Software
Houzz Logo Print
kahlanne_gw

Question about addition

18 years ago

We have decided to add a 900 sq foot addition to our home. I have designed the plan myself using a really nice design program that a friend of mine loaned me after using it for their home design a few yrs ago. Basically, I have decided to extend our hallway out the end of our home to create the new space. We would not be removing any existing walls or changing existing spaces other than the hallway. We will add a master bedroom and bathroom, small bathroom with small shower, utility room, and another small bedroom. I am wondering if anyone can give me an idea of what it may cost per square foot for this addition. I know there are a lot of factors but I am wanting a rough estimate. We live near Baton Rouge, LA and homes in our area sell for $100-$110 per sq foot for new homes. Am I right in guessing it can't be more than $100/sq foot to build since they wouldn't be able to sell a new house for the building cost? Do you have a guess as to how much it may run? We actually hope to cut costs by doing the floors, painting, and just whatever we can ourselves but I need an idea. Not sure if this matters or not but our home is a basic rectangle ranch with a hip roof and our addition is just making it more of a rectangle. I am not sure how the roof will work but I assume it will stay a hip roof.

Btw, my friends are completely building it themselves and with cash as available so they don't know how much they have spent or will spend which is why I can't ask them.

Thanks again.

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thing is, the $/ft for an addition can actually run more than building a stand alone.

    Why? There's the roof, for one thing: depending on the age of your house, you may end up having to re-roof the whole thing to get it to match. Same with siding.

    You may have to change some flooring to maintain a sense of flow. Because you really don't want the addition to seem like an addition. I've known people who just stuck it on, planned to integrate it 'eventually', and never got around to it. The result was bigger, but an eyesore from the outside, and disjointed on the inside.

    And the electric system may not have that much expansion room. You may end up making significant revisions in the existing structure in order to expand it.

    On the upside, kitchens are generally the most expensive rooms, and you already have one of those. But baths can be just as bad if you have expensive taste. Be sure to design for standard size vanities and showers, consider using one piece showers instead of custom tile.

    My guess is if you are lucky, you can get the job done for a bit less than a new build, but if things break against you, plan on spending that $110/ft and then some.

    Though I'm a big believer in sweat equity, it's really hard to quantify just how much you save. On some jobs a lot [I love to paint and I'm good at it], on some-- if you lack the basic skills needed, etc-- it can actually cost you in lost time and wasted materials. Know your limits, I say: I've done my own tile on the floors, but I'm letting a pro do the walls [after I've hung the kerdi]-- I'm running out of both time and inclination, and walls make me nervous. While he's tiling, I can be doing other things.

    Place to start is your local planning or sanitation office, if you have them. You need to find out if theres a limit to the Number of bedrooms allowed in your area, if the septic or sewer system will need to be updated with 2 more bedrooms and bathrooms-- around here, the # of bedrooms dictates how big the septic tank and drainfeild need to be. We can declare some rooms to be storerooms, and 'just happen' to keep a bed and dresser in there. Some localities consider it a bedroom if there's a closet, though-- like you don't need a closet in an office.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I appreciate your help oruboris. I understand your thoughts on sweat equity. My husband is very handy and has installed everything from hardwood flooring, cork click together floors, moldings, and tile floors. However, he decided not to install the tile on our bathroom walls and hired it done instead. I love to paint and can to a great job if I say so myself so that isn't going to be any problem. My husband has done electrical work in the past but prefers to leave that to the experts this time. We just had a new septic tank installed and I will check and see if it is large enough. Here is hoping! As for number of bedrooms allowed, there is no zoning or restrictions in this area. We are rural.
    As for the roof, we will replace our existing roof which would have to be done soon anyway so I know that will increase the cost. We have brick on the house and are hoping to reuse what is removed and stucco the entire front. However this isn't set in stone yet.
    As for electric, I am not sure about it. I know the power company said we have a larger box/system??? than needed for a house this size but I don't really know what that means or if that is helpful.

    As for the costs of the baths, my taste can get expensive and I do plan to splurge but I was hoping to get a general estimate and any of my splurges would cost extra.

    Anyway, thanks so much for the help.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Okay, lets try again...
    I would love input on our new addition. The house is a basic rectangle ranch with hip roof which we hope to keep since we are adding on to one side only. The addition will carry the existing hall out and then turn to run the length of our "now" mbr. We did this to give assess to the pool outside that door from the new bath and utility. This new addition will give us 5 bedrooms and 4 baths for our family of 7. If you have any suggestions or questions please let me know. Thanks.

    Here is my pic if the link doesn't work...
    {{gwi:2064675}}

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You want to add 900 sq ft. How big is your present house? How old is it? What are neighboring homes like? How large is your lot? What is the value of the land alone? How long will you live in this house? How long will you need 5 BRs and 4 baths?

    What will your enlarged house be worth? Are there larger existing homes you could buy for less (and spare yourselves a year of remodeling)? Could you build an all-new home for bbout the same as what your remodeled one would bring?

    I have no problem with your planned addition. I'm only wondering if adding on is the wisest choice.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Could you pot the master bedroom on the other side of the house?

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The existing master bedroom is the bedroom and bath directly above the existing hall. Like I said, the old master will become a bedroom for two of my children. We can also use it as a guest room in the future.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am going to try to answer all of your questions.

    Our present home is 1800 sq feet and was built in 1978. We have one nearby neighbor whose home is similar in style and age to ours.

    Our lot is slightly over 2 acres. Land values in this area are on the rise but there are few small acres to be bought. I can still find lots in subdivisions at $25,000 for slightly under half and acre. You can find large amounts of acres sold together but the cost is usually too expensive for a homeowner. For instance, not a mile from our home is 18 acres that is listed for a little over $500K. Our land should hold its value and cont. to rise in cost due to the popularity of this area. We are only 1 mile from the best schools in the state, have easy access to a major hwy, and is a short drive to town.

    We plan to make this our permanent home. I honestly don't see us moving until retirement and maybe not even then. Our kids all attend the local school which I mentioned are the best in the state. I can leave my driveway and drop off my elementary student in exactly 3 min. and my middle school student in 15 with heavy traffic. These schools are also the newest ones in the area. Baton Rouge is close enough that you can live outside the city but still have a relatively short commute to work. New Orleans is only a little over an hours drive where so much is at your fingertips.

    As for needing 5 bedrooms/4baths, we are a family of 7. My oldest daughter just turned 12 and has 6 more yrs of school before college. If she decides to go to LSU, it is close enough that she could even drive if that is her choice. I have a son age 8, a daughter that just turned 7, and another daughter that is 2. We are expecting our 5th, and last, child in March. The kids are young enough that I know having the extra rooms will be a plus.

    I have tried to find larger homes in this area but there just aren't any. This area was very rural until a few yrs ago and many of the old homes were torn down for subdivisions that consists of maybe 4 bedrooms tops. The only 5 bedrooms I found were not in our school zone and needed major work. We bought this house a few yrs ago and have remodeled it, added a pool, etc and are finally getting what we want. Starting over isn't an option unless it doesn't require as much work. Understand?

    The other two questions, I am not sure. I know that before we remodeled, after adding the pool, our home was valued at $175k. This has been a few yrs back so hopefully the time and money spent will show an increase in value. As to what it will be worth with new addition, I am not sure of that either. My thinking was that my home is valued at old appraisal $175,000 and we will add 900 sq foot. I was hoping this would increase the value by the average home value in this area of $100/sq foot. making it worth $275000. Then I was hoping that we could build the addition for the added cost of $100,000 or less. The other homes this size, including the older one that needs work is in the $300K range.

    As for building new, I am not sure. I do know that we can't afford to build on our property and have this house. We don't have any other place to stay while building, no local apts. The other issue is land costs. I dont' want a subdivision lot and we haven't seen under 10 acres sale in a while in this area.

    Sorry this was so long but I wanted to be thorough. Hope this helps you advise me more.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the answers! I have a better idea now of why you want/need to stay where you are, and that your family will be needing the space for quite a few more years. 2700 sq ft is certainly not *huge* and it doesn't seem as though you'd then own that bugaboo, the biggest house in the neighborhood.

    I'm still a little concerned that the addition will cost more than it will raise the value of the house as a whole. It still may be the best thing you could do...it just may not make the most financial sense. You will have a part-old, part-new house. (I don't know how much you have already updated the 1800 sq ft.) A house 30 years old isn't *very* old, but...well, I think you see why I'd hesitate.

    We bought a 1950's ranch on an acre and planned to remodel it. Our new next-door neighbor was a bank appraiser. He had the real estate knowledge to show us we would be ahead to tear down and build new. (An honest man, considering that then he had to live with the mess!)

    People seldom recoup remodeling expenses when they sell. The partly new/partly old house can't compare with all-new. Selling may be far in your future, but we can look at which would be worth more today. As I said, the dollars may not be the deciding factor for your family -- just something to consider when you are planning such a big addition.

    One example: Former neighbors added two bedrooms, a bath and a family room to their 3 BR house. The addition nearly doubled the size of the house. When they sold five years later they couldn't compete with newer houses or houses originally built with five bedrooms. The kitchen especially was viewed as too small for a house that big; LR and DR were also undersized. Although their family enjoyed the enlarged house, they came nowhere near to getting back the cost of the addition and it took a very long time to sell.