Software
Houzz Logo Print
babushka_cat_gw

HELP - Is my backsplash tile too chunky?

15 years ago

hi gw comrades -

am now wrestling with backsplash options and need your help! i want to do a classic white subway backplash and had planned for a 3x6 but as i mock it up it feels like it might be out of scale - the 3x6 too big for cabinetry? wondering if i should consider a 2.5 x5 inch tile instead? or another size you would suggest? i am aiming for a vintage feel so do not want to go with too modern of a look. what do you folks think, and if you agree, do you have any white suggestions that would go with ben moore simply white custom cabs?

these tiles are just taped to the wall with blue tape to simulate the look... :)


Comments (25)

  • 15 years ago

    I did 4x8 subway on mine. I think once you get it all up, you'll see that it's perfect! Looks good, byw!

  • 15 years ago

    It's perfect. I love it.

  • 15 years ago

    If it helps, my husband was convinced that 3x6 was way too big when we started (he really wanted 2x6 but we couldn't find any in our price range and got tired of stalking Heath seconds). After it went up, he completely changed his mind and now thinks it's great---something about the transition from a few tiles to a whole wall of them shifts the bulkiness of the tile. And for vintage, I think subways can't be beat (but then, you probably would have guessed that! ;)

    Love how your cabinets and counter turned out after all that grief, btw! They're perfect!!

  • 15 years ago

    Looks perfect to me, too!

  • 15 years ago

    Babushka_cat, I think your backsplash looks perfect and you will love it when it is complete.

  • 15 years ago

    I think your cabs need this size. Any smaller would be too busy. You have wide drawers and a substantial sink. They balance perfectly together....

  • 15 years ago

    I think they look great, as do your gorgeous countertops and cabs.
    What may be throwing you off is that, since the tile isn't grouted, the grout lines are more pronounced.
    Try mocking up a few tiles on a board with grout and see how you like it.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree with everyone else - they look great!

  • 15 years ago

    Haven't looked at everyone else's thoughts but I think they are perfect! Looks good to me.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree that they echo the shape and size of the cabinet panes. Nice.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree, absolutely perfect choice. I don't think anything else would look as good. Also love the cabinets, glass doors and counters. Can't wait to see it finished!

  • 15 years ago

    With so many classic elements in your kitchen,
    I think your 3" by 6" tiles are the perfect choice.
    (I say that not having seen your whole kitchen in the way that you can.)
    As so many of us have found, once grouted they will look much different
    (and usually/always better!)

    We did pick smaller "subway" tiles (2" by 3") for our recent kitchen reno,
    in part because we felt so sad about having to demo our original 1928
    3" by 6" subways that we didn't even want to try to replace them
    and in part because our kitchen felt so plain that I felt I wanted to busier
    rusticity of the smaller tiles.

    You are seeing larger 4" by 8" tiles and 2" by 6" and 2" by 8" tiles a lot these day
    in magazines and on GW. So perhaps that is why you are second guessing.
    But 3" x 6" isn't just the "default" choice;
    it remains the classic choice
    and seems perfect for your kitchen.

    Can't wait to see your full reveal!

  • 15 years ago

    thanks all for replying, this has been very helpful. i am single so am on the hook for all the decisions and some are easier than others! while i have friends who i check in with they are not as TKO so i need to rely on you...

    it is hard to judge without seeing the whole thing and without grout. i feel much better about it getting your perspective. i definately do not want a busy look!

    does the color look OK as well? i got about 6 different whites and most were too grey. this tile seems the closest but none of them are exact.

    babushka

  • 15 years ago

    I like the color from what I can see in the photos, but having navigated the choose-white-tile straits, I know that the color doesn't always come across well in the photos (and even changes once all the tiles are in, and once they're grouted)---so I'd trust your eye on that since you can see how it pulls together in reality better than we can. The big plus of having both white cabs and whiteish counters is that you have a lot of leeway, too---you can pull out different tones and not have to worry about it "matching."

    Can't wait to see the finished kitchen!!

  • 15 years ago

    thanks artemis - i agree - hard to tell unless in person.

    just read your prior post about expecting a baby any day now - congrats!!! the kitchen will get a good workout and lots of place for the little one to scurry around in time!

  • 15 years ago

    I may be a bit late but you have no worries, it looks great!

  • 15 years ago

    I agree that it's a perfect choice. BTW, your marble is SOOOO yummy!

  • 15 years ago

    Color is good on my screen.

  • 15 years ago

    The size is good. With the colour that you have chosen (according to my monitor) you have a seamless flow of colour from the upper cabinets, through the backsplash to the counter and then to the lower cabinets. If that is what you are looking to achieve you did just that. Looks good.

  • 15 years ago

    The tile looks perfect to me, too (wouldn't go with any other size, it's the most historically accurate) -- but the most important question is: does it coordinate with Babushka the Cat?

    I think we need pictures to make sure. ;-)

  • 15 years ago

    love it all!

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks babushka! There's nothing like impending labor to light the fire under you for finally wrapping up remodels. ;)

  • 15 years ago

    I think it looks perfect! Everything is gorgeous together! :)

  • 15 years ago

    Oh, it looks fantastic! That marble is dreamy & your pics reinforced my love of glass cabs!

    I really like the 3 by 6. Keep the photos coming!