The vanity goes better. Looks like you have the makings of a Hollywood glam look. You need to find a good comforter with white and silver.

What are your needs - more storage with the dresser or do you need a vanity? Both will work and if you select the dresser, just add a great mirror above. Personally, I would go with the dresser due to storage - never can have enough. If you have room, a smaller vanity might do the trick along with the dresser.

Lake Geneva Lake House · More Info

Aliso Viejo · More Info

I have a big closet. I didn't know if the vanity was too reflective. The drawers o the vanity could store tops, and lingere for me. i like the white because its cheaper and had more storage, but i don't know if it would clash with the nightstands.

The vanity is glam like your bed and night stands. The dresser is country. Stick with glam. :D

Any other suggestions, please add pics. thanks!

I agree with nimrod25. They're two totally different styles. The dresser looks like what you'd see in a child's bedroom.

Here are a few dressers more in keeping with your style:

Antiqued Mirror Chest of Drawers · More Info

Hanson Hollywood Regency Smokey Grey Mirrored Dresser Nightstand · More Info

Hollywood Regency 9 Drawer Dresser · More Info

Of the two pics you want to know which best fits your existing style? The first pic is a NO CONTEST "Winner..." ;-D Everyone else has addressed storage issues etc. The other piece you show is "meh..." Don't forget to remove the plastic from your lamp shades! ;- ) All the Best!

I went to see the vanity in person and it scrathces easily. How about this dresser?

yes or no?

My Bedroom · More Info

My Bedroom · More Info

I like the style for your room. My concern is the space you want to put it in it too narrow. Mark it out on the floor with blue painters tape and see how it feels when you are making your bed.

Good luck!