Software
Houzz Logo Print
doonie_gw

Wolf Gas Cooktop jitters...

16 years ago

After reading another thread about these Wolf cooktops, I am second guessing the sealed burner that I thought I would be ordering. (I am going with Wolf because I can't get the BlueStar serviced here, if I needed it.) However, now I am back to sealed or unsealed gas burners. I had worked this through once and decided on sealed because "they" say it is easier to clean. But maybe I am yielding to the clean factor and giving up on the sizzling factor, which is really why I want this type top to begin with. I do most of my cooking on top of the stove, so I really need to make the optimal decision.

And here I am on the decision making merry-go-round again. Can anyone help with this?

Comments (13)

  • 16 years ago

    I was in love with a Wolf rangetop (open) when I found GW. I've changed a lot of my thinking about how I would like to cook in the future since then, and got some induction and some closed Wolf gas. If I didn't have a lot of induction power, I don't think I'd want the closed burners.

    Question: Is being clean more important to you, or is looking clean more important? Open can look less then clean, when it really is clean. Some people find cleaning open easier, but I don't know if that's the actual cleaning or making to look clean. For instance, on my old black, closed gas cooktop, I didn't bother getting the water spots off. My housekeeper did. In between, when I cleaned, I'd get it clean, but didn't bother with polishing.

  • 16 years ago

    Sealed burners tend to get a bad rap on these forum but I've had a DCS range with sealed burners for over 7 years and I love it. The burners my not be as powerful as the 22K star burner of the Bluestar but I've never had problems cooking anything with the 17.5K sealed burners including excellent stir fries. Also, I HATE cleaning - you should have seen my old range :-) but I find the sealed burners really easy to keep clean and I actually do it! If I had to take burners apart and drag them to the sink along with drip trays, it would never happen. It's a matter of personal preference but not everyone hates sealed burners.

  • 16 years ago

    If the open burners on the cooktop are the same as the ones on the AG range--they are not difficult to clean. I don't bother cleaning the rings/burners themselves unless they are really dirty. As for the black enamel burner pans, I use Perfect Kitchen from BB&B and paper towels for spot cleaning (as per Wolf showroom suggestion). For a more thorough cleaning, I pop the pans off the range, and either spray with Dawn Power Dissolver or sprinkle w/ BKF and then scrub with a blue scrub sponge. Rinse w/ hot water, dry with a dishtowel and pop them back on.

    FWIW, not too much stuff falls through the opening around the burners, and the drip tray is enough to clean, too.

  • 16 years ago

    plllog, my cleaning style sounds like yours. I have a black range top now, but it only gets looking optimal when the cleaning lady spruces it up, somehow, every 2 weeks. Maybe I should be considering induction. Tonight I was sauteeing chicken breasts and the recipe said 3 minutes per side on med high and it took at least double that amount of time. Very frustrating to not get the heat level that I want.

    wiessman, I hate cleaning too! So, that is why I thought I was going with the sealed. My 10 year old Kenmore is sealed now, but I really don't think it's got a great heat output. So, it makes me wonder, does the sealing really decrease the heat output that much or is it just that I have a bad gas top.

    cat mom, how often do you have to clean the stove top? I don't understand how stuff gets down there anyway. I guess to get more specific, how often do you clean the drip tray? Can you even see the drip tray, cause if I can't see it, it may not get cleaned (unlike my toothbrush BKF bearing mother!).

    I get so frustrated sauteeing on my current stove. I don't know if it's the stove or the sealed burner. Thanks to all who have responded, but I am still perplexed and I'll be cooking on this new stove into retirement, so I really want to make the right decision. TIA.

  • 16 years ago

    I get distracted so pasta, rice, potatoes, etc., tend to boil over on me. I've got old open burners and it sometimes runs down under the drip pan. I'm looking forward to sealed burners.

  • 16 years ago

    doonie - not all sealed burners are created equal just as not all open burners are created equal - how much airflow they get and how many BTUs they have contribute to how hot they get. My DCS burners get so hot that I rarely ever cook on high - only for stir frying and boiling water - when I first got it, there was a learning curve - I wanted to crank them up all the time and I had to learn how low to keep them, not how high! I suspect you just have a weak cooktop. I have a friend with a Jennair range with open burners and she can barely heat things up with it.

  • 16 years ago

    I don't really clean the drip tray very often at all. If I think of it when I'm cleaning the range top and front, I might pull the tray out to see if it needs to be wiped down at all. Otherwise, I clean it when I know something's boiled over.

    The part you pull out (the lip) is visible, but the tray itself isn't visible at all when it's pushed in.

