Software
Houzz Logo Print
upstatedoor

POLL: Which do you prefer? Country or City?

10 years ago


Upstate Door Custom Exterior Doors · More Info

Upstate Door Custom Exterior Doors · More Info

Relaxed, Breezy, Fresh - Country!
Formal, Luxurious, Established - City!

Comments (117)

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Wow! We are amazed and awed by the thoughtful and personal responses we've received on our poll! Wherever you call "home", thanks for sharing the meaningful stories and photos from the country, city and suburbs!

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    More space, more air! Country all the way.

    Upstate Door thanked Fletcher Cameron Kitchens
  • 10 years ago

    I live in rural Aotearoa / New Zealand & absolutely love it. Our closest town is just over 32kms away, with a population of 3000 & all the amenities we need. Definitely country for me :)

    Upstate Door thanked alangelamaiart
  • 10 years ago

    Does it really need to be one or the other? How about what some other countries consider a norm like every single home having extensive vegetable and fruit gardens on the whole of their homes landscape? What would you consider that? That's not your typical American burb to be sure. I think THAT is what we all ought to be aspiring to: containing our gutter drainage to use in gardens. Then living in a Burb is more convenient than living farther out in the country and it would be pleasant as well because people wouldn't be hiding away. Your neighbors would be out there working in their yards and maybe stopping to have a cool drink on a front porch or stoop. Ordinances need to change and quickly to accommodate much needed changes.

    Upstate Door thanked rricciman
  • 10 years ago

    I voted country, but if the address were rue Montorgueil, 2e
    Arrondissement, Paris, I would definitely go city.

    Upstate Door thanked susanaikman
  • 10 years ago
    When they look like that...both of course!! It would be too hard to make a decision on either end one...I'm torn.
    Upstate Door thanked Annette Byrdy
  • 10 years ago

    I live in a town with 30,000 people. It's 20 minutes to Niagara Falls, Ontario, 15 minutes to the U.S. and less than 2hrs to Toronto. The interesting thing is that the majority of people who move here to retire are from Toronto and the large cities surrounding Toronto. So the city lovers change as they age I guess. At some point the small town atmosphere, the beautiful beaches along Lake Erie, the knowledge that you can walk out at night alone safely is what they are searching for in their golden years and if they need a city fix it's not too far away.

    Upstate Door thanked layne66
  • 10 years ago
    Country..... My idea of vacation is to slap on a backpack and get back away from roads and civilization about 30 miles. No city getaways for this girl.
    Upstate Door thanked 2lacoop
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I love living in the country with animals, a garden and beautiful sunrises and sunsets. It's the only place I can sleep well, since there's no light or noise pollution (if you don't mind crickets and frogs). However, I live close enough to a city that I can have a date at a restaurant with my husband, get a haircut, or shop if I want to! This picture is of a lamb we bottle fed, standing on the porch with my lavender and rosemary plants.

    Upstate Door thanked teanhny
  • 10 years ago
    Neither or both. In between. Town of White Bear Lake. Close to the city and close to the country. Not the burbs, but a outer ring from the city. The best of both!
    Upstate Door thanked Gloria H.
  • 10 years ago

    live in the country, visit the city

    Upstate Door thanked Tannachton Farm
  • 10 years ago

    In between for me, too! 15 minutes from the city, 15 minutes to the country in--gasp--the suburbs! I'm happy in the suburbs as long as my neighborhood has LOTS of mature trees, the houses all look different, and I don't have a postage stamp sized lot.

    Upstate Door thanked angelkins7
  • 10 years ago

    Nothing sophisticated and elegant about my "city" house. But..."New York is where I'd rather stay, I get allergic smelling hay". Although my dream home is a huge farm where I can take in all the abused and abandoned dogs and cats, etc. So, I want to be both city and country.

    Upstate Door thanked buster57
  • 10 years ago
    I lived in a city condo with a dog for 3-1/2 months. I need space and dirt to dig in.
    Upstate Door thanked Donna
  • 10 years ago

    Although the 'sound' of country living is VERY appealing... and I've tried it twice, it REALLY didn't work for me. We found it much more work and wherever we wanted to go it was a much longer drive. So, the money 'saved' living rural was eaten up in gas & car maintenance. I personally felt isolated. Back to 'city' living again... not a super large city, Spokane, WA... and I LOVE it!!

