Software
Houzz Logo Print
cjaustin81

New Roof Install - Problems and issues.

12 years ago

Hello, I recently had my roof replaced a couple weeks ago due to a hail damage claim. It was a complete tear off and a new roof was installed. The work was completed on 8/5/2014. The crew was 3 guys (instead of 7) and it took them 2 days and over 15 hours to complete the roof. After install I noticed several issues with the roof, most importantly the shingles were not laying flat. I had the owner come out to look at the roof and showed him the shingle curling, bowing in areas, shingles sticking up, shingles lifting by the flashing, shingles coming off along a ridge, along with several other issues. I had the owner of the roofing company come out to the house to see the issues. He indicated that the shingles were installed "too closely" and that was causing the curling, lifting by the flash, and any other issues where they don't lay flat. He said the "bowing" was a result of the workers not trimming the shingles toward the edges of the roof, instead they just laid a full shingle down.

I'm obviously not happy with the work. They also didn't install a PVC boot correct (it's for the wrong slope they said) and all the areas by the flashing have shingles sticking up (since they were not trimmed properly). I'm very concerned with the work that was done.The owner indicated this was easy to fix and I asked him to explain how they intended on fixing all of these issues (there are over 75+ areas of curling/lifting). He indicated they simply need to "trim" a bunch of the shingles. I asked about the bowing, he indicated they would have to redo that area, same with the ridge that sticks up.

I told him I was not happy and that I did not receive my money's worth. The roof does not look right and it looks worse than my parents roof (who have the same shingle brand and color) which is 15 years old. I told the owner I will need the entire roof redone because there are a myriad of issues and trimming the shingles as a "fix" was not acceptable.

The summary of my issues are below:

Above Garage
1) Bowing/rippling going up the entire length of roof, this is towards the garage door.
2) The shingles by the flash don't look straight and are lifting.
3) Shingles are lifting in multiple spots. Not lying flat.
4) The last Roof Cap has exposed nails that are not sealed.
5) The edge of the roof (towards garage door) is jagged and hanging off.
6) The siding is exposed and sticking out on the area above front door.

Main Front area
1) The area where the 3 slopes meet looks terrible, not sitting flat.
2) Toward the right side, the last Roof Cap has exposed nails that are not sealed.
3) Multiple areas where the shingles are lifting.

Main Back Area
1) The back of the house has shingles that are lifting in multiple spots.
2) The pvc vent cover isn't correct, it�s wrinkled and isn't smooth. Looks to be the wrong size and looks worse than what all neighbors have.
3) The 2nd to the left vent cap is crooked (this is even after adjustment was made).

I wanted to get some opinions on here as to what you think?

Comments (23)

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here are a couple more pictures.

    shingles lifting by flash, several wavy sections


    curling visible on 2nd row from bottom



    roof is wavy

    roof is wavy in this section, flashing shingles are lifting


    bowing toward right of pic

    roof is uneven, due to bowing

    This post was edited by cjaustin81 on Thu, Sep 4, 14 at 15:42

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Get a reputable roofing consultant to look up the shingle manufacturer's installation instructions and compare them to the job. This may be invasive.

    I've done this for countertops; it's very powerful. The contractor is no longer arguing with you, they are arguing with the manufacturer.

    A good consultant will cost you, but will be well worth it for the leverage he'll provide.

    This is what happens when guys are paid by the square instead of the hour.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have contacted the Illinois Department of Financial & Professional Regulation and will be having the village come out to look at the work since a permit was required to do the work.

    Nobody ever inspected the work after it was done (Town inspectors or Insurance company) Which is very surprising to me.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I doubt the inspector will say there is anything wrong, they generally look for code violations not material not installed to the mfr specifications.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This is what happens when people don't care about their work. You might have a battle ahead financially, but get someone else to fix or replace the roof. The damage to your home from avoiding the inevitable will exceed any losses now. A reputable company would not allow this to happen to begin with. Where was the owner or forman then?

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    " Would you have a roofing company in the area do this? (one that was reputable) Or are there special roofing contractors out there I need to contact?"

    Shop around. Explain your problem and what you have in mind. Make clear you're not looking for free advice.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Are you sure the new shingles were not installed over the old shingles?

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Are you sure the new shingles were not installed over the old shingles?"

    Looks that way to me too.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Are you sure the new shingles were not installed over the old shingles?"

