skip to main content
Software
Integrations
Mobile App
Expert Support
All-In-One Platform for Construction and Design
See Pricing
Schedule a Demo
Talk to Sales: (888) 316-4595
My builder uses Houzz Pro to plan the timeline and give detailed estimates and daily updates with photos of progress, and provide invoices at pre-agreed key points in the build. This made the whole experience much more efficient and stress-free.
Steve W.
Client of Cribbs Construction
Learn More
Ideas
Discussions
Houzz TV
Houzz Research
Sign In
Houzz Logo Print
Explore DiscussionsFeatured Home DiscussionsFeatured Garden Discussions
Design Dilemma
hzdeleted_392745

Thoughts on Fireplace Rock

13 years ago
Hi All,
This is my townhouse. This is the downstairs. I plan on replacing the gray slate around the fireplace with the rock (or something similar) that is placed above the mantel. Should I just replace the slate or should I take the rock above the mantel up the steps of the fireplace? My worry: too busy next to the Sid Dickens Block in the stairway and too busy next to the way too busy kitchen granite and backsplash. I've been agonizing over the granite and backsplash for the past 6 years and think about replacing the the backsplash on a weekly basis. But, I guess that is another post.

Anyway, fire away! All comments, criticisms, and ideas are welcome and very much appreciated.
Featured Answer
  • 13 years ago
    Great and appreciated comments - thanks!

    Here is what happened today: The plants are gone! I took down the mirror and picture above the fireplace. I temporarily placed a frameless mirror where the picture was and placed the candles in front of it on the mantle. Very nice! I moved the large chairs opposite the couch and the are too big for that location too, so they went back to their original location.

    My plan on Saturday: Tile store! I'll be looking for a creamy white subway tile for the backsplash...thanks mmilos. I am leaning toward keeping something similar to the rock shown in the photos for the fireplace. However, mpoulsom, I like the idea of stream lining and mantel removal too. Classic Designs by Brook: I'm not sure how realistic it will be for me to have the fireplace reframed, but It's in the back of my mind now! All these great ideas will be with me on Saturday.

    I will be posting more pictures as the project moves along. Thank everyone!

    Comments (14)

    • 13 years ago
      A few more pictures...
    • 13 years ago
      I would limit the new tile to just the slate area you have now.

    • Related Professionals

      Mobile Interior Designers & Decorators · Peoria Interior Designers & Decorators · South Bend Interior Designers & Decorators · North Platte Interior Designers & Decorators · Casper Interior Designers & Decorators · Jacksonville Architects & Building Designers · Danbury Architects & Building Designers · Brattleboro Architects & Building Designers · Cape Coral Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Albany Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Portsmouth Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Dallas Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Muncie Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Altoona Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Temecula Kitchen & Bathroom Designers
    • PRO
      13 years ago
      Right now your eyes are drawn to the drywall steps over the fireplace. If you can't reframe that, which would be my first chose, please remove the plants on top. It is not a pretty feature so do not draw your eyes to it. Swap the mirror for the picture. Place candle sticks in front. If you still want a painting on the other wall where the mirror is now it should be quite large. Do not put smaller tiles on your fireplace, they will compete with the small scale Sids. Do not tile above.
      I know you didn't ask, but you need an area rug.
      And yes the tiles in the kithen are very busy, perhaps a travertine 3" x6".
      Good luck, Stefanie.
    • 13 years ago
      last modified: 13 years ago
      agree with mmilos on the tile. to unbusy the fireplace area, try removing the framed picture as well as the framed mirror, so these don't compete with the fireplace tile and the memory tile in the stairway.the framed picture could be hung lower on the wall where the mirror is now and place the small ottomon under it on that part wall. float the two large upholstered chairs in the middle of the room facing the sofa and their backs to the dining area. i would alsos remove the potted plants from above the fireplace, perhaps using one of them on the mantel with the candlesticks. Pretty place and the new tile will certainly add a bit of class!
    • 13 years ago
      I think that FP and stairs combo is the weirdest installation I've seen. I'm afraid my first instinct is to tear the FP and faux block stairs out, but apparently they must have some kind of cache.. WIth your chair backed up to it, I assume it is non-working to boot! Guess I'm ignorant about who Sid Dickens is, but I don't care for his style. Def tone down the busy kitchen tiles, and find a way to take the emphasis off the FP.
    • 13 years ago
      Thanks everyone!
      mmilos: Good advice!

      E. Jackson Design: I'm up for reframing if it is possible. I'm not sure what's under the steps, but will look into it. Any suggestion on the shape of the reframing? Guess what? I'm going to re-tile the backsplash. It bothers me everyday! Whew! I appreciate the rug advise. Thank you! This is what I know now: I am going to hire a designer for my next place!

      Patriciarhall: Got it! I'm going to move things around to see how it looks. Thanks!
    • 13 years ago
      way to go Atia. please post pictures as you go, we would love to see your progress!
    • 13 years ago
      I like the stepped up fireplace wall. Unique! I would not use the small rock you have in mind though. I would use very large clean lined tile. And do it all the way up. Either a solid gray or tan color! I'll try and find a pic of what I'm talking about.
    • 13 years ago
      For your backsplash, a plain creamy white subway tile would look great with the cabinets and granite.
    • PRO
      13 years ago
      Take a plain cream travertine and set it butt-joint (without grout lines). Tile the entire fireplace. But first frame the step ups to the height of the top one. That way fireplace blends with walls and the firebox will stand out and the sid dicken will stand out. You could always paint the wall that sid dickens is on a fun red or a deep charcoal. The kitchen backsplash - find a skilled tile guy to cut out the top part of the splash leaving about 5" of harlequin from granite top , then add a cream travertine trim piece on top and fill in above that to bottom of upper cabinets with the same cream travertine from fireplace in full pieces.
    • 13 years ago
      last modified: 13 years ago
      I disagree with others suggesting a large tile on the fireplace. I think the stones atia has chosen look neutral, contemporary and in scale with the small fireplace surround. It'll just read as a texture around the fireplace.

      I also wouldn't add another stone for the backsplash. Let the busy granite stand on its own.
    • 13 years ago
      Couldn't find exactly what I wanted to show you, but you'll get the idea maybe...something like this, but more solid in color. You have so many other things going on around that area, I feel like it needs to be more streamlined and clean. Then your art on your wall WILL be the centerpiece, which it should be. I would also completely remove the mantel and just do the tile straight up. Then maybe adding a beautiful piece of artwork on the wall to the left! :)

      [houzz=
      While at CHil Design Group · More Info
      ]
    • 13 years ago
      Demolition has begun. Standby!
    Related Stories
    MOST POPULAR7 Ways to Rock a TV and Fireplace Combo
    By The Inman Company
    Win the battle of the dueling focal points with a thoughtful fireplace arrangement that puts attention right where you want it
    Full Story
    121
    TRANSITIONAL HOMESHouzz Tour: A Home That Honors Family in Little Rock
    By Bryan Anthony
    A third-generation homeowner keeps her family history at the forefront of a thoughtful remodel
    Full Story
    106
    DIY PROJECTSReinvent It: Penny for Your Thoughts on This Antiqued Table?
    By Becky Harris
    Let's take it from the top. Make over a routine table with pennies and antiquing for a unique new look
    Full Story
    41
    MAN SPACESHouzz Tour: Rocking Out in a Converted Stable
    By Mary Jo Bowling
    Get an all-access look at a decked-out Connecticut music space a rock star would love
    Full Story
    94
    DECORATING GUIDESRoom of the Day: Warhol Rocks a 19th-Century Dining Room
    By Mary Jo Bowling
    Stellar modern art brings new energy to a dining room in an 1896 mansion with traditional bones
    Full Story
    51
    BEDROOMS5 Ways to Rock a White Bedroom
    By Jennifer Ott Design
    White is, well, white-hot these days. See how to best use the hue in your bedroom
    Full Story
    22
    REMODELING GUIDESRiver Rock Rounds Out Rooms
    By Kristy Woodson Harvey and Beth Woodson
    Worn smooth from rushing water, river rocks add an organic, serene touch to bathrooms, fireplaces, patios and more
    Full Story
    13
    ECLECTIC HOMESMy Houzz: Music and Eclectic Finds Rock a Family’s Los Angeles Hideaway
    By Corynne Pless
    See how a creative couple thoughtfully curates their hilltop home perched in L.A.’s Laurel Canyon
    Full Story
    25
    CURB APPEAL7 Finishing Touches for a Thoughtful Front Yard
    By J. Peterson Garden Design
    Make a great first impression with artful house numbers, water features, garden art and more
    Full Story
    32
    CRAFTSMAN DESIGNHouzz Tour: Thoughtful Renovation Suits Home's Craftsman Neighborhood
    By Becky Harris
    A reconfigured floor plan opens up the downstairs in this Atlanta house, while a new second story adds a private oasis
    Full Story
    78
    Sponsored
    More Discussions
    How to make kitchen less bland
    30
    design dilemma
    8
    Help with living room lay out do I remove the fireplace or leave it?
    39
    HELP! Wallpaper ideas for powder guest bath
    19
    Ready to launch the sculpture inspirational thematic craftsmanship
    0