Software
Houzz Logo Print
rrstanny

River Birch Rot?

11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago

I wonder if anyone can advise on the sooty-black, mold-like stuff by the crotch of the 10-year-old river birch shown in the picture. You may be able to see some little white dots in the pinestraw to the left of and slightly below the crown. Those are little mushrooms. The tree's foliage looks ok.

We're located on the northern Gulf coast of Florida. This tree gets played on by a sprinkler, so I figure it's dampness related. I'd prefer not to lose the tree; however, it's close to the house and if it's doomed I'd as soon get it out of there and get started growing a replacement. A Swamp Tupelo or Bald Cypress might fill the bill--though I'm getting kind of old to be planting Tupelos. Naturally, I'd be happy to hear that it's nothing to worry about. River Birches do, after all, grow by rivers. Thanks.

Comments (13)

  • 11 years ago

    Distance diagnoses are hard, some kind of rot, likely some sort of collar rot, often not confined to that black part you see. That tree is as common as dirt in many places, make your plans for replacement.

  • 11 years ago

    at this distance.. i can say w/o doubt.. its a tree .. lol ...

    also post a pic of the whole ...

    a little weepage on a tree that flexes in the wind.. doesnt really bother me ... unless you are just looking for an excuse to get rid of it ...

    mushrooms in mulch.. also doesnt bother me ... its in the mulch ...

    if the premise is.. you are looking for ammo to use on a spouse ... because you want the tree gone.. yes.. i think its at deaths door ... lol ...

    if not.. i wouldnt worry about it.. lol

    how do we rule out sooty mold from honeydew .. anyone???

    ken


  • 11 years ago

    Here are closeup and whole-tree shots. There's a second birch in the background of the latter that contributes to the apparent fullness of the canopy, but the picture isn't especially misleading: The foliage is in very good shape.

    It was hard to get a good angle on the whole-tree shot as the area is a bit cramped.

    Those trunks definitely flex in the wind. And, no, I'm not looking for an excuse to cut it down. I like the tree.



  • 11 years ago

    It may be Armillaria Rot. If so, not good at all. If you don't get a confirmed answer here, you may be better off calling your local agriculture extension office. One thing I can tell you is it's a fungus.

    Dax


  • 11 years ago

    New to the River Birch on our lot, I took note of your post. I'm sorry for your tree's troubles. I did look up Armillaria rot, which seems to be white when bark is removed.

    http://www.plantpath.cornell.edu/Trees/Armillaria.html

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Looking at the trunk closeup of the birch in question, the black stuff almost looks superficial -- just sitting on the bark & not hurting anything. That's not an expert diagnosis, tho.

  • 11 years ago

    Can't tell much from info provided. In fact, this is very likely a case for a local expert, be they private consulting arborist, county extension hort. agent, etc. That of course assuming your state hasn't followed the lead of so many others in "reforming", er...eliminating these popular and helpful individuals from the payroll.

    +oM

  • 11 years ago

    to be clear ... the pic immediately above it NOT the tree we are talking about ... correct

    ken


  • 11 years ago

    Beng12, that's my prayer. Ken, yes the picture immediately above is not the tree in question. Gardener 365 & Wisconsitom, I agree about calling in a local expert. I'm going to to try to find someone in the area with good training who isn't in the tree-cutting business and who will come pay a visit. The University of Florida has traditionally run a fine program of local Horticulture/Ag centers. Wisconsitom, understand you: Florida has been a leader. Let's not rant.

  • 11 years ago

    Trust me, rs.....that ain't ranting, lol! That's me in my finest filtered forum voice!

    +oM

  • 11 years ago

    Official, University of Florida Extension opinion: Don't think there's anything to worry about. The black mold is probably wet wood or slime flux. There's nothing that can stop it. Should the tree begin to decline then take it down.


    I think I'll let that tip my opinion. The discussion here has been helpful, and I appreciate it.


    RS

  • 11 years ago

    Interesting....that slime flux infects birch. I did not know that. Then again, that's pretty far out of typical range for that or any other birch. I do see on the USDA Plants Database that river birch's range does indeed extend down into NW Florida, so maybe not so far off. But yeah, not much one can do about that bacterial pathogen. An odd one for sure, the pH (acidity/alkalinity) of slime flux is extremely high, literally burning away tree tissues as the disease progresses.

    +oM

  • 11 years ago

    Yes, we have river birch in Florida. You see them north and west of Waldo. Where, as the old Don Grooms song goes, the Orange Blossom Special don't stop anymore. ;-)