Software
Houzz Logo Print
jon_martin90

Kitchen Cabinet Help - ~$12,000 kitchen

11 years ago

Hello,

We are building a new home and have budgeted roughly $12,000 for the kitchen cabinets+countertop. This works out to roughly $7,000-8,000 to spend on cabinets. The kitchen is L shaped, 8' x 14' with an island.


So far we have been quoted for; JSI, Schrock Entra (upgraded to full extension, dove tail drawers), Medallion Silverline and American Woodmark. It seems that kitchencabinetreviews.com and rekitchen.com have overwhelming negative reviews on all of these companies lol (I am sure a lot of this is due to unhappy people reviewing, while the satisfied customers do not, but still concerning). Does anyone one here have any experience with these brands? The quotes are all fairly similar (within $1,000 for the cabinets). The American Woodmark has all plywood construction, and then some "free" upgrades such as trash pullout/rollout drawers, but we have some doubts about working with Home Depot on such a big part of our house. We have sort of ruled out the JSI since it is made in China and it seemed to be a step below the others in quality, but we really know nothing. Is one of these brands better than the others? Is there another brand in this price range we should be looking at?


Thanks in advance for any help!


Comments (12)

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Deborah! Looking at your profile, we love the Oak Holllow kitchen! Is there a brand I maybe didn't mention that you would recommend close to our price point?

  • 11 years ago

    I have 18 year old Medallion in my kitchen. The doors are solid wood and I just finished refinishing them. However, I wanted to change out a cabinet (microwave cabinet out and spice box / plate rail cabinet in) and found the newer doors were not solid wood on many styles - perhaps they have an upgraded line that does, but not that came close to my door style. I ended up retrofitting my old cabinet to what I wanted instead of buying a new one. I used a spice box from Shrock and was pleasantly surprised to find it was solid wood. I was also surprised on how hard it was to take apart the old cabinet - which I guess says something good about it:) The cabinet sides are particle board, which many will say is not as good as plywood. I would agree, but mine have held up fine.

    Jon Martin thanked jhmarie
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Of the semi-custom lines we like Shiloh and the options they provide, but they are a higher price point than you are looking for. The Schrock should be a good cabinet for you. It is not bottom of the line by any means and is a reasonable price point. They seem to do a pretty good job with their finishes.

    Thank you for the compliment on the Oak Hollow kitchen. Was a really fun project and is our Tour of Remodeled Homes entry this year. The cabinetry was mostly custom in this kitchen.

    Jon Martin thanked Brickwood Builders, Inc.
  • 11 years ago
    We installed Schrock a year and a half ago and have no complaints so far.
    Jon Martin thanked drbarb03
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks drbarb! Do you know if it was the Schrock Entra line or one of their higher end lines?The Entra's standard have a furniture board box (same as the Silverline Medallion, but the Medallion seem to be a bit thicker) and the dovetail drawers are also an upgrade in the Entra line (included in our pricing).

  • 11 years ago
    I can't recall seeing "Entra" listed anywhere but that doesn't mean anything. I have since decluttered catalogs and packing slips, it seems. We purchased through Menards. Our drawers definitely have dovetail joints. The sides are solid wood. They have soft close and fully extend.
    Jon Martin thanked drbarb03
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    The dovetail drawer is a nice feature that will allow it to hold up better. But general cabinet construction in this budget will make it tough to find a really great set of cabinets. But good counter tops could help!

    Jon Martin thanked Circle Goods Reclaimed
  • 11 years ago
    I'd be happy to post close-ups of features if that is helpful to you. Let me know what you need to see if that's the case.
    Jon Martin thanked drbarb03
  • 11 years ago

    That's ok, I appreciate the help!

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I still think in this price point the best cabinets are Ikea so that’s my 2 cents worth in.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Not to be sales pitchy but I wanted to offer you my services. Feel free to take a look at our site http://directcabinetexpress.com/ we have all wood cabinets with dovetail soft close drawers. I used to work for a big box store and I have priced similar kitchens and I can say confidently you will save hundreds to thousands looking into RTA (ready to assemble). We also offer free design services if you need it. Good luck with whoever you choose :)

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert