Software
Houzz Logo Print
janniemac_gw

Double hung windows in kitchens-advice needed

12 years ago

Hi- I am in the early stages of a big kitchen reno...My current plan will have a bank of 3 windows above sink, and a window on either side of the range. I really don't like the crank-out/awning windows. How horrible would it be to have double-hung windows in these locations? Will I regret it every time I have to open and close a window? Any insight would be helpful! Thanks!

Comments (24)

  • 12 years ago

    As long as you don't have to reach up to open the lock, and you have a lip on the bottom to push it up, and you're a tall person, you can probably get away with it. I'm 5' even, and have double hungs over the sink. HATE IT!!! I have to get a stool out to open the windows. Bad design; and shame on me for letting them put these in. Sorry for the bad exposure on the picture.

  • 12 years ago

    We replaced all our double hung windows a year ago with casements, and love them. Our previous windows were very hard to open, they were about 30-35 years old. We love our new windows - it's so easy to open them now. We did get good quality Marvins.

  • 12 years ago

    Are double hung windows the ones that open from either the top or the bottom? I installed these in my new kitchen over the sink on the advice of the salesman (open the window at the top portion to keep air from blowing across my gas stove top) and HATED them. Every time I opened them, the top panel dropped just a bit, so closing them was a PITA and required a stool. I had them switched out for single hung windows and LOVE them. They look just like the double hung's, but operate much easier and don't require a stool. They are very easy to open and close with just one hand (Milgard brand). I have a walkway outside my kitchen window and didn't like the idea of the casement window sticking out into the space when the windows are open.

  • 12 years ago

    As a point of clarification, "crank out" are as pointed out, casement and would be the most convenient in your application.

    Double hung is the action of both the top and bottom sash able to be opened.

    Single hung is the action of just the bottom sash able to be opened.

  • 12 years ago

    Haha yeah I've smashed my face on a few casements in my day...

    What do you hate about the awning style windows? I think they've come quite a ways in recent years as far as ease of use. I think some are even electrically operated - I forget who but someone here had one over their sink with a little button that made it open and close. I thought that was pretty slick.

    Do you NEED to open the windows? I opted for a non-opening thermal pane on my kitchen window - I really love the unobstructed view it gives me and if I ever light anything on fire, we've got a door right off the kitchen in the mudroom I can open. Plus, I can't afford the fancy awning windows...

    This post was edited by Swentastic on Thu, Oct 9, 14 at 11:12

  • 12 years ago

    snoonyb: thanks for clarifying...I knew there was a word for them (casement) but I couldn't think of it!
    jellytoast: good point about the top panel slipping down...that happens in my house to almost all of my windows! Maybe I'll look at single-hung.

  • 12 years ago

    I have double-hungs above the kitchen sink...they came with the house...and the only thing I like about them is that I can slide down the top sash (since it doesn't stay up well anyway) and if it's not breezy the heat goes up and out, and if it is breezy, the fresh air wafts into the room without blowing things around.

    Of course, it's hard to close them, sliding them up is not ergonomically easy.

    When I replace them, I'm really torn as to whether to get casements which I otherwise love, or continue that "feature".

  • 12 years ago

    I used to have a double-hung over my sink and hated opening and closing it, so I rarely did. I love my "new" push-out casement - there's no awkward crank mechanism:

  • 12 years ago

    Loving all the input! Swentastic: The kitchen in question is at my shore house. We almost never use A/C because we get such a great breeze on most days, so, yes, the windows will need to actually open.
    I feel like the casement windows in the open position would block some of the breeze..plus I just don't like how they look.
    The kitchen is on the 2nd floor so I don't have to worry about anyone smashing their face on it in case I do end up going that route! :-)
    I'll have to look into the "push-out" casements...

  • 12 years ago

    Wow...OK, I have a double-hung over my sink & no problems. We replaced the casement one with this when we added a porch on the other side of the window--otherwise, you'd be walking into the window too much.

    But I am tall, I'll admit to that, so maybe that's why it's no problem. All I know is I wouldn't want to change this! The casements we do have don't like to lock tight against the winter, drat them.

  • 12 years ago

    We replaced a double-hung over the sink with another double-hung. Main reason is that I sometimes put a window fan in and I wasn't able to do that with a casement. We get a good breeze through those windows and with a casement, the opened window would have blocked a good portion of the breeze due to how the wind comes through.

    That said, I'm short (5'3") and it can be a bit of a challenge opening and closing it. Although it was initially our frontrunner when planning on new windows, we wound up not liking the look and feel of the Marvin fiberglass and instead went with the Pella fiberglass...one thing that I've found that I miss with our new Pella windows is that the bottom sash doesn't have a finger pull to raise and lower the window, so I have to push and pull from the top of the bottom portion of the window...wish that was different.

  • 12 years ago

    Double hung above the sink. Been there forever, would not think of replacing them. Not a fan of casement. If you just push them out, how do you push them back?

  • 12 years ago

    Thanks all. I am 5'2" and my husband is 6'5...I am used to pulling out a step stool in order to reach something. If I get lazy, I can just ask my husband to open them!

  • 12 years ago

    Had double hungs over the sink once, never again. Love my casements over the sink - the rest of the house has double hungs but over the sink is different.

