Software
Houzz Logo Print
ckindiana

question about floors

20 years ago

DH and I are in the process of buying the 1907 building that currently houses his store in our historic dowtown. We plan to live in the second floor apartment. Now I move from lurking to participating on this board. My question is this, we want to refinish the floors before we move in which are quite yucky. The previous owner removed the flooring that was on top of the wood but did nothing after that. We plan to do just a light sanding before putting down the finish. After doing some research I think the waterlox finish would be best but I'm not sure we can manage the 3 days for putting on the finish and the 7 days to cure (after the sanding of course). Any other suggestions for a finish that would be more true to the era than poly that might require a little less time (even just a few days less)? I really don't want to go the poly route. Did that on this current floor and I've not been happy with it. Thank you in advance for your help! I'm sure I will be posting often as now we have our own old building to care for.

Comments (9)

  • 20 years ago

    Consider a tung oil finish which is easy to touch up in any places with wear. I don't think it has the curing times as long as you mentioned. Afterward, I also put down a coat of butcher's wax, then buff with a big round buffer.

    By the way, "a little light sanding" is a bit of a misnomer, unless you're talking about doing a small patches by hand. Sanding is sanding, and once embarked upon by machine it's got to be thorough to get the marks of the sanders off.

    You didn't mention what kind of wood the floor is. That might make a difference. Along with what kind of finish is on there now. Varnish, shellac, oil (like tung) or one of the modern products?

    As an alternative to doing the sanding, you might want to consider just giving it a very good scrubbing, and then see what other plans you have after you've been in the house for a while.

    Whenever you can avoid a sanding, you "save" that amount of wood and prolong the life of your floors. Even with thick older floors there are only so many refinishings-with-sanding you can make until you've got to replace it all.

    Congratulations on your new house.

    Molly~

  • 20 years ago

    For speed, you could consider shellac. You can do several coats in one day. We have a house from 1920 where all the floors are heart pine, and have been finished with shellac.
    I have re-finished one room, and am in the process of finishing the master bedroom. I do not want to do much sanding, I like the look of old wood floors.
    Shellac is not as durable, but on the other side it is easy to repair and to apply, and it looks great.

    Barney

  • 20 years ago

    Why are you againnst poly.All my floors were redone 13 years ago,We used 3 coats of waterbased poly.,They look and wear as good asthe day they were done.easy clean up.

  • 20 years ago

    Bulldinkie, I don't want to go with poly for two reasons:

    1. I don't like the plasticy look. I don't think it will look right for our new old place.

    2. I have two large dogs who will eventually leave scraches on the floor. I find the poly flakes and I would rather have something that won't flake and/or is easier to touch up.

  • 20 years ago

    A quality waterborne polyurethane done right will not flake when scratched.

  • 20 years ago

    Mine doesnt flake at all,I have a jack Russell in the house also it doesnt look plastic either.Just a slight shine.Id do it again.

  • 20 years ago

    I'm glad those of you who have poly like it and yes, I'm sure if done right it will not flake. But I would like to use tung oil or something similar because I would like it to penatrate the wood rather than sit on top of it like poly.

  • 20 years ago

    I have not yet refinished my floor, but after talking with a friend who has used tung oil, I decided to use the tung oil finish from the Real Milk Paint Company.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Real Milk Paint Company

  • 20 years ago

    Inox, thank you. This is the kind of finish of interest to me.