dependence of a finite resource. (jumping off box now...)

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for the comments.

    We are located in Lancaster County and humidity is an issue since we are in a wooded area with a stream running through the front yard. I'm not sure whether any of that factored into these estimates since my wife wasn't asked specifically about humidity.

    The Trane models are listed, XR15, XL16i, and XL15i - all 4 ton. My wife was around for the contractor visits and the Trane contractor was the most thorough. They did not, as far as I know, do a full-on heat calc.

    I am starting to lean towards the heat pump and we have asked a couple of the contractors, who all sell ClimateMaster, to come back out. The Trane dealer specifically said he can't do a quote on Geothermal without measurements, etc.

    Right now, there are a lot of insulation issues with the house, but we are preparing to do a full refurbishment of the exterior with a new roof, siding, windows. I expect we will be here for at least 10-15 years.

  • 15 years ago

    if you have a leaky house you will discover the heatpump to be running alot. You might want dual fuel - then you have the best of both worlds. If would seriously consider geo-thermal if your going to be there for alot of years and your planning on re-insulating/upgrading.