Software
Houzz Logo Print
billyinalabama

grounding the water regulator?

19 years ago

The guy doing the electrical is telling me I need to buy 150 ft of the #4 solid copper ground wire to run from the outside panel to the water regulator. Has anyone heard of this? I know I have to have the ground run to the rods drove in the ground outside, maybe 20 ft, but the water regulator? My plumbing is pex and pvc.

Comments (22)

  • 19 years ago

    Regulator or meter? Very few homes I have seen actually have a regulator.

    Even if your home is plumbed with plastic, if the main line coming in from the street is metallic (copper, etc.), you MUST use this pipe as the main grounding electrode. The connection to this pipe electrode must be made within 5' of where the pipe enters the house. Any meters or plastic filters, etc, must be jumpered around with the bond/ground wire.

  • 19 years ago

    There is 1 1/2 inch pvc running from the meter by the road, 700 ft by my driveway. It runs under the front porch then turns to 3/4 inch copper that runs up from the ground about 3 feet then turns into the basement to a brass water regulator. There is a fitting that changes it to pex from the regulator. It's only 3 ft of copper. The regulator is on one end of the house and the panel or service box is on the other end. It will be about 70 to 80 feet of the ground wire to do this. I just want to make sure it's needed before I buy the copper ground.

  • 19 years ago

    The metallic feed pipe needs to be in contact with the earth for at least ten feet. Yours obviously does not even come close.

    If your guy presses the issue and insists on this bond ask him for a code reference in writing. Unless you have some freaky local code requiring this he will not be able to prove his request.

    I am all for doing things to code and not one to cut corners. But I also have enough common sense to see that bonding/grounding a 3' piece of copper pipe will do absolutely nothing.

  • 19 years ago

    Just a clarification.
    I should have said:
    "The metallic feed pipe needs to be in contact with the earth for at least ten feet to be used as an electrode."

    Isolated sections larger than that should be bonded.

  • 19 years ago

    Don't forget, though, even if the copper section's that short, the water itself, and where it runs to, eventually back to a metal supply pipe of some sort (what are they made of these days?) all contribute to forming a ground, however, I guess it's worth checking if the code's applicable - although it's easier to do it now, during construction, than to add it in later if it's needed.

    I imagine 150' of #4 isn't going to be cheap, I'd diplomatically ask the plumber for the leftover afterwards.

  • 19 years ago

    "Don't forget, though, even if the copper section's that short, the water itself, and where it runs to, eventually back to a metal supply pipe of some sort (what are they made of these days?) all contribute to forming a ground,"

    Are you saying that you think the water itself is part of the grounding system???

    Short sections of isolated copper DO NOT have to be bonded.

    And the jury is still out on whether you were serious about the water comment.

    Also, what "leftover" would you ask the plumber for? The wire?

  • 19 years ago

    I thought per 250.52(A)#1-7 being your choices for electrode. Him choosing #5 (Gound rods). Then following code 250.104(A) bonding of metal water piping. Then 250.104(B) bonding the metal gas piping.** I have even had inspectors make me put a jumper from the cold to the hot side right above the hot water tank. they felt the tank stopped the metal pipe path.** Overall its only 3 ft worth of copper tubing but at least the system would be bonded. For any such reason the water did happen to get energized and he went to grab the metal facuet or hose bib it would not shock him.

    The code dosen't save money, it saves lives.

  • 19 years ago

    I tend to agree with lanelu on this point. Don't have my code book handy at the moment to look up chapter but any metla that is likely tp become energized must be bonded tp the grounding system. Water can carry electricity (well, actually water does not carry electricity, the minerals do, the regulator or meter could conveivably become energized from within. Do to this, I would agree with the inspector on this one.

    BTW lanelu: bonding across the water heater is not uncommon. It also provides a bond if the heater is removed as well. Also I have seen where a metal water faucet when the house plumbing is plastic, had to be bonded as well.

    Same theory as the regulator above.

  • 19 years ago

    Do either of you truly feel that 3' of pipe is a "system". 250.104(A) call for bonding of "metal water piping systems". Three feet is NOT a system, and bonding it is of NO consequence.

    The water DOES NOT get energized. Lets forget that fact for a while shall we. It is a piping system that can become energized.
    The only way an isolated section of pipe can become energized is if a live wire energizes it.

    lanelu, I think you need to read 250.104(B) a little closer regarding gas piping as well.

  • 19 years ago

    are you saying mineralized water will not carry electricity? You would think that if it didn't, GFCIs would not be required in a wet area.

