We used Mullet Cabinets in Millersburg, Ohio.They do fabulous work. I'm sure they would do work in Indiana. Since moving to California, we considered using them but decided the shipping and flying installers would be too much of a headache and expense:-)
Good luck.

www.mulletcabinet.com

Here is an old thread with people who used Amish cab makers in Indiana/IL. You can e-mail them and find out who they used and how to reach the cabinet maker. I know that there are alot in Northern IN outside of Chicago, but I don't personally have contacts.

Here is a link that might be useful: Old thread on IN Amish cab makers

I don't have a specific recommendation but you should check out northern Indiana, like Shipshewana or Wakarusa. My in-laws are from up there and there is a large amish population. I think there would have to be a cabinet maker there as well. Maybe try googling amish cabinet makers in those cities.

Friends of mine used Lambright Woodworking in Shipshewana.
I am considering them also. I took a trip out there a few weeks ago to look at a few displays in their shop. Beautiful work.

Ayr Custom Cabinets in Nappanee, Indiana. The absolute best. Check their website. My kitchen was done perfectly by Ayr. Everyone I know is totally in love with my cabinetry. Ken Miller is the guy. Nothing is too difficult. He will read your mind and know what you want. Beautiful work. Also check the kitchen of 'loves2cook4six'. They do travel so give them a call.

Graber is one - out by Grabill / Leo. North of Ft Wayne.