Software
Houzz Logo Print
momofred

11th hour countertop decision! help!!

15 years ago

Ugh, I thought I had it figured out, but my contractor and the stone yard rep have me second guessing myself.

My cabinets arrive TOMORROW!! I want to template and order the stone asap.

Cabs are a greyish creamy white with white glazing. Floors are a medium brown oak (not too dark, not too light), light fixtures and kitchen faucet are a brushed nickel and there is a 36" white fireclay farmhouse sink. Appliances are stainless steel and black. Wall color is BM Dried Parsley, adjacent dining room is BM Ivy Lane also with brushed nickel fixtures. I haven't picked out backsplash yet, but thinking of going with a speckled white subway tile (tbd).

I was going for a light, clean, airy look. Up until today, I had planned on a Caesarstone in Oyster. I loved the cream, grey and silver speckles with accents of brown and tan. I also loved the low maintenance aspect of quartzite. I have no 'issue' with granite, but just never found one I loved. I had a very poor quality granite in the house I rented that was possibly never sealed, it stained very easily and I HATED it. I am being told by GC and stone lady that experience is VERY rare.

Anyone BTDT, love/hate their quartzite, wish they had done natural stone?

The granite the slab yard had in that I am considering is Millennium Cream, it was light without being too light and had some nice brown swirls in it. It is cheaper than the caesarstone, currently waiting on a quote.

ahhh! I'm just so turned around on this now...someone straighten me out! thanks in advance! :0)

Here is a link that might be useful: {{!gwi}}

Comments (11)

  • 15 years ago

    Did you take your cabinet door to the stoneyard and like it with the granite? Ask for a sample and test it with all sorts of things that stain, i.e., red wine, oil, strawberries, etc. If it stains, try sealing the sample and test it again. Pictures would be helpful, but really you need to decide which kind of counter you want. I have granite and love it, but I have never heard of someone who got quartzite and regretted it. My granite is dark (verde butterfly) and is maintenance free. Don't let the stone yard people or your GC sway you if you really would prefer the Caesarstone.

  • 15 years ago

    For whatever it's worth, our old kitchen had extremely cheap granite in it (told by a couple of contractors that it was "the cheapest you can get"---lovely!)---and it was a dream from a performance perspective. No staining, no maintenance issues in the three years we used it, and they were able to get it out intact and took it off to be reused elsewhere. So I do think it's probably unusual to have lots of issues with it, if cheap granite that was VERY poorly installed (horrible seams, etc.) performed that well.

    I liked Caesarstone a lot, but the dealbreaker in the end was not being able to set hot pots directly on it, since we got accustomed to being able to do that with the granite. I know I should use trivets anyway, but the chances of screwing it up once and having to live with the costly consequences scared me off of it. So that might be one thing to consider. (I don't know what happens if you set hot things on Caesarstone; just know that the dealer and literature both said no-no-no!)

    Also, FWIW Caesarstone is manmade quartz, which is different from quartzite---that's a separate type of natural stone.

  • 15 years ago

    I personally like the Caesarstone in oyster better than the granite you linked to. In my remodel, I am coming to the conclusion that my first "gut" instincts have generally been my best instincts, and when I start second guessing myself or listening too much to others is when I start veering away from what is "right" for me.

  • 15 years ago

    artemis- I'm very confused, I have heard exactly the opposite (research, GC and slab yard all concur) about caesarstone v. granite as far as scorch-ability is concerned. Granite it is not recommended to set hot pots where as caesarstone they say it's 'okay' but always of course recommend a trivet regardless. Anyone else heard this? Very confusing.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm going to surprise even myself, and recommend you go with the granite. I think you need the warmer tones in your kitchen, to keep it from being too cool and gray.

    Normally, I'm not a big fan of granite, but that is very pretty granite and I think it would give you a wonderful palette, from which to pull paint colors and fabics :)

  • 15 years ago

    @momofred, I'm not sure whether or not you're supposed to with granite---I just know that we did with no consequences whatsoever. :) (I also have no idea how/if our granite was sealed since it was already there.)

    The Caesarstone technical sheet says short-term contact won't harm the counter, but hot cookware should never be placed directly on the counter. The warranty also says thermal shock can occur so it does not cover damage from hot pots. That said, we have friends with Caesarstone who aren't especially careful with it, so it could be that the problems are pretty rare---I just didn't want to mess with it when, for the same price, we had the option of going with a material where I didn't have to think about it. If you aren't as lazy and/or absent-minded as I am, you probably don't have much to worry about! ;)

  • 15 years ago

    I think either the granite you've shown us or the oyster Caesarstone will look great. One way I would decide is to ask myself if I want the kitchen to read a bit more modern, clean, and contemporary or a bit more traditional, classic, old-world. To me the beautiful oyster Caesarstone looks very fresh (like a Sarah Richardson kitchen). The granite looks more traditional. Both are great looks. But which look do you want? Could you do the Sweeby test?

  • 15 years ago

    As Artemis wrote, quartz (not used for countertops) is different from quartzite (natural stone which is used for countertops) which is different from manufactured quartz (i.e. Caesarstone, Cambria, Silestone) so be sure you have your terminology right when you're trying to research specific properties.

    The following recent thread, about using crockpots on manufactured quartz, might give you some answers. Especially scroll down about half-way for Live_Wire_Oak's informed explanation.

    All the best with your decision.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Engineered Quartz versus Crockpots

  • 15 years ago

    Well, I'm not a good person to ask since have never been a fan of ceaserstone.
    I love the granite you are considering!

    I had granite in my previous house and always put hot pans on it. It was a very dark granite so the only issue was the cleaning. If you go with the Millennium Cream, I'm guessing it would be easier to clean.

  • 15 years ago

    My first post! I am remodeling my kitchen at the beach and every time I run a search, it leads me here. All that said, your last decision was my first. I love granite and natural stone. I choose my slabs first - millennium cream. I've been back to visit it several times and just love it - it's not common, it's light and has beautiful colors. My granite at home is dark and I have never had a problem. I put hot pots directly on the granite. My installer used some of the extra granite to make me a portable cutting board - I use it if something is extremely hot, but as I said, never had a problem with heat.

    As a side note, I am painting my cabinets a cream (haven't decided exact color yet), porcelain brown tiles on floor (not too dark, not too light) and a farm sink. Will you post pics? What I am doing sounds so similar to what you have done. So many great choices...but sooo many choices! What sink did you pick? I'm deciding between Kohler Dickenson and Rohl/Shaw. Thanks!

  • 15 years ago

    Of course you should do what moves you....having said that. I would pick granite if price is not a factor. It's a natural material and each piece has it's own personality. It may not matter to you but for future resale, granite is much more desirable. I've had 2 homes with granite over the past 12 years, I've never sealed them and have had every kind of spill possible and put hot pots directly on it with no ill effects. Can't say that about anything else I own! Good luck!