So let me start by saying I like the Avila better, but based on several factors my suggestion is to go with the Aragon.

1. If your cabinets are white and the counter is similar to that in the picture, I think the Aragon will bring out the warmer tones. I think the Avila would looked washed out and bland with that counter top.

2. Same goes with the rest of the living room/dining room. A lot of your features (i.e. fireplace fascia, wall colouring etc.) are cool - I think the Avila would add to that coolness. The Aragon would really add a warmth and coziness to the space.

3. And lastly, the slight grey tone to the Avila is in right now but I think the Aragon is a more classic finish and would never lose appeal (think resale down the road).

I should be a professional ;)

I think either one would be great. I like both.