Software
Houzz Logo Print
dtchgrl

Help with countertop choices/combo

17 years ago

Hi All,

I'm hoping you can help give me some perspetive and direction on which path to try first for countertops. I sense this is going to be long, so thanks to anyone who gets through it all!

Floors are light golden oak, soon to be refinished but staying in same color to match rest of house. Perimeter cabinets will stay with current light golden maple cabinet. (So those two elements are about the same). New island cabinets will be a stained (not painted) sea green with some small knots in panels and small amount of distressing. Appliances will be stainless. Wall color and backsplash is yet to be determined but my initial choice for backsplash is "shiny" ceramic or crackle or glass subway tile in a soft color.

Perimeter and island together, there is approx 120 sq feet of counter (not counting any for a backsplash). Island will have two parts - a counter height work space and then a drop down to table height big enough to seat 6, with 3 facing each other like a table.

Initially I thought dark granite like Ubatuba or similar (Verde peacock, etc) everywhere. I like the 3-d effect and bits of different colors, and it seems tough as nails. But the little sample I have gets smeary fingerprints sooo easily. I wonder if it would make me crazy. And not sure about a big table of granite to eat almost every meal from...seems a bit cold. And thats a lot of shiny mirror like surface. I'm pretty sure I don't want a lighter granite everywhere as I don't want a "shades of beige" look as I"ve got a lot of lt. maple cabinets.

Then I found Soapstone. Got samples and happen to really like one that is mostly a dark, dark, dark green background (almost black) with some light green splotches (reminds me of the small circles of moss/lichen I get on my north facing slate walkway in the early spring. It also happens to be on sale for $59 per sq foot which sounds reasonable for soapstone. This particular sample did not scratch easily and I'm Ok with gentle scratches and oiling. BUT, if this is everywhere including the eating part of the island, I wonder if that is a lot of dark surface, and again, do we want to eat off of stone every night. Also, this kitchen is not modern, or rustic or "restoration"...which is where I mostly see the Soapstone.

One or two friends have advise to have the same surface on both perimeter and island b/c the island already has different cabinets. These are friends with good taste but I don't think they have seen the lovely kitchens I've seen here with completely different islands.

So, I started looking in to wood for the eating part of the island. Its expensive, but with one estimate I got, I could swing it just a bit over budget. Supposedly they use a "marine finish" and this part would just be for eating, but I'm worried about wear and tear (not sure what "marine finish" is anyway!). And would it be strange to have wood on this part of the island and something else on the prep part? What type of wood and stain? Maybe stay in the golden family but could do a bit darker?

Scroll down page for stain options: http://www.rrcwoodcountertops.com/finishoptions.shtml

Here is general layout. Note that there ARE light maple cabinets all around; the back wall to the right of the pantry has the fridge and then 9 linear feet of counter/cabinets/cooktop and then the far right wall has the sink and over 13 linear feet of counter/cabinets. These are not shown b/c there was no changes from what we h

ave now.

Here is general look of cabinets, colors:

Here is sample of Soapstone but had a hard time picking up the light green of the blotches, they look washed out here. Ignore knobs,they will be changed.

Here is Ubatuba sample

So, what surface or combo do you think will look the best as a total package? What about function and how long it will stay looking nice?

Thanks so much if you got this far!!

Here is a link that might be useful: wood stain choice

Comments (2)

Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH