I like the contrast of the darker one with the granite, but think it might stand out too much against the cabinets. With all the traditional, linear features in your room, I'd stick with brick lay.

The Residences at Black Rock · More Info

I think a subway tile design would look great - using a light grout with the darker gray would add just enough interest without competing with the granite. If there is space above a sink or range, you could add a herringbone design with the same tile just in that area as a nice feature.

The Residences at Black Rock · More Info

Paint a test board of Revere Pewter and put it in the room with your other selections before you make a decision on anything further. It is a paint color that can change based on its surroundings. I prefer the lighter of the two tiles and would keep the pattern simple to create a timeless room.

love the lighter tile -- and I think herringbone would look awesome! Just make sure to grout the tile in a similar color so it won't be too busy.

I love the tile you chose! the lighter one is my favorite. a suggestion for something a little fun and different would be to use the lighter one on the walls, set as a subway tile, and do a feature of either the darker one or the same color in a herringbone pattern above the stove or sink, if there is a space that allows. the herringbone pattern can get quite busy in a large format.

What is your kitchen floor material?

Thank you all so much for your helpful comments! I have included a picture of our floors. They are going to be a dark espresso wood.

Herringbone is second to brick pattern? I have to agree, although you could frame an area in herringbone (above the range is often chosen) -- but this will double or triple your cost for that area -- it's a nice feature, if you can't choose between the two patterns, and may be less than other features available. I also prefer the darker tile.