    Now since all the water n a pipe is connected, it would make sense that all the water does indeed become energized. Now since the water is in contact with the meter/regulator or whatever, it would make sense that the regulator could in fact be energized due to a water contact.

    Not saying code requires it but as I said before, I have seeen an inspector require a metal faucet be bonded if plastic water supply piping is used.

    Theoretically it is a possibility.

    If you doubt me, hop in the bathtub with a hair dryer and no GFCI protection. Let us know how that works out.

    As well, have you ever been told to not take a bath or shower in a lightning storm?

    250.4(A)(4) states any metallic object likely to become energized must be bonded to the grounding system. Now is the regulator likely to become energized? I'll bet the AHJ requiring the faucets to be bonded would think so.

  • 19 years ago

    "Now is the regulator likely to become energized?"Absofreakinloutley not. Energized by what? NOT the water, I know that. The word is "likely".
    What is likely to energize a 3' section of copper pipe?

    Let's agree to disagree. You will NOT convince me that the water itself will energize a conduit.

    "Now since all the water n a pipe is connected,"
    Now this made me laugh out loud.

    ALL the items you mentioned are likely to become energized through a metallic conduit system.

    If an inspector asked me to bond a faucet first I would chuckle, then I would ask him for a code reference.
    Do you always automatically do what you are told, especially by an inspector? They are not infallible you know. Some are less experienced than many electricians.

    Build a house will all plastic supply and drain lines. Get a hair dryer, turn it on, bring it in the shower with you and I'll jump in. No problem.

    WATER IS NOT A GOOD CONDUCTOR. It does however make conductive materials better conductors.

  • 19 years ago

    drinking (tap) water has an electrical conductivity is 0.0005 to 0.05 siemens per meter, compared to 37.8 Ã 10^6 siemens per meter for aluminum.

    copper is 59.6 Ã 10^6 siemens per meter

    A huge difference

  • 19 years ago

    As stated previously, water is not a conductor of electricity at all. I attended a grounding seminar that emplployed a visual to prove this. The speaker held a neutral conductor while placing a hot conductor into a glass of water and then proceeded to drink from the glass. No injury. It is the mineral content that conducts the electricity. He was using purified water. The level of minerals would determine the level of conductivity and is very area specific.

    Water itself absolutley does not make anything a better conductor. As a matter of fact, that premise itself is very flawed. There is nothing that makes something else a better conductor by an external application. At best, it allows for a better connection, nothing more.

    Now to your acceptance of the hair dryer. A shower won't neccessarily do it. A stream of water from a shower is not continous and the draining water is unlikely to be so as well.

    Do a simple test to prove yourself right or wrong. Take a pot of water. Ground yourself. Take a bared hot wire and place it in the water being sure you do not touch anything other than the water. Now stick your hand in the water.

    Let me know how that works out. Until you test my theory, don't try to refute it. Mineralized water will carry electricity.

    regarding the inspectors requirement: all of us in the field understand that it is sometimes (read usually) in the best interest to simply abide by an inspectors odd interpretation of the code. Even if you win, you often eventually lose. It usually takes too long to dispute a finding with the state level authorities and you piss off the inspector who may now nit pick your work. I can guarantee you I can find a code violation in just about any job out there. It is a matter of cost versus benefits that we often do wht the inspector requires.

    So to the original question: although it is not truly within the codes intent (as most will interpret it), if the inspector in the area requires it, it is often the most prudent action to simply accomodate his requirememnts.
    The actions required to argue the requirement will prevent you from obtaining a certificate of occupancy until it is resolved and in my state, that could be in excess of 6 months.

    As well, I don't know what you feel your time is worth but the cost of the wire is much less than the time it will take to dispute the requirement. This isn't to say you need to blindly accept the requirement. It usually doesn't hurt to ask for justification. The inspectors in my state are required to give chapter quote justification for such things. It may give the inspector reason to pause and rethink things.

  • 19 years ago

    "regarding the inspectors requirement: all of us in the field understand that it is sometimes (read usually) in the best interest to simply abide by an inspectors odd interpretation of the code. Even if you win, you often eventually lose. It usually takes too long to dispute a finding with the state level authorities and you piss off the inspector who may now nit pick your work. I can guarantee you I can find a code violation in just about any job out there. It is a matter of cost versus benefits that we often do wht the inspector requires."

    Sorry, but I do NOT live by this rule. I have a very good relationship with the inspectors in my area. Maybe it is because they are third party inspectors NOT affiliated with the state and do not have the "god complex" many inspectors do. If I feel they are incorrect about a requirement I simply say say hey, where is that in the code. We look it up. If it is there I was wrong. If not they are wrong. It DOES happen both ways.





