Software
Houzz Logo Print
grannabelle

Green Mountain Original Soapstone

18 years ago

seeing the bump in florida joshua's post about darkening soapstone prompted me to post....to gather info before i speak with my fabricator....for those of you with green mountain original: can you scratch it with your fingernail and does pretty much everything that barely touches, scratch the surface leave a mark(scratch, ding, etc)...and when you oil these scratches and dings do they blend in with the darker, oiled stone, or stick out even more because they stay light (as in my case)- this wss NOT the case in any samples that i received or actual installations that i saw...the saga of my search for the right soapstone for me is very long - so i won't bore you - but what i got is not at all what i thought i was getting....i think it may be ice flower because of it's super softness....any comments, suggestions would be very much apreciated...HAPPY NEW YEAR to all!! thanks

Comments (9)

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Grannabelle.

    I just hot-footed it into my kitchen to test your theory on my un-honed chunk of Green Mountain Original. Tried to scratch the stuff with my (admittedly short) fingernail. Couldn't make much of a dent, and had to look hard to see anything. What minor scratch I made disappeared when I put some oil on it.

    Somebody out there correct me if I am wrong, but it seems to me that Ice Flower is grey and becomes black, but Original is decidedly light green and becomes dark green.

    Grannabelle, where are you located?

  • 18 years ago

    i am in nj....my ss is light greenish,unoiled becomes darker, more black (but still has a greenish cast) when oiled...maybe i don't have ice flower either...this whole thing has me very disappointed and frustrated!!

  • 18 years ago

    grannabelle, shoot me an email and contact info and I'll tell you what I know.

    Merry Christmas

  • 18 years ago

    I thought you were in NJ - did you get your soapstone from Garden State? E-mail me offlist (address on mypage).

  • 18 years ago

    i will contact both of you through email - thanks so much -
    also, please understand i love the look of my stone - the veining and movement are beautiful...it's just way too soft and the colors and movement don't go so well together when oiled...happy holiday everyone!!

  • 18 years ago

    My SS is pretty soft too. It is dark green/black when oiled. I have found that I can usually buff out any scratches, or use fine sandpaper to get them out. The nicks tend to blend in once oiled, so they aren't that noticeble. I think my stone may have come from S. America.

  • 18 years ago

    We have Ice Flower...from Bucks County SS. It was originally light gray with beautiful caramel colored veining. Oiling makes it charcoal gray...not black....and the veining becomes richer and more pronounced. It also has sparkles in it that really twinkle when the undercab lights are on. It is over two years old, and now retains its charcoal gray color. I only oil it when guests are coming...as it gives it a nice matte glow.

    Initially it scratched and dinged fairly easily. However, that is not the case anymore...as it takes a lot more to scratch or ding. DH believes that the oxidation process also serves to harden it, making it less apt to ding or scratch. Indeed, minor scratches disappear on their own after a few days, without oiling.

    We have a sample of Original Green Mountain; it is dark greenish blackish. When oiled it looks more black with a definite green cast. I did not notice a difference in the scratch or dingability. Bucks County stated that Ice Flower is just a tad harderÂhowever, I really think it depends upon each slabÂas not all natural material is created equal.

    Ice Flower also has more movement within the stone than Original GM, which IMO, serves to camouflage any minor scratches and dings that happen.

  • 18 years ago

    My Green Mountain stone is very soft. I think it is also ice flower. Very scratchy, and dingy. My GC taught me how to get rid of scratches myself with sandpaper (gently!) so I have done that once (from HIS damage!). The dings don't bother me because they are very small and look like part of the stone markings. I have oiled w/ Beeswax/oil mixture and after about 4x it finally has stayed a charcoal grey that I like, will probably oil it some more but not so obsessively. I had wanted Mariana which is less soft, but it was really hard to find. I was surprised at how soft ice flower is (even after extensive soapstone research here and elsewhere) but I am already loving putting my hot pots down and enjoying the counters very much, and since they are in, I have told myself to be OK with the softness (especially since I can get the bad scratches out if the come, which I suspect they will).

  • 18 years ago

    lpolk: how did your GC teach you to sand out the scratches?...i am hesitant to sand right now because the scratches are staying light, but i will try anything on some leftover pieces that i have (it's funny you said that the GC left dings, mine did too which i did not care about thinking that they would just blend in with oiling - hmmmm not the case here)...