Software
Houzz Logo Print
agreenflower

Aluminum siding replacement

19 years ago

I live in NE Ohio and have a large 2 story house with aluminum siding. Due to a recent storm, I am replacing/repairing the roof, gutters, and siding.

My concern is with the aluminum siding. I am leaning towards power washing and painting the siding after the roof and gutters are replaced, due to my fear of a contractor doing shabby work.

Is it a good idea to replace aluminum siding with vinyl siding?

Should I insist that the aluminum siding be replaced with aluminum siding?

Comments (5)

  • 19 years ago

    How available is aluminum siding? I can't tell you the last time I've seen it!

    My in-laws just replaced aluminum with vinyl after a hail storm if that is any help. Labor has got to be less with vinyl; it's easier to work with. There are different grades/qualities of vinyl, so be aware.

    If you do replace your siding, do consider more insulation (foam sheathing) and/or a Tyvek/Typar house wrap to control air infiltration. You would also have access to better air-seal the windows/doors to the house as well. Well worth it while the job is being done!

  • 19 years ago

    This being an old house forum I feel obligated to tell you (well somebodys gotta do it) that maybe you don't want to do aluminum OR vinyl - cement board siding is really by far the superior product - paintable, breathable, more durable. Or its possible you'll find original siding in perfect condition underneath.

    They do still make aluminum siding, some doesn't look half bad with the narrower width struos appropriate for the old house.

  • 19 years ago

    I agree with kashka kat about either cement board or removing the aluminum entirely and getting your original siding back.

    Take a look at the attached article for issues with siding.

    Here is a link that might be useful: vinyl siding issues

  • 19 years ago

    vinyl siding....*shudder*....eeeek!!!

    Fiber cement is a great product. Sure, it costs more, but putting vinyl on a great old house is sort of like drinking dom perignon out of a styrofoam cup.

    only IMHO, of course! :)

  • 19 years ago

    The main problem I have with aluminum siding is fire. If you have a fire inside, it cannot break out through the siding. I owned a house where the previous owner had died of smoke inhalation because of the aluminum siding and a small fire, so small it only left smoke film on everything.

    We removed the siding and found undamaged wood clapboard and shingles and very nice trim and corner boards, all covered up because in the 1960's they were old fashioned and too much trouble to paint. Our house went from ho-hum to charming! And it wasn't too much trouble to keep it painted.

    so I suggest you find out what's there first.