    "So to the original question: although it is not truly within the codes intent (as most will interpret it), if the inspector in the area requires it, it is often the most prudent action to simply accomodate his requirememnts."

    Even if you are the OP and will cost you 150' of #4cu and about 2 hours???

  • 19 years ago

    Even if you are the OP and will cost you 150' of #4cu and about 2 hours???

    and for no benefit? Not worth it, If i was the OP I would definitely be asking for a code reference from the inspector (then I assume if he can't provide he can't violate you for not adhering to his "requirement")

  • 19 years ago

    he can use 250(A)(4) and his beliefs. How are you going to argue what "may become energized" and what won't. While it is highly unlikely, as long as the AHJ believes it may, that would allow him to interpret that section as he sees fit (as allowed and directed by the code itself).

    The only way to argue the point at that is to contest it is to take it to a higher authority. In my area that would be the state board and they only meet once every 6 months (I believe).

    It could be a long wait for vindication.

    Just because you argue a point does not mean you are right and it doesn't mean the AHJ is going to change his position.

    The cost of the material and labor may be justified depending upon the circumstances.

  • 19 years ago

    From petey racer: ""I think you need to read 250.104(B) a little closer regarding gas piping as well.""

    My 2005 NEC 250.104(B)code says, "where installed in or attached to a building or structure, metal piping system(s), including GAS piping, that is likely to become energized SHALL be bonded......"

    Just curious what yours said or the point you were trying to make.

    Yes the AHJ(Wash. State) makes us take a #4 str to the gas. piping

  • 19 years ago

    The BC code seems to state quite clearly that gas pipe should be bonded to the water pipe; when I do some mods in my furnace room, including a whole-house water filter, I figured it would be a convenient way and time to bond the two, since I will have to run a #6 ground wire (apparently #6 is appropriate for my setup) as a jumper across the plastic-bodied water filter, I figure just an extra clamp and don't even cut the wire where it goes to the water pipe, just run it through the clamp and onto the gas pipe.

    I am planning this, on the basis that I haven't seen a bond on the gas pipe anywhere, yet I have probably the best view of most of the gas pipe in the furnace room (you can see a 'plenum' or duct the pipe runs right through, to the wall where it originates at the gas meter)

    So, question is, if a water-gas bond already exists elsewhere and I've just missed it or it's obscured, will it be a technical problem or violation (in most codes) if there's two separate water-gas bonds?

  • 19 years ago

    Keep reading......

    "(B) Other Metal Piping Where installed in or attached to a building or structure, metal piping system(s), including gas piping, that is likely to become energized shall be bonded to the service equipment enclosure, the grounded conductor at the service, the grounding electrode conductor where of sufficient size, or to the one or more grounding electrodes used. The bonding jumper(s) shall be sized in accordance with 250.122, using the rating of the circuit that is likely to energize the piping system(s). The equipment grounding conductor for the circuit that is likely to energize the piping shall be permitted to serve as the bonding means. The points of attachment of the bonding jumper(s) shall be accessible.

  • 19 years ago

    The gas suppliers are scared sh**less by bonding.
    Steel pipes are often the 'sacrificial anode' when a copuple occurs in soil woth electrolytes and moisture present.
    The gas pipe bonding requirement was in and then out of the NEC in short order, replaced by the rule above.

    A water leak from corrosion is one thing, a gas leak is another.

  • 19 years ago

    Peteyracer said:

    "Don't forget, though, even if the copper section's that short, the water itself, and where it runs to, eventually back to a metal supply pipe of some sort (what are they made of these days?) all contribute to forming a ground,"
    Are you saying that you think the water itself is part of the grounding system???

    Short sections of isolated copper DO NOT have to be bonded.

    And the jury is still out on whether you were serious about the water comment.

    Also, what "leftover" would you ask the plumber for? The wire?" end quote

    Was that necessary? Of course I meant the leftover wire, to ensure the sparky wasn't profiteering, what did you think I meant, his lunch? OP was mentioning he didn't see where that figure came from.

    I never said water made a GOOD ground, but it does form part of it. Grounding spikes don't make much of a ground in soil that's totally dry....

    I received a very large shock, turning something off whilst standing in water, so I can attest that water makes a good enough ground to make a difference.

  • 19 years ago

    Was what necessary? The question?
    Why would you be asking the plumber for leftover wire???? Are you saying the plumber is doing the bonding??
    I wish I could convince a plumber it is his job to do the bonding.

    "Grounding spikes" (ground rods), or water, do NOT "make" any ground at all.

    Let's just leave this topic for now. I think we are beating a dead horse and will never agree.