Software
Houzz Logo Print
mama_jenn

Another LG vs HE5t washer post...

19 years ago

I don't know which to get. I'm only buying the washer, not the pair. I'm leaning towards the HE5t because the price and because LG seems so new. But then I like that the LG has a light and, I confess, I like the red color. :blush: I wish that the HE5t came in better colors like the HE4t's sedona color. I know that color shouldn't matter and I can't believe that I'm actually even giving it a value.

So, searching posts, it seems like LG service could be an issue--how do I determine if there is LG service where I live?

Another cost factor is that I want to buy the extra warranty and if I get the LG at Lowes (or is it Home Depot), the extended warrenty is much cheaper than if I get the extended warranty with the HE5t at Sears.

Also, it seems like the only difference between the 2 machines is the light bulb and the steam function, is this correct?

Last, and most important to me, the HE5t claims to use 71% water and 71% less energy, is this true? And what about the LG? Does the LG save the same amount?

thanks.

Comments (14)

  • 19 years ago

    With regard to energy and water usage, they are all (the high end washers) so very similar any differences here would be negligible.
    To verify service in your area you will have to be somewhat coy. If you call LG and tell them you are interested in buying and want to know if there is service in your area....well they are going to tell you what you want to hear. I have told folks to call and advise you need service (fabricate an issue) and see how soon they can get someone to you. If it is a week or more; there is a good bet they have no service in your area, if it is a day or two out you are good. They will try to solve your issue over the phone with all these ridiculous test. You can either go into a rage for having to do all of this on a 1600.00 machine or say that you have followed all the "resolution tips" in the owner's manual and now you want it serviced. If they ask for serial #'s tell them you are in the office and don't have it available. If they want to know what model, tell them you have the red ones. (lol)
    I know that is a lot of deception but I don't trust any of these manufactures and unfortunately you don't find out until AFTER you have purchased that there is no service.
    The HE5t is a good washer but has been dinged on not being gentle to clothes and not to mention the issues people here have had w/Sears service. The LG's will sound like an earthquake if they are not leveled properly.
    I have the "red" ones lol and I love them...the light is pretty nifty too!

  • 19 years ago

    Also, if I have the warranty, do I still contact LG or do I contact the warranty people?

    Off to do your test.

  • 19 years ago

    ok, I did your test (after searching the LG website for the local number) and they said that they are working 2 weeks out. She said that they are located in Reading, which is where I am, but really my city is fairly small. She did say that I could try a few other companies to see if they could come sooner. Hmmm, maybe I should check with the Sears people.

  • 19 years ago

    who said they are located in Reading? the LG folks? she actually sugessted that you try other companies for repair on a LG?

  • 19 years ago

    Yes. I went on the LG website and did support, and then service centers, and then entered my zip code I think and it gave me the phone number for a service place in Reading. I called them and she said it would be 2 weeks. I asked if she was located in Reading, and she said yes. I asked if there wasn't any way to get it taken care of sooner and she said that I could try to call around and find another place that could repair the LG.

    Oh, and I did this with Sears and it's about a week.

  • 19 years ago

    OK that makes better sense; it was the service ctr that suggested you call around to see if somebody else could work on the LG.
    Well that makes sense, they may be smaller service ctr. Sears does have almost a hundred years on their side! lol look on the forum today...somebody is fussing about Sears! They are all a crock!! Whatever you buy make sure you follow the rules, i.e. HE detergent, leaving door open etc.
    Take care

  • 19 years ago

    Hi,
    I too did exhaustive reseach on front-loaders, spent many hours reading here and other sites. I ended up buying LG 2487 washer with LG 7177 dryer. It's been two weeks and maybe 5 loads of laundry and I'm very impressed so far!
    Our house is buuilt on a concrete slab, so washer did not need leveling even though I had level in hand as they installed it. Washer is very quiet! Average wash time has been 54-55 minutes. I like how it senses the size of the load and then calculates how much water, how much time, etc to clean load. I'm also surprised at how much laundry 1 load will handle! What used to be two loads in our old TL is now 1 load in the FL. Clothes come out clean and smelling very nice! We used the Tide HE liquid sample it came with. The warrantee seems like it was pretty good, 1 year parts/labor, 2 years-control board, 7 years-motor and 10 years-drum. I have 30 days to buy extended warrantee which I'm still thinking about.
    Dryer is also very impressive, the auto-drying has averaged 41-42 minutes per load on normal cycle, it also is very quiet unless you have zippers or snaps that can clang in the SS drum. The venting sensor is cool, lets you know if you have sufficient vent flow. It has cooling tumble after clothes are dry to keep from wrinkling, and last but not least, the coolest jingle when dryer is done. These machines have many more features, but so far so good! I live in the very populous SF bay area, so I'm not too concerned about service in needed, I too leave door open as a precautionary too prevent mold smell. My neighbor used to be a Sears appliance repairman, Sears does source out to numerous manufacturers now, so Kenmore brand is not exclusive to Whirlpool anymore. Take all advice with a grain of salt, weigh all your options, roll the dice and hope for the best! Good luck with what ever you choose.
    Take care and stay clean!! :)

  • 19 years ago

    Three comments. The HE5T claims to use 71% water and 71% less energy. Less than what? The He2T, The Maytag..What?

    The fact that the service center you called is in the same city you are doesn't mean the service is coming from them. You could have just called a call center..these can even be located in a foreign country, so best to ask where the service truck is coming from. Waiting 2 weeks to get something fixed is not what I would want to hear...but this might be the rule nowadays.

    Last - as you stated --the color red does not make anything a good product.

  • 19 years ago

    jerrod6,
    the water and energy savings are in regards to a traditional TL. I don't think there could be any FL that uses 70% less water than another FL...at least if they are both less than 10 years old. Many, many years ago, FLs used to use a lot more water, but they have been improved and they are all considered HE nowadays.
    There are bad comments about both LG's and Sears' service. I think I would consider one of the HE5t's siblings like the Maytag Epic or Whirlpool Duet. The extended warranties are a lot cheaper at Lowes or Best Buy as well...

  • 19 years ago

    I currently have a TL and the water and electric saving are in comparison to a TL.

    I ended up going with the HE5t, and it should be delivered tomorrow! YEAH!

  • 19 years ago

    When I checked the energy savings, LG 2487 was rated to use much less electricity than the other models. I recently got this model and really am happy with it. From my checking, LG has much less repairs than Whirlpool, Maytag, etc. Whirlpool is relatively new to FL. LG has been making them for decades.

  • 19 years ago

    Is that correct that LG has a direct transmission vs belt one used in other washers? If so, it means another expensive part to be repaired.

  • 19 years ago

    premier, Whirlpool is not as new to frontloaders as you may think. They marketed a frontloading washer/dryer combo in the late 1950s and early 1960s, then dropped them under their own brand label but continued to manufacture and sell via Kenmore until 1974. The Duet, HE3/4/5, KA Ensemble/Maytag Epic are made by Bauknecht in Germany, where frontloaders have been common for many years.

  • 19 years ago

    miksh as far as I know there is no 'transmission" on the LG's true they are direct drive which is supposed to eliminate vibration and additional parts. Also I believe Whirlpool which probably includes the Kenmores and Maytags are direct drive as well as Samsung and Siemens are too. That is not the holy grail, but I believe my information is correct. I cannot speak on Fridgidaires or GE's and Miele's.