    As for the burner pans, it really depends on how much cooking I'm doing in a given week, and how careful I've been while cooking (I tend to be a messy cook BTW!). If I've just cleaned the range, I try to be more careful. For example, I might cover the unused burners and surrounding surface with foil if I'm using just one or two burners and I think I might splatter while cooking.

    If you do a search in the Appliance Forum, you might find a somewhat recent thread I posted to about about how I clean my range. Mind you, I'm a bit better about keeping the outside clean than the inside...!

  • 16 years ago

    Doonie, there's a massive difference between a Wolf and an old Kenmore!

    According to Wolf's website the 36" gas cooktop (drop in) has: One large 15,000 Btu/hr sealed burner with 800 Btu/hr delivered at simmer. One medium 12,000 Btu/hr sealed burner with 800 Btu/hr delivered at simmer. Three small 9,200 Btu/hr sealed burners with 300 Btu/hr delivered at simmer. The 30" is one large, one medium and two small. The sealed rangetop has the same burners.

    The 36" open burner rangetop has: two, four or six dual brass burners with automatic re-ignition at all settings. The burners can produce 16,000 BTUs for professional cooking heat and turn down to 500 BTUs for those delicate jobs like melting chocolate.

    The rangetop has all larger burners, slightly more oomph than the largest on the closed, and significantly more than the medium and small, with a lower simmer, but doesn't have as low a simmer as the small burners.

    By comparison, your Kenmore probably tops at 9.6K BTU or less. From your description it sounds like you might like the open burners' power better.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks so much for all the help! I think I may have to go unsealed.

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Doonie, Best of wishes for your decision on Wolf open rangetop vs sealed rangetop. I've just made the switch from a vintage open burner range to a sealed Wolf. For what it is worth, I'm happed with the sealed burners. I'm an enthusiastic home cook, not a professional. I made my decision based on my need for a flexible, dependable range for home cooking. I did not expect to be able to replicated restaurant stir fry on my stove.

    Be sure you are comparing apples to apples, i.e. Wolf rangetop to Wolf rangetop (not cooktop). The open burners rangetop offers 16,000 BTU on all burners and the sealed burner rangetop offers 15,000 BTU on all but one burner (the back left burner is a lower simmer burner). Some cooks will notice a slight difference in the loss of BTU stepping down from 16,000 to 15,000 BTU. I did a test with a friend (sealed vs open) and it translated into about 1 minute longer to heat a big pot of pasta water. But for most purposes, you will not notice the difference. I get an excellent sear when I cook meat and great recovery time when I add additional pieces of meat to the pan.

    The flame patterns do look very different on the open than on the sealed burners; but a good quality All-Clad style pan/skillet will distribute the heat very evenly across the bottom of the pan on either the Wolf open or sealed burner. The ability to modulate and control the heat is excellent on both. The low simmer is amazing. This is something I could never do on my old stove.

    Also note that if you want the 30" Wolf rangetop, the sealed burner is your only option. Both sealed and open are available on the 36". To a certain extent the decision also comes down to aethetics: each rangetop has a different look. Which do you like better?

    I'm sure you have seen all the great advice on open vs sealed burners on the kitchen and appliance forums. Most people in the end seem happy with the decision they have made. Have you considered finding a store that permits you to try out their stoves live? For such a big purchase this seems like a good idea.

    Rest assured that in either case you are getting a great range top. And rest assured that no matter which one you pick you will still spend lots of time cleaning it -- at least if you are a messy cook like me!

  • 16 years ago

    Oh, thanks, Francoise! I think my browser burped when I looked it up because it gave me the same description for the sealed rangetop and cooktop.

    Here's the proper one for the rangetop:

    15,000 Btu/hr (4.4 kW) burners with 950 Btu/hr (.3 kW) delivered at simmer. 9,200 Btu/hr (2.7 kW) burner with 325 Btu/hr (.1 kW) delivered at simmer and melt.

  • 16 years ago

    I don't have a Wolf. I have a Capital range, the burners are closed. It is very easy to clean---I just use soapy dishrag followed by microfiber cloth after cooking. It is a breeze.

    Each of my burners is 19,000 btu, and the simmer is 140 degrees. I love it.

    I did love the Wolf when we were shopping, but getting my dh to go for the Capital was a big enough accomplishment for me. He thought we surely would find something for around $800.

  • 16 years ago

    My two burner little closed Wolf module was installed today. The electricity isn't even on yet, so no igniters, but the plumber, who hooked it up, was really impressed! I was surprised because I would have figured he'd have seen the like before, but I guess not. He was astonished by how low the flame was on the small burner on low, and that wasn't even on simmer.

Sponsored
Kuhns Contracting, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Central Ohio's Trusted Home Remodeler Specializing in Kitchens & Baths