Can you pay the difference so you can go with the tile you love? That would be the first thing I'd try assuming you can afford it.

It is beautiful...I just looked at a sample online:

What is it that you like about it? The colour, the variations of shade, the pattern? My first thought was it looks like a greyer version of travertine (it is in fact porcelain tile to mimic the look of travertine). Knowing what you like about it (or don't) will make it easier for you to choose an alternative that fits within your budget. Good luck!

Hubby says we can "try" squeezing in the difference in the budget but it will be tight given the fact that I am guilty of splurging big time on the kitchen cabinets and the master closet...