Software
Houzz Logo Print
bobbledee

Help with Nantes carrots

11 years ago

I've grown Nantes successfully for years. Sweetest, crispiest carrot I ever tasted. That was in Idaho. Moved to No. Calif and can't grow a good Nantes. Not sweet or crispy and doesn't look like one either. Has pointy end instead of blunt. Tried seed from 2 different companies. No difference. Anyone have a clue? We've had very hot spring and summer. I planted in Feb.

Comments (11)

  • 11 years ago

    Different soil and different ambient air and soil temps easily affect carrots. You'd likely need mush earlier planting times in No. Calif than in Idaho for example and I seriously doubt the soil composition are the same so it is sort of a comparing apples to oranges comparison.

    You may even need to change you planting methods.

    So it isn't the seed, it is the growing conditions. Warmer soil now, different soil tilth and texture, different planting time needed, likely even different water and nutrient needs.

    I have a relatively new neighbor who can't understand why he can't grow tomatoes and cabbage here in Arkansas like he did for decades in Northern Iowa. :)

    Dave

  • 11 years ago

    Could the difference be seasonal rainfall? How does do the two different locations compare with rain vs hand watering? Nothing beats rain for watering and plant growth, at least that's true here in my Va garden.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks, both of you, for your feedback. I have raised beds with lovely soil that has been great for my other crops. Drip irrigation. I agree with you, there is nothing better than rainfall for watering, but .. in No. Calif ??? Pretty skimpy. I'm focusing in on your comment about the planting times. That seems the likeliest difference. The most puzzling part of it is the difference in the characteristic shape of the Nantes. These look like a different breed. Anyway, thanks again for your responses.

  • 11 years ago

    <The most puzzling part of it is the difference in the characteristic shape of the Nantes.>

    Keep in mind that all carrot varieties are tap root plants o the shape you are getting now vs. the rounded tip is more common in my experience. The more that tap root has to go deep for water the more elongated it will be.

    Dave

  • 11 years ago

    Well now that's something I wouldn't have thought of. Perhaps with the drought I have not been watering as deep. The blunt end is so characteristic of Nantes that I have never seen one pointy in 15 or so years until my experience now. But what you say makes good sense, so thanks again for another helpful comment.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    it is also possible that the batch of seeds was packed wrong or not pure and is a different type. While uncommon Ive had it happen with several types of plants especially from a particular very well known brand(probably the most common company selling seeds). Where did you get your seeds from? Ive been migrating slowly toward smaller seed companies in leiu of the stuff you go get at the Farm Store or Walmart

  • 11 years ago

    fbx22: I tried 2 different seed companies, both small ones that sell non-GMO and lots of heirlooms. Bountiful Seeds is one; Territorial Seed is the other. There are many small companies that contract with local growers so they know them and their farming practices. (or so they say)

    n2xjk: Maybe I should try other varieties, but I sure hate to give up on the Nantes. In Idaho I planted in the fall, left it all winter under the snow and in the spring it was sweet and juicy. I know they are grown here in CA because I get them at a market that features local produce. Thought I'd try Danvers next. I'll look up Kuroda too. Sorry about the rabbits. Bummer !!!

  • 11 years ago

    About carrots under the snow... How much snow? Did you mulch them, or protect with paper, blanket Ect? How big we're they when snow fell?

  • 11 years ago

    Nantes are my favorite carrot also. I agree with fbx22....It might be a (lack of) quality control issue. I too also find that year to year the Nantes don't always produce the desired cylindrical shape. Last year I noted about 50% tapered. Hopefully this year will be better. I plant in September & begin harvesting in December.

  • 11 years ago

    qbush: It's been a long time since I gardened in Idaho so I'll tell you what I have in my notes and what I remember. I covered them with straw bales. My notes say they stored very well except for a few places where the water got through. So the next year I used straw bales and plastic. That must have worked because my notes indicate I left some in the ground each year for storage. I planted the end of July or early in August so the tops must have been fairly well developed. We got from 18 in to 3 ft. of snow. I hope this helps. I know it's not fresh info, but I remember spring harvest of some real crisp, juicy carrots. Good luck.

    grandad: So the plot thickens. Wonder what it is about the breeding that would cause such undependable results. Must be about genetics...and now I'm over my head. Thanks for your comment. That's very helpful.

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals