Nice space. For paint take a look at Benjamin Moore revere pewter. It seems to blend in and bring out the best in whatever color it is paired with. When you replace your countertop look at Quartz. You will never regret it. Good luck.

I totally agree with jeniwren.

I envy the size of your kitchen! I'd go for a super pale green (think white with a green tint, like SW Pearl Onion):



I know you don't love the countertops, but try to work with them instead of against them. They're large, they aren't going anywhere, and you might as well try to embrace them. Make them look like they fit instead of like you're trying to hide them, and they'll just blend.

What are the odds on replacing the light fixture? That would also make a big difference in the room, imo.

I have never thought of a greenish color in the kitchen but I love the idea blending the counters in more (they are in great condition just GREEN)!! We are replacing the light above the island with a dual fan/light fixture.