    I'm positive, I watched them remove the previous shingles. The bowing is because they didn't trim it right toward the rake. There's excess shingles bundling up in that area.

    My question is how would you guys go about fixing this? Would you have them redo sections that are off?

    I posted these pics in another forum > http://www.diychatroom.com/f9/new-roof-install-problems-issues-206052/index3/#post1400429

    and they are saying it doesn't look too bad. Obviously the pictures don't do it justice because in person these issues become much more apparent.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here are some new pictures (some w 16x zoom). This is the PVC boot I was referring to before:

    What on earth were they thinking??

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here's where 3 slopes come together. I'm no roofing expert.. but this doesn't look right. This looks like water could get in there. This part is horrific, how would you fix this?

    What were they thinking?

    Again, I had to use a 16x zoom to show you guys here, but in person it looks like crap from the ground.

    This is what it looks like from my yard when you look up.

    Another 16x zoom shot. Shingles are literally coming off. Could this even meet inspection? The town has not been out to inspect this yet..

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here's a better shot of that infamous garage picture (with a better camera this time)

    Notice how at the top there's 2 exposed nails. Also notice how the 'edge' of the roof isn't trimmed straight. Notice again how the shingles are not done per GAF instructions with a starter shingle, then 2nd shingle and so on.

    How would they 'fix' this?

    Look at the bottom-right, it looks weird. At 3/4 of the way up you can see the overhang isn't cut straight. At the bottom right it doesn't look like they did the rake per GAF spec.

    I showed a professional roofer this picture and he said they 'dutch lapped' the rake and didn't install it correctly. He indicated the finished edge should always be exposed to the exterior.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This is how the ridge was capped

    Flashing

    They reused the old flashing here

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Another picture of that infamous bowing edge, I just noticed it looks like the shingles were "torn" in the bottom-right..

    more pics..

    Now this is the "other" side of the "bowing" roof. This side looks better but not that great either.

    And back to the infamous side. I'm demanding a redo of this slope for sure.

    Another angle.

    Here's the 'main' slope or the front of the house. I'm worried there may be issues here too.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have a professional roofer coming over Saturday to access the repairs needed and/or if the entire roof needs to be replaced. He's worried that the roof might not even be nailed correctly.

    I haven't notified my insurance about these issues yet (I'm waiting to get my report from the roofers).

    I demanded a new roof be installed last Tuesday when the owner called asking if he can start repairing the roof. The owner said he would get back to me and he hasn't yet. It's been over a week.

    I signed a contract with them (they are a GAF Certified installer) to do the roof and siding. I now want out of that contract. I'm not sure they followed the insurance procedures correctly because they did the roof install before my insurance had received the affidavit of work from the roofing company. You could tell the owner seemed like they may have missed a step.

    I have not paid them anything yet, I still have my insurance checks.

    Here's the thing though.. the company I hired is GAF certified and bonded with the state of IL. However, I did NOT know they were going to sub contract the work out to another company. I don't know if the company they sub contracted the work to is GAF Certified or even a licensed roofing company (which is required in the state of IL).

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You can get a representative of the shingle manufacturer to stop and look at the job too! Since there is a warranty on the shingles. They would be the ultimate experts on installing shingles since they manufacturer them and should use their installation techniques. I would give the shingle manufacturer a call and get the local warranty rep to do a drive by and look at the installation first hand!

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It does look pretty crappy.
    I hope you get it all sorted out.
    When i had a new roof installed it leaked 4 times in 2 different areas and i had to keep calling the company back to fix it.
    It was reall annoying because they gave me one of the most expensive estimates. And i had to pay our of pocket.
    It was not an insurance claim.

    Goodluck

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "I have not paid them anything yet, I still have my insurance checks."

    Your problems are over.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Do not pay them anything until you are satisfied.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm confused you said the owner came out & then owner of roofing company in next sentence. Are you renting the house, if you are that is the owner of the house's responsibility, he would be expected to pay for the roof, not the renter. I'd insist they start over as that is a mess.

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There is no fixing that hot mess. Unbelievable. Don't get sucked into a "repair" that only serves his interests.

    Looks like they shingled over the old roof. Make sure to have all removed and start over with a decent company. This one doesn't have a clue. Have it redone asap before you have water damage to contend with too.

    Good luck! What a pain!

  • 4 years ago

    I know this is a few years ago, but what was the outcome? I just had architectural shingles installed and noticed the same wavey-ness, doesn't look right.

    Thanks