Software
Houzz Logo Print
exmar

Dificulty starting seeds this year?

Hi Folks,

OK, this is going to sound strange, but I'm having trouble getting some seeds to start, specifically, gourds, melon, and cukes. Chatting with some other folks who also start seeds to set plants they're reporting similar difficulties. I've been gardening over 50 years and "business as usual," just ain't working. e.g. Birdhouse or "dipper gourds," three packages of seeds, one from Guerney's, the other two from another major supplier. These were set as usual in "peat pots" bottom watered, covered in plastic, etc. etc. ZERO germination??

We're doing everything "as usual," by process of elimination, could it be the seeds harvested last year were somehow challenged or stressed?

Naturally, the volunteer tomatoes are where tom's were planted in the garden last year. :-)

Ev

Comments (12)

  • 11 years ago

    For (very specifically) GERMINATION, the three big factors are temperature, water, and... er, nothing else.

    If you put them in peat pots, what was the soil you put in there with them?

    If you meant peat pellets, and you watered enough to keep slightly damp 24/7 and only had them wet for a few minutes and never ever had them go totally dry, then it comes down to either cooking or chilling. Cooking is easily done with saran wrap and sunshine and it often leaves no evidence behind.

    All the above, of course, assumes no poisoning or super bad seed storage conditions. "Zero" is a big number in its own way.

    Since the soil is warm enough to foster tomato volunteers, is it too cool to plant out directly?

  • 11 years ago

    grubby, thanks for the response, however, I'm not asking "how," I'm asking if anyone else has noticed this happening?

  • 11 years ago

    exmar, besides the details that grubby offered, if the seeds came from different sources, I would think to ask yourself what may have changed with the conditions at your place.

    Do you have city water? Did they (as many municipalities must do from time to time) add extra chlorine to the water supply (it would probably have to be a lot, but things happen)? Perhaps the "peat pots' (I guess these are the little, expandable disks) you mention were contaminated with something? As grubby mentioned, if they were actual peat pots, perhaps your medium was contaminated?

    Do you use a heating pad? Maybe it failed?

    Anyway, I got seeds from Johnny's and other than a few things I could have done better with some, they all did fine. You sound like you know what your doing, I think it's ok to check to see if the companies had some 'bad' seeds, but in this case, since you did everything the same, I'm wondering if there wasn't a contamination issue with your supplies that was outside of your control.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Some seeds like large gourd seeds need to be notched before sowing...yes.


    Other seeds came up quickly for me...except Cooperstown seedless watermelon which have such a hard seed coat that they need notched too.

  • 11 years ago

    I haven't noticed a markedly different proportion of non-starters, but then I only germinate a few and they are from vastly different companies. I did notice they took longer to germinate than tomato & pepper seeds.
    I would call the seed companies as suggested and let them know you're getting some low germination rates. It's not likely, but it is possible that the seeds were harvested, processed, stored, or shipped in a way that could have damaged them.

    If that's a dead end, go through every step and piece of equipment of your "as usual" process and check for something different (different temps, brands of peat pots, soil, fertilizer, etc.) It wouldn't hurt to sterilize what you plan to reuse. Past that, chalk it up to a freak year and get some nursery plants to work with for this season.

    A note: when our municipal water provider switched over from river to ground water sources due to drought deficit, I noticed a big difference in the hardness of the water, and I suspect they added more chlorine and softeners to pretreat it. You don't mention where you are located, but could there be a chance something like that happened?

  • 11 years ago

    You could separate the possibility of defective or mistreated seeds from the possibility of poisoned planing mix by just soaking some of the seeds and see how many sprout. Reputable seed companies spot check germination rates in seeds they sell, so I'm thinking you have a problem at your end. That is, this isn't likely to be an oopsie from the supplier.


  • 11 years ago

    Exmar, I've had a similar experience this winter with two separate plantings done consecutively. (The second time I was super careful about everything). Very poor germination rate, although seeds were fresh, from different suppliers, and all environmental conditions were right. Same thing happened to someone I know - he had zero germination, as you did, although the seeds were fresh, procedure and environmental conditions, as he described them to me, sounded just right.

    I've been gardening for over 30 years, starting both commercial seeds and ones I'd collected myself, and have never had this problem before.

    After the second high failure rate, I started doing germination tests on the seeds and even pre-sprouting some so I could actually SEE what was going on there.


  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for all the responses. Since I live on a farm, guess I'll just say, "that's farming." I've experienced low germination rates before both garden and field crops, but never had "zero" when all "usual and appropriate" measures were taken. Hence, I thought I'd ask.

    Not interested in asking seed companies, I'm sure they'll immediately send me replacement seeds but it's getting too late for the hard shelled gourds.

    thanks again,

    Ev

  • 11 years ago

    I have had a hard time getting zucchini, cucumbers and melons to start growing this year too. But my problem is with the outside plantings. The seed has rotted. I have planted twice and with all the rain we have got, they rotted in the cool soggy soil. I punted and started over 1,000 in 50's and will have to transplant them all in a few weeks. They are growing very nicely in the high tunnel.

    Jay


  • 11 years ago

    BTW, I didn't mean peat pellets, personally don't like them, I use peat pots which you then fill with your personal choice of soil, has worked for years and gives a much bigger plant to set out, and you just bury the whole thing, less root disruption.. Here's a "generic" link.

    http://www.greenhousemegastore.com/product/jiffy-peat-pots/jiffy-peat-pots


    Ev