Bottom left is natural blend and Wisconsin to the right

wisconsin

natural blend

wisconsin

I like the natural blend.

My choice would be the Wisconsin. I think it blends with the roof color nicely. But the natural is very pretty as well. Either are good picks!

I like the Natural blend. though I agree both are nice

Wisconsin is beige with brown. My roof is black.

Natural blend seems to have more dark stones which works better with your roof.

I am afraid that the light stones in the natural blend will be blending with the house color.

Natural blend is my favorite. I like that the natural has a range of colors- light,medium and really dark pieces mixed in. The Wisconsin looks like shades of brown pieces only. I think blending in with the house color is good thing as long as there are other colors in the stone as well.

Wisconsin is my preferred. I don't like how the dark brown bricks pop out and draw too much attention to themselves. The tones in Wisconsin are more uniform.

Are there not other choices available?

Natural blend

Has anyone seen natural blend on a house?

Check this out. I believe this is the same stone (natural blend) you are talking about. I hope so. It has tons of pictures with captions to show what stone is in certain pictures.

http://www.westmichiganbrickandstone.com/downloads/DutchQualityStoneCatalog.pdf

Wisconsin, from a different angle looks very different.

wisconsin

natural blend

I like the natural blend best. I think it gives more interest to the home and the darker stones help tie the roof in with the rest of the house.