Software
Houzz Logo Print
snoopyb_gw

Condo question - no board?

19 years ago

I recently went to view a new construction condo, 3units total. The condo was built from the ground up; there was nothing in the lot beforehand. I was shown the condo by the developer/builder/contractor. The condo has common charges but he told me that there would be no board setup. Instead all of the condo owners would be the "board" and we would have to put the common charges in an account, etc.

Is this normal for there not to be an outside property manger to take care of this?

I know that in other condos the board may consist of condo owners but isn't usually overseen by an outside property manager/lawyer who doesn't have a personal interest in the property?

Also, the way the condo is setup is such that the 1st floor as sole access to the basement, then there is a 2nd floor and then a 3rd floor which has sole access to the roof. He said that if anything happens to the roof, the owner of the 3rd floor condo would have to pay for it. It is not something that all of us would have to pay for since it is not a common area. Same for the basement.

Is this a good setup? I can see future potential problems with this, but if this is not unheard of maybe my reservations are unwarranted.

Thanks

Comments (7)

  • 19 years ago

    I am not a condo expert by any means. My answers are based on my personal experience.

    I own a condo that is wholly managed by the owners, no professional manager or management company. We do have a paid person who does bookkeeping and general cleaning of the common areas. There are 15 units. We have investigaged hiring a management company, but can't find one that wants to work with such a small group of condos without charging a huge fee on a per condo basis.

    I really can't comment on the other issue you have - the top floor gets the ownership of the roof and the bottom unit gets the use and ownership of the basement. In my very limited experience, I've never seen such an arrangement.

  • 19 years ago

    The fact that there's no condo board and that you just share expenses isn't unusual, at least in my area. There are lots of condo conversions in 2- and 3-family houses, and that's what's usually done. I would find it silly to pay for a company to handle what's so easy to do myself.

    I live in a semi-detached house which is legally a condo. We don't have a board or condo fees. When the bills come in, we just throw in half the money and send it off.

    The thing I'd be worried about is how the common areas are set up. The outside perimeter of the building - including the roof - should be a common area. It's easy to imagine a scenario where the roof is failing and the third-floor owners decide to do a bad patch-up job, just to save money. Then you - presumably on the first or second floor - want to sell your condo, but prospective owners are turned off by the bad shape of the roof.

    I have to say, I'd pass on this, and I'm not a worried or paranoid person. I'd just hate not having any control over such a vital part of the building.

    Are the other units sold yet? If not, perhaps the builder could be persuaded to change the condo documents to reflect what's more usual.

  • 19 years ago

    Consider making the roof and basement a "limited common element" - at least I think that's the proper term. That would give the upper floor sole use of the roof but the other owners could force the 3rd floor owner to maintain the roof. The balconies on our condo are limited common elements. The association is forcing everyone to repair their balconies since their conditions have deteriorated over time.

    Better yet - talk to an attorney that specializes in condo law. It will be money well spent.

  • 19 years ago

    The lack of a professional/outside board is not unusual in my area, especially in smaller developments. Typically all owners are board members and they vote on shared costs/improvements and majority rules. The only time they bring an outsider is usually a lawyer, in case one of the owners refuses to comply with whatever the majority agreed upon.

    But the basement/roof arangement seems very odd and that would worry me. What if the basement floods or the roof caves? It may not be a common area for access - but it sure impacte the entire building.

  • 19 years ago

    I don't like the idea of the potential problems that you all have touched upon. I didn't even consider how damage to the roof affects the whole building so we would all be in trouble if the roof was repaired/maintained incorrectly by the 3rd floor owner.
    And I could even see how this could be problem if we buy the 1st floor and our contract says we are not responsible for the roof. However, the 3rd floor owner may have a different understanding and want everyone to share in the cost if not out of the common charges.

    This is something I would consider if I could talk to the other buyers. But since it is all through the contractor/seller I don't know what the other owners are coming into this thinking.

    Thanks for all the replies.

  • 19 years ago

    Walk away. Seriously. Normally, the roof would be a common element. It is ridiculous to expect one unit to have to cover that maintenance and replacement costs. Are there gutters? Are they also the responsibility of the top unit?
    Does the unit that has sole access to the basement cost more? Likewise, the top unit - what is meant by access anyway, unless you are referring to the attic.

  • 19 years ago

    It all sounds to wishy washy and open to interpretations. I wouldn't even consider it. Most states and provinces have rules and regulations as to how much money must be kept for major repairs, how much could be used for discretionary enhancements etc. and details what the differences between those things are.