Software
Houzz Logo Print
prbychanda

help selecting a rose w/specific criteria

11 years ago

Last night our 15yr old lab mix was put to rest. She was my oldest friend and a loyal companion and protector to me for nearly half of my life. She was a sweet girl and we will miss her dearly. In the spring we would like to plant a rose on her grave to honor her spirit. We would like a rose that blooms in a fall color ...orange yellow etc. Or later in the season. She was a sweetheart so we would like something that smells nice. Also she had a fierce strong spirit and was very protective of her people so some decent thorns are in order. And last of all, our good 'ol girl would've been a big dog if only her legs weren't so short. So a stout hardy plant would be preferred. we live in northeast ohio in zone 5. I know its specific but if anyone has any suggestions or helpful ideas I would be very grateful. Thanks


Comments (8)

  • 11 years ago

    I am so sorry for the loss of your dear girl.

    Here is a new thread on Morden Sunrise, it might be a rose that fits your needs.

  • 11 years ago

    I'm so sorry I just went thru the same with my 19 year old kitty. Oh how dear they are to us. My suggestion is Lemon Fizz.

  • 11 years ago

    I'm very sorry for you loss. I know how dear a treasured pet can be and what a terrible loss it is.

    I'm going to second Julia Child. It's been a very good rose for me. It's very winter hardy so should do well in Ohio and it has above average disease resistance so will be easy to care for also. It gets to be about 3 x 3 feet in size and blooms a lot with a very rapid repeat cycle. Basically I prune it once in the spring and then just keep it dead headed the rest of the season and not much else.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you all for the kind words and helpful suggestions. I will do a little research on these to see what will perform best in the soil & light conditions where shes burried in our backyard. Roses are a little intimidating to me...im more of a vegetable gardener, but my thumb is green. I need to be confident in the variety because ill feel guilty if it doesnt survive.

  • 11 years ago

    I'm so sorry for your loss, I lost my sweet yorkie of 15 years last year. It's heartbreaking. I am going to also suggest Julia Child. JC has been in my garden for 2 years now and has done very well despite some neglect on my part. I think it would be a easy no fuss choice for you to get started on your rose journey and it's a cheerful rose to look at and remind you of your beloved pupster. Good luck!

  • 11 years ago

    I am so sorry. Your girl sounds like she was a terrific dog. The saddest thing about dogs is that their lives are so much shorter than ours.

    I have used roses as a memorial for some much-loved pets, too. There are so many kinds of roses and they are so variable. What will do well for me in zone 7a Tennessee may not survive for you in zone 5 NE Ohio. I grew up in NE Ohio and well remember the long, bitter cold winters. Please keep in mind that while I may suggest some of these roses, I may not have grown them myself and did not grow them in Ohio. They are rated to survive a z5 winter but your microclimate may be colder or warmer than that and your special situation may not be suited to that rose for other reasons. For best results, check with someone local who may have grown it.

    Sweet Fragrance- a Ping Lim rose- While not all are exactly the same, Ping Lim roses were bred to be disease free and hardy, so things like fragrance took a back seat. Sweet Fragrance is a little different. It is a lovely coral/peach/ apricot color. It isn't my most fragrant rose but does have a nice fragrance. It is disease resistant for me but hasn't been a fast grower.

    The following three are Kordes (a German rose nursery) roses. Kordes and other European rose breeders are having to find roses with innate resistance to disease because spraying has been banned there. Many of these roses lack fragrance but there are exceptions. I don't grow any of these, although I grow several older Kordes roses that are tough as nails For pictures and a better knowledge of these roses, you might follow the ongoing discussion about rating the new Kordes roses.

    Folklore- I can't say much more than it's a two-tone rose with an unusual color combination, sort of a rose-coral and yellow. People who grow it have remarked on its fragrance.

    Summer Sun- Ditto the above, except more orange/reddish and yellow.

    South Africa- This is a rose that I've considered but it was never available by the time I ordered. It's sort of an apricot/golden color and so lovely. It does remind me of autumn. Fragrance is the icing on the cake.

    The last are Griffith Buck roses. Buck bred roses in the 80's that were able to stand up to an Iowa winter and still come back and bloom. They weren't tested nationwide for disease resistance. Disease resistance might be different in Ohio than in Iowa or here in TN. However, many have survived to come back and bloom beautifully. I have grown some but not all of these:

    Enchanted Autumn- I thought of this when you said that you wanted autumn colors. It is a blend of fall colors and also has a nice fragrance.

    Golden Unicorn- I loved this rose. Since it never had winter die-back for me it got a lot bigger than the official size of about 3'. Seemed to be especially tough and hardy. The roses would go past quickly but it bloomed a lot and put on its biggest and best show in the fall. Golden yellow with a touch of apricot, it becomes more and more apricot in cooler weather. Nice fragrance. Sadly, it succumbed to the rose rosette virus which can attack any rose.

    Honeysweet- This one is on my someday list. It's a lovely blend of rose, pink, coral and yellow that is difficult to photograph. It can black-spot some here but may not for you. It has a lovely fragrance.

    Prairie Sunrise- One of my very favorite roses of any kind. It is a blend of sunrise colors, as you might imagine- apricot, peach pink, yellow and orange. The flowers are full, cup-shaped and oh-so-fragrant. The plant is smallish here but tough and forgiving. It is capable of blooming and growing in spite of imperfect conditions.

    Winter Sunset- Another name for this rose is 'Fuzzy Navel'. It is a pretty golden apricot yellow with a nice fragrance. Also on my someday list.

    I don't spray my roses and don't know how they'd grow if I did. I can live with imperfect leaves now and then but not with sickly or difficult roses. Your standards might be different than mine.




  • 11 years ago

    I'm sorry about your dog. I've never lost a pet yet - so I don't know the pain. My eldest dog is 11. I think you have a great idea to plant a rose for your dog. I have no suggestions as I don't live in your zone (zone 3). But I wish you joy as you plant your chosen rose.

    CArol