Software
Houzz Logo Print
bloomcin

Help! Fix leaky shower drain from top

The shower drain leaks to downstairs ceiling. I am wondering if there is anyway to fix it from top without damaging the surrounding tiles. Can somebody please look at the pictures. I am not sure where exactly the leak happens.


1. Should I try to seal it in situ or better off replace the basket? If replace, how do I

take the basket out?


2. The pipe and the basket are covered with white color buildup which I assume from the hard water before the water softener installed 7 years ago when we moved in. Everything is so calcified I had hard time understanding the structure. Should I do sth with the limescale buildup first? If yes, how?


3. If you look at the close up picture, you can see part with thread sitting between the basket and pipe(?). Should I remove that too? If yes, how?


4. Is there any wonder method/wonder product that I could use to fix it without me prying/sawing out anything and risk making further damage? I am totally intimidated by the limestone look of this thing.


Thank you very much!


Comments (14)

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    We need to know the brand and model of drain so we can figure out if there is a chance of repair it. I would bet if you place a hose inside the shower drain and run the water it will not leak. I imagine the leak is coming from somewhere else.


    I would be inspecting this shower from the room below. And looking for water under the entire shower floor.


    Almost looks like some kind of lead shield was formed inside... ??? Not sure. Sorry.

  • 11 years ago

    Thank you John. Unfortunately I don't know the brand. As to check it out from under, we tried. We cut open the ceiling downstairs and see water running along a ceiling joist. The joist is right under that shower so we couldn't see through to inspect.

    If water leaks between pipe and drain structure, is there any easy way to fix?

  • 11 years ago

    First, I have some bad news and then some more bad news. The bad news is, you need to call a plumber on this one. The more bad news is, it is going to cost more than you want to spend.

    If you want to diagnose the problem a little better, go to a plumbing warehouse or home depot and get a wing nut trap plug then let the water run a few and check for leaks. If the water leaks with the plug in and tight, then you have a tear in your shower pan. Since it is in New Jersey and old, you almost certainly have a lead shower pan, which an experienced tile guy should be able to replace but you are probably still going to need a plumber. If there is no leak when the pipe is stopped up then the pipe is leaking and you might be able to save the tile floor by going at the plumbing from underneath.

  • 11 years ago
    Thanks Bry911. In another word, there is no possibility to fix it from top no matter what the problem is. Am I understanding it correctly? Well, guess DIY is out of the question. Sigh. Thanks again.
  • 11 years ago

    The answer to your question is, never say never. To be fair, we are not even sure what the problem is. You can try the wing nut trap plug and see if we can figure out if it is a leaky pan or leaky plumbing. I am not aware of a solution that you can do from the top, but there probably is. The bad thing about plumbing though, the more esoteric your solution is, the less cost effective it is. If your goal for going from the top is to save money then I think you are going to struggle. If the reason you want to keep the tile intact is because the tile is irreplaceable, then a solution is probably out there, but again it is probably not cost effective. Having said all this, calling a plumber to find the problem is a good first step.

  • 11 years ago
    Tile is probably irreplaceable but I can live with any other tile. The only reason I wanted to keep it intact is I thought cutting out and replace tiles would cost $$$ than what it's worth. You are right I need to call a plumber in and go from there. Thanks again.
  • 11 years ago

    The joist is right under that shower so we couldn't see through to inspect.

    I'm a little confused by this statement. How is a single joist blocking your sight of the whole bottom of the shower? Maybe a photo would help.
    Are you able to open up the ceiling directly below the shower? Or are you just looking through a tiny hole?


  • PRO
    11 years ago

    "...We cut open the ceiling downstairs and see water running along a ceiling joist. The joist is right under that shower so we couldn't see through to inspect...."


    Did you run the shower and see the water start? Or did you see signs of water at that point and make that conclusion? Make sure you know what is what.


    Start first by dumping water down the drain from another source. Like a garden hose or buckets of water. If you see water then you know for sure it is the shower floor, curb or drain. If you don't try filling up a bucket of water with the shower head. If you see water now it could be a plumbing line issue and not a fault in the shower.


    Water travels a long way. Don't rule out an exterior leak issue or a problem from another source....

  • 11 years ago
    We opened about 2 square feet hole in the ceiling, not big enough I know. And I know it's not right beneath the offending drain. Water travels that I know too. It's just all these recessing lights and ceiling lights out there we were reluctant to tear it all apart. Guess I was just in the denial stage of a very expensive problem.

    The leak is in the shower floor/drain. I did dump a bucket of water to the drain. Water leaked out downstairs quickly. I am going to find a way to run a hose into the pipe and test it out if it's the pipe. My gut feeling is not. And pick up a plug and stop the pipe to see if water goes down. Chances are yes. I still think the segment where water run from the shower floor to drain pipe is the problem.
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You are in for a full shower & pan gut. and it looks like its time .....this home has gotten a long life out of this one..

    Heres your #1 new challenge. "How to qualify and hire a tile shower pan builder" where will you look and how will you know the proper questions to ask while getting quotes? what methods of standards they adhere to and what materials they will use.


    request a flood tested shower pan.

  • 11 years ago
    Tundra thank you for the advice. You know now I start to think about a total redo of that bathroom, since fixing the drain is not gonna be cheap anyway. And why not make it bigger by taking down the wall next to the closet? And the other bathroom next to it needs an update too. And the kitchen downstairs that the water leaked into, and... You see now my #1 new challenge is way beyond hiring a good tile shower pan builder. Isn't it how 90% of whole house remodel starts?
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    LOL!! Bloom.... well lets hope youve deep pockets then...best of luck..... did you say Jersey Shores summer home?


  • 11 years ago
    Greg you are right. Anyway that part of ceiling need to be replaced eventually. Will open it up bigger to inspect.