Software
Houzz Logo Print
cjphilly

Water Heater Recommendations?

17 years ago

I am looking for recommendations for a 40 or 50 gallon natural gas water heater. Ours is at least 16 years old, and has recently started making noises like there are marbles rolling around inside. Also, we have noticed a gradual, yet significant, reduction in the amount of hot water we get.

I've investigated going tankless, but it really won't work in our situation. We live in a rowhouse and would have a very hard time finding any place we could vent the unit according to code. Additionally, I just don't want to fork over the cash upfront at this time.

I've found there are a ton of water heaters out there, and it can be hard to compare them. Are any of them relatively more efficient than others? Are there brands to stay away from? I'm hesitant to go with a powered vent unit, simply for fear the fan would die and I've never notice.

Any advice greatly appreciated!

Comments (13)

  • 17 years ago

    Now for some answers to your questions:

    Standard gas tank heaters have a similar efficiency. They will typically have an energy factor of .56-.58 The cost is around $300-500 for the unit and they all tend to last about 8 years. There seem to be a lot of complaints about the Whirlpool Flame Lock heaters... you can search this site for the details. Bradford White heaters get good praise, but I don't know if they are really superior and if that translates to anything meaningful for the owner.

    A power vent gas tank unit (which uses the fan and may use pvc vent pipe) may have a slightly higher energy factor. The usually cost $1200-1500 and the main attraction is that they can solve venting problems. The burner won't work unless the fan is running, so you don't have to worry about that. The downside, besides the cost, is the fan adds additional point(s) of failure.

    Standard gas tankless units have an energy factor of ~.85-87. They can be vented through a sidewall but require Stainless Steel venting that is expensive. Cost is typically $800-1200 for the unit + vent. They can solve venting problems, space problems and provide continuous hot water. Note that the cost is about the same as a power-vent tank unit. If you go this way, you need to do your homework on min flow rates, proper sizing, venting and gas line sizing. They save about 39% on energy costs over standard tank and may have tax and utility incentives. Avoid Bosch units.

    Condensing Tankless: Energy Factors ~.93-.95 They vent through PVC pipe thereby solving the cost issue of the SS vent. All of the other benefits of tankless. Cost generally $1600-2200. These aren't generally worth the price difference from a standard tankless unless it solves a venting problem by using affordable vent materials.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks Jake for giving me some real info, it's much appreciated.

    What's the deal with sidewall venting? I am assuming that any venting I'd have to run would need to run above the roof due to the fact that I have no wall space not below or next too a window.

    Otherwise it sounds like I'm safe going with pretty much any tank manufacturer other than those you advised against.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm not sure what the question is regarding sidewall venting. Elaborate a little more on your question. There are code restrictions on venting near an opening so that CO doesn't get back into the building. Heater manufacturers usually provide some good diagrams, but you need to know local code.

    How old is the vent on your existing? If it is at least as old as the heater you will want to check it for corrosion and holes. Will it last another 10-12 years(the life of the new heater)? Is it sharing a vent with something else? The typical problem is that flue gasses condense in a long flue run and the acidic condensate eats up the metal.

    If you need to replace your flue, I would at least run the numbers on a heater that could vent sidewall if you can, or through PVC.

    Other than that, I would say that you could use about any brand of heater other than the Whirlpool flame-lock that seems to be problematic. You can always google the brand that you intend to buy and see if comes back with a lot of bad press.

    I don't mean to be flippant with other people's money, but when a 40 gal water heater is $400 or so and just about any will last 8-12 years, I don't see worrying about one brand over another. The Ford vs Chevy debate can go on forever.

    If I was a plumber installing a ton of heaters and someone else was picking up the tab for the heater while I'm picking up the cost of a call-back, it might be a different story.

  • 17 years ago

    In your case, replace with similar (no power vent, no tankless, etc.) Pick the one with a long warrantee and you'll be fine.

    Consumer reports reviewed water heaters a couple years ago. Might want to pay a visit to your local library.

  • 17 years ago

    I second the Consumer Reports idea if you want to delve that far into it. I don't know about the long warranty. I think what you will find is that the warranty on a standard tank unit covers parts only, not labor and there will be a debate about if the failure is covered by the warranty.

    What a lot of people have said is that the heaters with the longer warranty were the same heater as shorter warranty but simply cost more.

    The chances of using a long warranty isn't good. Most people will move/forget/not keep documentation/not want to fight/etc. After about 4 years on a standard tank gas heater, it's not worth it to spend the money in labor to repair anything other than a thermocouple, a TPV or maybe an anode.

  • 17 years ago

    I wasn't really implying to use the warrantee, but I read somewhere (maybe the consumer report article) that there is a correlation between how long they can last and the warrantee. Main difference is a larger anode, I think. (that's the thing that rusts "sacrificially" to keep the rest of the unit from rusting out prematurely - so when the anode is spent, it's time for the unit to rust.)

    This reminds me (yet again) that we're long overdue to replace ours. We have a Rheem installed in 1985 that's still running great. Since I finished the basement, this is a project that I keep meaning to get to....thanks for the reminder!

  • 17 years ago

    rheem,state,a o smith , i am a plumber, the list goes on and on, as far as i am concerned the ones i mentioned are good, now a days there all good, i have a rinai tankless
    with the side vent cost around $1000.oo gas
    plus i have a 40 gallon electric as a backup
    a water heater will last 5 years or more longer if
    home ownerswill drain and flush once a year as a maintaince
    regiment

  • 17 years ago

    Yeah, but how many folks will bother to flush it yearly? I'd guess it's practically zero percent (maybe less!).

  • 17 years ago

    Yeah, but how many folks will bother to flush it yearly? I'd guess it's practically zero percent (maybe less!).I flush our hot water heater annually, so you will need to count me in your statistics. Also, I chose a tank unit for three reasons:

    1) We reside in an earthquake prone area and can use the tank water if necessary.

    2) During power failures we still have hot water.

    3) We have a hot water recirculating system (built at the time of construction). Yes, I know that you can put a recirculating system on a tankless, but the hassle and the results are not worth the changeover. Plus, it reduces your warranty on the tankless unit.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks all for info.

    Our venting is fine and is relatively new. We're just gonna replace it a new tank then. I'm pretty sure I won't flush it every year, but I doubt we'll spring for a longer warranty.

    I'll stay away from the Whirlpools though.

  • 17 years ago

    do this it will make flushing easier, replace the plastic drain with a 3/4 brass nipple and a FULL PORT ball valve
    pipe it to outside or a floor drain

  • 17 years ago

    consumer reports had/has a special publication "reducing energy costs" published sept 2006 (not a magazine , it's a 156 page book). on page 91 they say that they SAWED OPEN 28 wh's to see what was inside. they found that models with longer warranties typically were better products...(it goes on)....find and buy this book