Software
Houzz Logo Print
dawdemo

Active sons and choice for kitchen cabinets

14 years ago

Hi. We are planning for our kitchen remodel. Countertops will be soapstone, appliances will be stainless, hardware will be brushed nickel. Floor and backsplash to be determined.

Cabinets will be Brookhaven (Wood-Mode) shaker-style. Choices for cabinetry wood are maple or cherry. Choices for finish include 1)natural or slightly-darker-than-natural stain, 2) some sort of gray (driftwood-like) stain, or 3) white.

We have two active sons, ages seven and nine. They are only going to get bigger and more active, with bigger and more active friends!

I am prepared to deal with the fingerprints-and-smudges on the stainless. I am hoping for some guidance regarding which wood and finish choices may hold up best to the wear-and-tear of our family.

Thank you!

Comments (7)

  • 14 years ago

    I would be more concerned with the soapstone & active boys! I love soapstone, and you'll see some beautiful kitchens on here with it, but I decided I could not live with the dings that are inevitable. I have an 11 yr old boy and an 8 yr old girl - plus a messy, careless hubby!! I was afraid I would be a nervous wreck everytime a set of keys or pot was dropped on the counter!!

    I either either maple or cherry would stand up fine for the cabinets.

  • 14 years ago

    Maple is a lot harder than cherry and hickory is harder than both. Soapstone however, is pretty darn soft in the world of stones. Something like Uba Tuba granite is bulletproof though.

  • 14 years ago

    My active boys are now 22 and 24 but when they were younger we had painted white cabinets. I painted them myself (over slab walnut doors - I know, I know - what can I say - I love white cabinetry) with BM melamine paint and they stood up for 17 years with no dings. We just redid our kitchen and put in shaker maple creamy painted cabinets. We have natural maple in the bathrooms and for both, so far so good.

  • 14 years ago

    This is a post I can really relate to.

    I have 3 kids, (B-G-B) and the two teens cook. I bring over Girl Scouts to cook. The youngest, a boy, is 11. We also have a full-size dog (standard poodle). I did polished granite in a darker tone. Yes, I briefly loved soapstone, then fell in love with all the light-colored granites (wannabe marbles, really). In the end, our choices were all about durability. We realized we won't be doing this again for a really long time.

    I would go with maple or cherry. Previous poster is correct, that maple is harder, but cherry is still relatively hardwood. Woodworking websites actually rate the hardness of different wood species, something worth checking out. It can be hard to stain maple--not that it can't be done, we just saw an amazing finished maple kitchen from theplayer. But I myself was advised against it.

    In the end, myself chose red birch with a natural finish. My viewpoint was that it would be easier to sand down and re-finish if they got nicked badly enough. But that may be overthinking it. If you really want grey, I'd go for it. I would not do lower cabs in white for a busy-boy household, myself. But certainly the uppers could be white. I know there are many who would disagree with me.

    The s/s fridge is a pain and I hate keeping it clean but I couldn't find another option I liked. Our stove front is black with a brushed chrome top, and I liked it enough to keep it. I wish there were a brushed chrome fridge but not available. Our dishwasher was just 2 years old and it was black in front; I kept it too. Not sure I will switch either to S/S but we will hopefully not have to decide that for several years.

    Good luck!!

  • 14 years ago

    This is a post I can really relate to.

    I have 3 kids, (B-G-B) and the two teens cook. I bring over Girl Scouts to cook. The youngest, a boy, is 11. We also have a full-size dog (standard poodle). I did polished granite in a darker tone. Yes, I briefly loved soapstone, then fell in love with all the light-colored granites (wannabe marbles, really). In the end, our choices were all about durability. We realized we won't be doing this again for a really long time.

    I would go with maple or cherry. Previous poster is correct, that maple is harder, but cherry is still relatively hardwood. Woodworking websites actually rate the hardness of different wood species, something worth checking out. It can be hard to stain maple--not that it can't be done, we just saw an amazing finished maple kitchen from theplayer. But I myself was advised against it.

    In the end, myself chose red birch with a natural finish. My viewpoint was that it would be easier to sand down and re-finish if they got nicked badly enough. But that may be overthinking it. If you really want grey, I'd go for it. I would not do lower cabs in white for a busy-boy household, myself. But certainly the uppers could be white. I know there are many who would disagree with me.

    The s/s fridge is a pain and I hate keeping it clean but I couldn't find another option I liked. Our stove front is black with a brushed chrome top, and I liked it enough to keep it. I wish there were a brushed chrome fridge but not available. Our dishwasher was just 2 years old and it was black in front; I kept it too. Not sure I will switch either to S/S but we will hopefully not have to decide that for several years.

    Good luck!!

  • 14 years ago

    We have 8 kids, and we homeschool, so our house gets active use all day, every day, plus the addition of lots of friends, who all seem to want to do projects in the kitchen. When we did the kitchen in our last house we used cherry, and in this house we have fir, and some painted. Cherry is a hardwood, but on the soft end of the scale. Fir is soft. The cabinets, being vertical, get very little rough treatment and I don't worry about the fir or the painted cabinets we have.

    If something crashes hard into a cabinet, it's likely to ding whether it's a hard or softer species of lumber. But mostly, as I said, our cabinets don't get much wear and tear from an active family. I'd concentrate more on the construction quality and the hardware (drawer slides and hinges) than the faces.

    The wood hides more than the painted, and natural hides more than stained or painted, since there's a chance of scratching or dinging through the color. But, I would go more with what look suits how you want your kitchen to feel, so you and your family love being in there.

  • 14 years ago

    I think you are exactly right about the hardware and construction quality, rhome. In particular, I would say dove-tail drawers are a must.

    I was probably paranoid about finish and color because that is what drove me to replace our cabinets. The doors had a veneer that chipped off in places, also the drawers were literally falling apart.