Software
Houzz Logo Print
dgsg_gw

WS brine tank refill . . .

19 years ago

(2) hours BEFORE regeneration or AFTER regeneration and sits until next regeneration, 7-9 days?

Comments (6)

  • 19 years ago

    AFTER

  • 19 years ago

    There are those with a scientific background who say that 2 hours is not enough time to achieve maximum saturation of the brine solution at room temperature.

    I spoke to a chemist at North American Salt and he agreed, also noting that he has seen more clumping and bridging problems when repeatedly wetting and allowing the salt to dry out as "pre-fill" (before) does.

    I've experienced no downside to post-fill (after) so I'll continue to do it that way.

  • 19 years ago

    Salt does not dissolved quickly in cold, stagnant water, such as the conditions in a brine tank. It takes at least 12 hours and, under some conditions, over 24 hours to get a strong brine (salt) solution. A strong brine solution is absolutely essential to ensure complete, consistent regeneration of your softener resin. Poor regeneration will result in less-soft water and shorter resin life. Anyone who tells you that 2 hours is adequate is either a) incompetent or b) wanting to sell you more resin or equipment at an elevated price after yours quits softening.

  • 19 years ago

    Are there ANY drawbacks to post fill? I ask because of the three softeners I have had over 20+ years, they were ALL prefill, so I assume there must be reasons for each type of fill.

  • 19 years ago

    Okay here's the only thing I can think of. Brine solutions can be corrosive. If you have a single-tank softener, where the resin tank is inside the brine tank, constant exposure to the brine might damage the resin tank or other components if they are made cheaply. Pre-fill is a way for manufactures to get away with using cheaper, inferior materials. Unless space is at a super-premium, always get a softener with separate brine tank.

  • 19 years ago

    Pre fill is used in most if not all big box store softeners and all Ecowater and a number of other national brands and softeners using some Autotrol and Fleck control valves and ALL Clack control valves if programmed for Pre fill.

    The same for soft water refill; most of the above softeners mentioned above and ALL Clack valves use soft water as brine refill whether they use Pre or Post refill, along with ALL twin tank type softeners regardless of the brand of control valve.

    Pre refill has been used for many years. If it didn't work right it wouldn't be used by so many manufacturers and I can say it does work and here is why.

    Most control valves are programmed for Pre fill to finish two hours before the regeneration begins; plus the time for the first backwash, usually 4-12 minutes, plus some of the 10-20 minutes it takes to suck the brine out of the tank during the brining position. So it is longer than two hours to begin with but sufficient to create more brine in the brine tank.

    More brine because there is always 2-3 gallons of fully saturated brine left in the brine tank after the brining cycle of the last regeneration with either Pre or Post brining control valves.

    The refill water mixes with the 2-3 gallons of fully saturated brine already in the tank and dissolves more salt into it, regardless of the temp of the refill water or the brine.

    Then the brine used by the resin is diluted to 8-12% by the slow rinse water used to suck the brine out of the brine tank and then, the free board water in the resin tank; free board is the water filled empty space above the level of resin in the resin tank.

    As long as the resin gets its 8-12% brine it will be regenerated to the extent of the salt dose and capacity settings the softener was sized and programmed for.

    An added benefit is the brine tank will not require cleaning near as often or at all as those using Post refill. Especially if the softener's brine tank has a salt grid and uses solar crystal salt rather than pellets and not salt substitute potassium chloride pellets. As some here testify to having to do with hot water at least annually if not sooner.