    Upstate Door thanked Leigh Bligh
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I suppose it also depends on your definition of city and country. Folk who were born and raised in majors cities Toronto, New York etc would think I live in the country or that somewhere where you have a lawn to mow and no retail establishments within a feet of their front doors is country. And Folks who live on hundreds of acres with miles between neighbours would call me city folk because there is a Timmies (Tim Hortons down the road and a grocery store less than a mile away. Its all perception I guess. I like the idea of the conveniences of a city but NOT actually living in one.

    Upstate Door thanked layne66
  • 10 years ago

    After living in big cities and dense suburban communities most of my life, last year we purchased a home in a rural area outside a small town. It was the best move we ever made. The small town is close for essentials shopping while a large city is half an hour away. The tranquility and beauty of country living is to our liking and we will stay here a long time..... perhaps forever.
    We have deer, raccoon, squirrels, rabbits, possum and huge oaks and pines with many flowering shrubs on a large lot. The beauty of the cultivated plants evolve smoothly into the natural wooded area which encompasses a great deal of our property. A gorgeous river from


    natural springs flows about a mile away. I will go to the big city for dinner and the theater but I am so glad to come home to this paradise.

    Upstate Door thanked nancyburridge
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I love variety and thought that both looks were great and nicely done!

    Upstate Door thanked Laurie McDowell Interior Design
  • 10 years ago

    I lovvvvvvvvvve city lights but the land and all it's greenery is where my heart is.

    Upstate Door thanked Melody Drinkwater Wagner
  • 10 years ago

    I've thought about this for years. It has changed with my age. And I think it depends on the city, depends on the country, and the latter certainly depends on the climate/season. Over the years I have had country gardens amid open lawns, a village cottage garden, now a walled garden in a desert city. I think I could learn to be happy downsized to just a little urban balcony, provided there is room for two chairs, some potted plants and herbs, to say nothing of a good book or a good friend, and a nice bottle of wine.

    Thanks everyone for sharing your fascinating incites and enticing pictures!

    Upstate Door thanked tfswest
  • 10 years ago

    Love where I live, country, with Kansas City within 30 min. drive if I want City, and great shopping within 15 minutes from home for everyday shopping.

    Upstate Door thanked jmslezak
  • 10 years ago


    My beautiful rural back yard any day over city life!

    Upstate Door thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    I was raised a half mile down the road. This is technically 'farm country,' but we do live in town, a very small town. Most houses in this small town have about an acre of land and there are several ponds, so it seems very country. The school systems are one high school districts, and we have a 'sheriff' rather than a police force.

    There's a creek behind us and a corn field across the road.

    I have found the biggest problem around here is some of the people who move out here. Not all of course, but the others I call 'city people.' Moving out here they think we have no laws, the biggest being the dog laws.

    I have heard several racist comments from people who moved into the town and I pointed out that just because there are no African American families in our school district, that does NOT mean we tolerate such statements. When her husband told me another, I was so glad they moved.

    My Dad grew up about 2 miles away, on a farm, so the country genes are old. I married a city boy, but he has adjusted well

    There are times when I leave the house every 2 weeks or so, and am very happy. I started a yard that is basically based on a cottage garden, why, whatever would it do without me deadheading every day?

    I have 3 blue spruces, that each of my kids brought home as 10" seedlings, when their 5th grade class visited the county conservation 'farm.' My oldest is now 31. Only in the country would that happen.

    That reminds me of a country story:

    I was having a garage sale (the last day it rained the year of the drought, the last garage sale I ever had) and 2 ladies stopped. They seemed to be in their 80's and their dress was 'prim and proper' There was no one else at the sale at the time, so, we chatted. (while they were shooting baskets at the hoop we had in the driveway)

    They went through the flowers in the side yard, we chatted, and they asked if they could see the back. Sure! What a wonderful visit it was, the highlight seeing them skip down a stone path, singing the song they sang as they skipped in the garden as children, in ENGLAND! They were sisters.

    I regret never getting their names, but treasure the memory.

    I love living in the country

    Upstate Door thanked mom3333
  • 10 years ago

    I love being able to see the stars at night, to buy fresh produce from the neighbor's farms, listen to real quiet, all things you can do in the country. when I need to be in the city, I can go there in an hour, do my business and come home to peace and quiet. Love the country!!!!

    Upstate Door thanked fatsia
  • 10 years ago

    I don't want big city living, but suburbia would suit me fine :) I am not a way out in the country type of girl either.

    Upstate Door thanked Kim Sheldon_Rothe
  • 10 years ago

    I split my time between a small cottage across from a small lake and 3 blocks from the beach and a home 10 minutes outside of NYC. It's a wonderful balance.

