Software
Houzz Logo Print
tashamh2

Cabinet Reviews

14 years ago

Is there a website or a useful resource that reviews different cabinet lines?

Comments (11)

  • 14 years ago

    There are several older (and newer) posts discussing comparisons between lines in general and specific lines compared to each other. There was one fairly long thread that sort of ordered the various lines from least to most desirable/expensive. Helpfully, it also pointed out which cabinet line names were the same as another line name from a different store, sort of like a Ford Taurus and a Mercury Sable-same car, different names.

    Your best bet is to google a specific cabinet name, say Medallion, and limit the search to this site:

    medallion cabinets site:gardenweb.com

    Note that there is no space after the colon. Just keep substituting names into the search and you'll keep turning up more threads with relevant information.

    Are you just beginning your investigation and have no clue what the story is? Do you have a specific line you want to see what people think? Pretty much everyone starts in that position and it can be very confusing. If you are at the beginning, you might want to investigate the difference between framed and frameless cabinets first. If you discover that you really want one or the other, that cuts down on the search. Also listen to what people have to say about custom cabinets from a local shop. And don't forget to check out Ikea, and Ikea + door fronts from other sources.

    Hope this helps.

  • 14 years ago

    Hi Suzannes1!

    Thanks for that information. I'm just getting started and completely confused by all the options. I've been to a few KD stores and big box stores. One KD carries Merillat, but read poor reviews on this site about that cabinet line. The other KD carries Brighton and haven't been able to find reviews for that line. Then the other KD carries an Amish line but I didn't have a good experience with the salesperson. I also looked into Kraftmaid at Home Depot, but again bad reviews.

    The other decision that I'm struggling with is whether I should have my architect (I'm converting my basement into a rental unit and the back porch into a laundry room) design the kitchen or use a KD store so I can recoup the design fee. Any thoughts?

  • 14 years ago

    "There was one fairly long thread that sort of ordered the various lines from least to most desirable/expensive. Helpfully, it also pointed out which cabinet line names were the same as another line name from a different store, sort of like a Ford Taurus and a Mercury Sable-same car, different names."

    If anybody can provide a link to this thread, I would be forever in your debt. I have spent quite a bit of time going through old threads, and don't think that I have come upon this one.

    Tashamh2 - I am also considering Merrillat, and the reviews here make me think twice. But there have been some decent ones as well. I am quickly coming to terms with the fact that you just can't expect to get a Masarati with a Ford budget.

  • 14 years ago
  • 14 years ago

    This is the link I found from the forum from 2008 that reviews the various cabinet makers. It's a long one and covers a lot of different manufacturers.

    http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg0311430425177.html

  • 14 years ago

    I would like to ask that you please look at some local cabinet makers. Custom is not always more expensive. We compete very well with the box companies. Plus it is helping your local economy and not some out of the country cabinet manufacture.

    Travis Alfrey
    Aberdeen, NC

  • 14 years ago

    Cribbs,

    How would I go about identifying reputable local cabinet makers? I live in the DC Metro area.

    Thanks.

  • 14 years ago

    Well my general advice is from friends and family first. They generally know who has and has not done a good job. After that start visiting shops. When you find one or two that you have a good feeling from go speak to their customers. People have different expectations so spelling those out to the cabinet guys is very important.

    Side note- I am actually speaking with someone in your same area about a kitchen remodel right now so if you are willing to speak to out of state companies then send me an e-mail. travisalfreywoodworking@gmail.com

    Travis Alfrey
    Aberdeen, NC

  • 14 years ago

    Regarding "local" shops (or "local custom cabinetmakers").

    Sometimes you can get quality cabinets & service less expensively through a local custom cabinetmaker, but not always. There is a lot of misleading information out there that makes it sound like all local custom cabinetmakers are less expensive and of higher quality than larger manufacturers (like Bertch, Omega, etc.)

    What's the real scoop?

    Some local custom cabinetmakers are less expensive
    Some local custom cabinetmakers have as good as or even better quality
    Some local custom cabinetmakers are good installers, businessmen, etc.

    Unfortunately, you may not find all of the above in the same cabinetmaker!

    All of this is regional as well...not just the availability/cost/quality/service of local custom cabinetmakers, but also the availability/cost/service of those from the larger manufacturers (quality should be the same, regardless of location for manufacturers).


    Here's the "blurb" I usually post when people start asking about "local custom cabinetmakers":


    Just a word of caution..."local (custom) cabinetmaker" is thrown around here a lot with the implication they are all superior to or at least as good as the various cabinet manufacturers. Some may be, but there is no guarantee. "Local custom cabinetmaker" does not necessarily equate to "high quality" or "low cost". There are many very good custom cabinetmakers out there, but there are many not-so-good ones as well. Just b/c someone is a "custom cabinetmaker" does not make him/her a good cabinetmaker. And, it's not just their skill at cabinetry...how are their business skills? E.g., How are they at meeting schedules? Do they stay within the cost they quote you? How do they deal with issues? What is their warranty? What recourse do you have if they drop the ball? Sometimes you can go "over the heads" of people at cabinet stores or even go to the manufacturer (at least for warranty issues), but you might not have that option with a local cabinetmaker.

    If you go this route, be very diligent in your research:

    • Contact several recent references, including at least one who had problems so you can see how the cabinetmaker handled those problems. Ask about:
    • How was the cabinetmaker at keeping to the schedule s/he promised?

    Did the cabinetmaker stick pretty close to the cost estimate s/he gave them (no hidden fees, undeclared upgrades, etc.)?
    Did the cabinetmaker let them (the customer) see a sample of their cabinet door w/finish for approval of the finish, quality, etc. prior to completing the entire order?
    How did the cabinetmaker handle construction issues?
    How did the cabinetmaker handle installation issues?
    Contact several not-so-recent references, ask them how their cabinets are holding up (joints, face frames, drawers, doors, finish, etc.). Try for some at least 5 years old and at least 10 years old.
    See actual installed kitchens with the same type of cabinets &...

  • 14 years ago

    An excellent post. As he says not all are professionals but not all box company reps are professional either. It pays to do your homework and ask the correct questions.

    Travis Alfrey
    Aberdeen, NC