Software
Houzz Logo Print
tony41

Code ? 210.19 (A) (3) Ex.1 Tap conductors

19 years ago

Here is a Continuing Education for Electricians in AR

Translating 210.19 (A)(3)Ex.1

An electric counter-mounted cooking unit & small wall mounted oven are tapped from a 50 amp branch circuit. The Small wall mounted oven is rated 15 amps, the counter-mounted coking unit is rated 25 amps. The minimum size tap conductors to each appliance are:

a. #14 to the oven;#12 to the cook top

b. #12 to the oven; #14 to the cook top

c. #10 to the oven; #12 to the cook top

d. #10 to the oven; #8 to the cook top

Since all tap conductors must be minimum of 20amps #14 thrown out.

My thought would be #12 to the oven; #10 to the cook top but this not a option.

Is C the answer?

Comments (7)

  • 19 years ago

    I would agree with you; 20A (#12) to the oven and 30A (#10) to the cook top. Maybe answer "C" is backwards by mistake.

  • 19 years ago

    As stated above, none of the choices presented match EXACTLY the MINIMUM conductor sizes for those specific loads as determined by the cited article. But of the choices presented in the possible answers, only "d" fully complies with the cited article. d would be my choice.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks Gentlemen for you replies.
    I have been out of the trade for 10 years due to physical disability. When your out of the loop that long a person looses confidence with interpertation.
    I keep my Master's License out of sentimentalism and don't want to give up hope of physical condition improving someday.
    Arkansas just implemented required 8 Hours of Continuing Education every 3 years & I agree its needed. The Home Study Course Test (Jade Learning & Mike Holt; AR approved courses) to me is much better learning tool than sitting in a room listening to a lecture without any testing. From what I hear from electricians who attend lectures the speaker spends more time on the history of his career than the NEC.

  • 19 years ago

    none of the choices presented match EXACTLY the MINIMUM conductor sizes for those specific loads as determined by the cited article. But of the choices presented in the possible answers, only "d" fully complies with the cited article

    I love these sorts of questions :)

    But I have to disagree with you. With #14 wire included in A & B, then they are both eliminated. That leaves 2 choices with #10 to the oven. So the final choice is between #12 or #8 to the 25A load. I'd choose "C", since the maximum ampacity of a #12 wire is 25A . The exception requires that the wire be "sufficient for the load" and the question requires the minimum size wire allowed. By code, #12 is sufficient even though choice "C" uses the smaller wire for the larger of the 2 loads being supplied.

  • 19 years ago

    Samneric I don't think we have any disagreement.
    Tony41 quote; "Since all tap conductors must be minimum of 20amps #14 thrown out."

  • 19 years ago

    Sometimes I wonder if those that make up tests are fully awake when they do so. I'm teaching 3rd year apprentices and on each test there is always one question where none of the answers is correct and/or the question did not contain quite enough information to arrive at one of the answers given.

  • 19 years ago

    Tom O, I'm with you. I keep expecting a new edition of the NEC to be written in terms that are not so confusing. In times past I have found Ferm's Fastfinder very helpful aid when using the NEC. I think authors of the Tax Code also moonlight proof reading the latest NEC before its published. Heard on the radio the Tax Code has reached between 6 & 7,000 pages long!