    Upstate Door thanked Paul Marzolla
  • 10 years ago

    City. Small house,small lot. Always have the best house on the block! Can always visit the country-smell the smells, take some photos, stop and talk with folks, get some cuttings or clippings, make a friend-then go home to my "shangrala"", spend 10 minutes cutting the grass, sit back and watch the people stare at the beauty growing in the city.

    Upstate Door thanked thazit78
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Thanks everyone for your inspiring comments and for sharing your own wonderful homes with all of us! City, Country or Suburb - there's no place like home.


  • 10 years ago

    I'm a city girl I inside and out!

    Upstate Door thanked Ava Williams
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Live in the city and live a full life! I grew up in the country and tried living in the country, and realized that "life was just passing me by." There are rewards to both lifetstyles, but I have chosen to live near the city.

    Upstate Door thanked T.J.'s Painting & Renovations Co.
  • 10 years ago

    Are we talking decorating or location? For location I prefer the country. In decorating I like a little of both.

    Upstate Door thanked gmicute
  • 10 years ago
    I grew up in the country and still live in the country. My husband and I actually built a home from a severed lot on my Dad's farm. (Which, unfortunately had been sold awhile back and everything torn down) We did live in the city for a bit when I was still home and then when I first got married....the city or even going into town is where you go to get supplies or visit friends, so cities are necessary....but I could only live in the country. I'm a country girl!
  • 10 years ago
    ....here is an aerial photo
    Upstate Door thanked peaceandmorepeace
  • 10 years ago

    oh, tough - both sides have their beauty! I am a city freak loving most of its beats and colours, yet dreaming about a cute mansion in the country side with a big garden and horse stud-farm!

    Voted for city though

    Upstate Door thanked Inese Murniece
  • 10 years ago
    Me gusta el estilo country, es campestre, fresco y tranquilo
    Upstate Door thanked mauren4459
  • 10 years ago

    I couldn't vote because I love BOTH! I can go into both country or city mode easily. They both have their pro's & con's. In the city = Culture & convenient shopping, also traffic & smog. In the country =Fresh air & peace & serenity, but bears with big teeth walking through yard & eating at your garbage cans.

    Upstate Door thanked artsyphartsy_home_maker
  • 10 years ago

    How about country living in the city? I found a perfect 1.25 acre lot in the city with mature pines. I'm Lovin it :)

    Upstate Door thanked Erin Zacherl
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I loved our country life in the mountains of Montana. It was so quiet I could hear the whoosh of a bird's wings as they flew overhead and never got tired of seeing a bear or moose walk by the window.

    Upstate Door thanked pambrown
  • 10 years ago

    I love living in the country. Watching wildlife and listening to birds is so nice. As well as the solitude.



    Upstate Door thanked Norma
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    How beautiful, Norma. We can see why you chose country!

  • 10 years ago

    I was born a farmers daughter. After I married though we moved around to a few different towns but I'm so happy now to be in the country. No nosey neighbors just coyotes, skunks, racoons, deer and lots of mosquitos in the summer.

    Upstate Door thanked Norma
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Country - amazing beautiful, healthy, fresh, no noise like in the city. It's the best place to live and grow kids!

    Upstate Door thanked Valter and Anna fon Eynik
  • 10 years ago

    My favorite living area is the suburbs since you are not in the city but not way out in the country!

    Upstate Door thanked Bev
  • 10 years ago

  • 10 years ago

    I like either one, for different reasons.

  • 5 years ago

    Country life suits me best. I lived in Chicago for 25 years and while I enjoyed living in the city, I really found my love of gardening when we moved out to the suburbs.


  • 5 years ago

    I love living in a fairly remote small town, but prefer to live in the town rather than further out. It's the best of both worlds in a way, to have little traffic and a close-knit community, plus easy access to vast wilderness, and be able to walk or ride your bike to run errands or go to the coffee shop or brewery.

  • 5 years ago

    I say both the city and the country are good. I've lived in both environments.

    And it really varies.

  • 5 years ago

    Burbs.

  • 5 years ago

    On boy...that’s a tough one but realistically I think the country...knowing what the city is like and all its wonders, I am older now and prefer the sounds of nature and the feel of it in doing gardening! The small wonders of the country is better for me now! Ideally to have an apt. In the city ..........to go back and forth! 👍

Sponsored
High Point Cabinets
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars21 Reviews
Columbus' Experienced Custom Cabinet Builder | 4x Best of Houzz Winner