  • 12 years ago

    We had almost all casements and a few sliders and replaced them with almost all double hung and a few awning. I was excited about the places we chose awnings. What I dislike about the awnings is that there is less glass, more frame. (Milgard Tuscany). If someone had told me that, I would have made other decisions.

    I am 5'2", DH is 6'2". Like you, janniemac, I occasionally get a stool but more often wait until DH is around to open the double hung over the sink.

    The thing that I love about the double hung over the sink, vs. the old casement, is no vertical obstruction.

    I have no issue with the double hung slipping down, though the windows were only installed last February.

  • 12 years ago

    We have two single hung windows above our sink. They are fairly high on the wall as the wall mount faucet is beneath the windows. I am 5'7" and can not open them. I hate this!

    We plan to remodel the kitchen in the spring and high on my priority list is putting in three bigger casement windows so I can actually open them! We have casements in our living and dining rooms and in our breakfast nook and I like them. Ours do not crank out, I just push them open and pull them closed, no problem--windows are original to our 1926 house.

  • 12 years ago

    I love my new casement windows. They are Marvin Ultimates. To the OP - I am wondering if the issue isn't the casement itself, but perhaps you had a poorly-made casement window. I replaced my old casement windows with new Marvin casements, and the improvement is like night and day. They crank open and closed with silky smoothness, they seal tightly when shut against winter cold, and have no rattling and no drafts.

    My casements crank open all the way so that the window is completely perpendicular to the frame. In other words, the window in not open a fraction of the space, it is 100% open and nothing is blocking breezes. Also, the crank has a setting so that you can open the casements so that the outside side turns in so that you can clean it (sorry I don't know how to word it, but I hope you get what I mean). Love that feature - with my old casements I had to look at dirt and bird droppings on the windows for months until I could get someone on a ladder to clean the outside of the windows. So don't be too hasty about not getting casements - it could be you just have to choose a good manufacturer and then you will like them.

    Also, there is a GW Windows Forum where actual windows contractors hang out, and you can ask more technical questions there if you want.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Gardenweb Windows Forum

    This post was edited by Mrs_Nyefnyef on Fri, Oct 10, 14 at 8:41

  • 12 years ago

    i just put all new windows in my house. the kitchen window was single hung and impossible to open as i had to lean over the sink/faucet and push up.
    i switched to a crank out "casement" window. the push out kind is called an "awning" window. my casement opens straight out leaving the entire window open to the air. my mom hated her old casements and told me not to do it but lucky for me i didn't listen because it is awesome!
    i actually like it so much, i wish i put them in the bathrooms instead of double hung. plus you can keep them open a little in the rain vs shutting all the way with the doubles. and they have the lowest air infiltration rate for colder climes. my windows are sunrise restorations btw and so far they seem great.
    the window forum on this site is very helpful and helped me decide on my windows.

  • 12 years ago

    I have a variety of windows in my house; double hungs, casements, and awnings. Each having their merits for the location/room they are in. For instance, the awnings are in bathrooms, the sills at about shoulder height, making for privacy, but still maintaining a view and ventilation. I did use a casement at my kitchen sink for ease of use. I keep many of my windows open all year long, the double hungs and awnings especially. Like crl, my casements, are all the push out type, (as are my awnings) I prefer the classic simple "old school" function of no cranks.

    This post was edited by ctycdm on Fri, Oct 10, 14 at 14:28

  • 12 years ago

    I love my awning window. I was REALLY concerned about breezes but I find it lets in quite the breeze. Casements even more so if they open to 90 degrees because the whole window opening is exposed, not just half (in the case of a double hung window). I also absolutely love being able to keep it open in all but the most horizontal of rainstorms.

  • 12 years ago

    There seems to be some confusion on terminology. A casement window is hinged on the side, regardless of whether it has a crank or not. An awning window is hinged at the top while the bottom swings out. I have both in my house.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Dictionary definition of awning window

  • 12 years ago

    We use our casements like sails to direct the breeze into the room. By changing the angle of opening, you can actually catch breezes that you might miss with a double or single hung. We have double hungs over a deep sink in a corner --- no issues but we rarely open these as a result :(

    Two other options (pricey, believe me) exist:

    in swing, pull in casements, both single pane and french style
    tilt/turn, European style windows.

    The inswing variants can be handy where its tough to reach and close a fully open window (without a crank, if you hate cranks). They are not so useful on a counter without open wall space to rest against, however.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pella specialty; Marvin has similar

  • 12 years ago

    I am short (5'3") and we put in a row of double hungs above the sink, and they are a breeze, very easy to operate.

    We have double hungs on all of our other windows (older home) and since this was a new addition the windows needed to look like they belonged. I have to admit that I almost chose casement because of function and my contractor talked me out of it, I am so glad he did.

  • 12 years ago

    I've had both double and single hung windows over sinks in different houses and all of them were a PIA to open & close.

    In this house, I chose casements.

    In general, casement windows (vs dbl hungs) are:

    Less expensive than double hung windows
    More energy efficient
    Admit more air
    Can be used to 'catch' breeze & direct air into house
    Easier to clean
    Less viewing obstruction

    All that & I don't wretch my back reaching out, up & over a sink & faucet to struggle with getting a double hung window unlocked and opened.